6 ms·
Musing: The deeper question that Rich Hickey does not seem to have addressed is whether a 1 to 1 mapping between 'reality' and 'systemic models' is in fact gen
by eternalban 14y ago
Musing:
The deeper question that Rich Hickey does not seem to have addressed is whether a 1 to 1 mapping between 'reality' and 'systemic models' is in fact generally beneficial.
Right now, the focus is on "productivity" e.g. producer (read: programmer) concerns and creating a practical model of concurrency that is accessible to the general programming workforce, but there are other concerns that reach into very unlikely areas of (overall social) concerns e.g. energy use, that are affected by this decision to focus on reducing programmer pain (instead of minimizing use of resources, for example).
An alternative future for the field is a future where a very select subset of "programmers" are tasked with building systems according to a semantic model that is not an analog of the "real world", or perhaps a deeper mapping of "real world" that is closer to quantum reality (e.g. probable states of things) than a classical world view, and such professionals will get compensated for their (strange) comprehension of reality given that it may save businesses using their systems money. Such systems will certainly manifest in their outer layers models that map to "real world" e.g. a banking interface and attendant "real world issues" such as "when did this thing change?" and that is why MVCC was invented and we may well discuss "immutability", "state" and "identity", but may entirely do away with such (possibly) quixotic efforts in the innards of the system.