3 ms·
"Really? I'd expect pg himself, at least, to upvote a comment that gets him to think." Perhaps a better general version is, "Criticize the content of a commen
by jamesbritt 18y ago
"Really? I'd expect pg himself, at least, to upvote a comment that gets him to think."
Perhaps a better general version is, "Criticize the content of a comment, not the writer or their style."
'A kind of comment I would like to see more of, a kind I have posted but don't get a lot of upvotes from, is asking a question along the lines of "How could we find out more about the facts of this issue?" or "What is the significance of this statement and its importance?" '
From time to time I like to ask how someone happens to know whatever it is they are claiming. It does not seem tot be a popular question, though.
- trapper 18y agoAgreed. I come from a medical background and we have to back everything with evidence. Even though it's computer science, most opinions of software guys tend to be backed up by blog posts or group think unfortunately. I am not sure how many people even read citeseer! Case in point: has there been any research touting the effectiveness of agile methods? What effect does pair programming have on productivity? Most opinions on the subject I have ever read haven't even looked, they just use anecdote and groupthink as their evidence. It's like listening to supplement pushers.
- tokenadult 18y ago"From time to time I like to ask how someone happens to know whatever it is they are claiming. It does not seem tot be a popular question, though." Feel free to ask me that any time. I hope I notice your comments and upvote them when you do that.