3 ms·
This says it's an abridged translation. I wonder what the original was called; "Assayer" is an English word, and Galileo would have been writing in Italian or
by kragen 2y ago
This says it's an abridged translation. I wonder what the original was called; "Assayer" is an English word, and Galileo would have been writing in Italian or Latin, neither of which I think would pose much difficulty in reading.
Il Saggiatore, apparently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Assayer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Assayer.
> The Assayer (Italian: Il Saggiatore) is a book by Galileo Galilei, published in Rome in October 1623. It is generally considered to be one of the pioneering works of the scientific method, first broaching the idea that the book of nature is to be read with mathematical tools rather than those of scholastic philosophy, as generally held at the time. Despite the retroactive acclaim given to Galileo's theory of knowledge, the empirical claims he made in the book—that comets are sublunary and their observed properties the product of optical phenomena—were incorrect.[1]
Original text, printed in 01623, in Italian, at https://archive.org/details/ilsaggiatorenelq00gali https://archive.org/details/ilsaggiatorenelq00gali, at least until the Archive is destroyed. (Pirate your PDFs while they're hot!) There are some other scans, but they are much inferior. The scanner comments, "First issue, second state. Without the poems by Johann Faber and Francesco Stelluti in praise of Galileo." This was scanned just three months ago from the collection of the University of Toronto. It's 250 pages, so this 56-page abridged translation is very abridged indeed.
The first sentence from the abridged translation is found on the 11th page, after the dedication to the new Pope:
> Io non hò mai potuto intendere Illuſtriſſimo Sig. onde ſia nato, che tutto quello; che de’miei ſtudi, per aggradire, ò feruire altrui, m'è convenuto metter’in publico; abbia incontrato in molti una certa animoſità in detrarre, defraudare, e vilipendere quel poco di pregio che,ſe non per l’opera, almeno per l’intenzion mia m’era creduto di meritare.
Italian has evidently changed a lot less than English since 01623, because Google Translate renders this as follows, which seems almost entirely in agreement with Drake's translation:
> I have never been able to understand, Most Illustrious Sir, where it came from, that all that I have had to make public of my studies, to please or hurt others, has encountered in many a certain animosity in detracting, defrauding, and vilifying that little bit of respect that, if not for the work, at least for my intention, I believed I deserved.
Where it differs, I'm a little bit puzzled as to why Drake chose the translation he did—aggradire seems clearly to be "hurt" (the English cognate is "aggress", or current Spanish agredir) rather than "please", as Drake renders it.
- sebtron 2y agoI believe aggradire is an archaic form for aggradare, "to please". Gradire also means "to enjoy". The Italian word for "to aggress" is aggredire. Having studied both Italian and English literature in high school, I can confirm that 17th century Italian is more understandable for a native speaker than 17th century English is. But I am naturally biased because I am a native Italian speaker.
- kragen 2y agoThank you for the correction! So, unsurprisingly, Drake is correct, and my Spanish-based intuition was wrong, as was Google Translate. ("Please" makes more sense in context, too.) In Spanish we have agradecido, "grateful", which I suppose must be cognate, though the underlying verb agradecer is not in my Spanish-as-second-language vocabulary. https://dle.rae.es/agradecer https://dle.rae.es/agradecer
- kragen 2y agoOops. "Feruire" should be "ſervire". Reading the long S as an F is a common OCR error which I corrected in the other cases where it occurred. U and V were not yet separate letters, just medial and initial lowercase forms of the same letter, so I've tried to choose the right modern letter in each case.