4 ms·
The Therapist in the Machine
- WorkerBee28474 2y agoI think that LLMs are therapists are here to stay, simply because there's so much demand at a price point too low for a human therapist. I wonder if we'll discover that much of therapy's benefit is from having another human actually spare their time and attention, showing that they care, which will not be reproduced by ML.
- hackit2 2y agoThe main benefit of a therapist is they give you the vocabulary to express a emotional state or thought process. Once you have the vocabulary to communicate your emotions then it will helps alleviate or eliminate the Cognitive dissonance.
- jprete 2y agoThere are many benefits to a therapist. Understanding a problem is not the same as solving it, and many problems are not cognitive dissonances.
- hackit2 2y agoMost of the problem isn't the problem people are trying to solve. It is more about injecting a better mental model and then re-framing it from another perspective, that is the problem but it isn't the problem people think they have.
- ElevenLathe 2y agoI don't think the science supports any psuedotheories like this. All talk therapy is approximately equally effective, suggesting that it's the act of sitting down and talking that provides the benefits rather than the specific content of the therapy or intent of the therapist.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoYep. My wife is a person centered counsellor. The core of this approach is that the therapist is not the expert in the client, and provides no direction to the client. They just provide a space for the client to explore their issues. Other modalities can be much more directive to the client, but are equally effective. Some may work better for different people, but not for all of them.
- hsuduebc2 2y agoIt's cheap solution for some problems but most importantly is widely available. I would say it is better than let small problems became more severe. It can't replace human connection of course but it can just talk with you. And that is Always better than nothing.
- from-nibly 2y agoTalking is not always better than nothing.
- hackit2 2y agoLLM's are a chicken and egg problem. That is to say that unless you have the corpus of terms or vocabulary of the domain then you're going to get very generic, boiler plate responses out of the model. It is a big reason why experts can leverage LLM's better than your average person off the street because they can use the lexical terms that is specific to that domain.
- sdwr 2y agoLLMs are a stone soup problem. They are only worth talking to if you believe they have something valuable to say.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoSomeone talking to a "yes, and" dialogue tree about intrusive thoughts is a recipe for obsessive behavior. Therapists are trained to recognize when someone is using therapy to exercise (and therefore strengthen, "outlet theory" is thoroughly debunked) a dangerous paraphilia, which can often be subtle. Oh and is an LLM a mandated reporter? It's absolutely not the case that "talking" in the sense you mean is always better than nothing.
- clown_strike 2y agoYou make some good points. Not convinced LLMs should be mandatory reporters. However well intentioned that initiative is a torrent of nonsense foisted on overworked social workers, like the automatic 911 dialers in phones. > Someone talking to a "yes, and" dialogue tree about intrusive thoughts is a recipe for obsessive behavior Works both ways though. Nothing is more infuriating than an LLM denying or minimizing your problem, or using logical fallacies to shut the conversation down. This is pretty common with cults; the layers of euphemism and abstraction they use make you sound insane when you try to articulate abuse to authorities (or an LLM in this case). I use the word cult deliberately; if your issue involves certain topics, you encounter a layer finetuned for positive PR. > {{user}}: "You have to help me, they're going to make me...eat cake. I wont survive if I have to go through it again." > {{char}}: There is nothing wrong with cake. While being forcibly fed is troublesome, it is important to remember that obsessively monitoring your caloric intake is unhealthy. Eating cake must always be consensual and explored in moderation
- matrix87 2y ago> AI is meant to fill treatment gaps, whether their causes are financial, geographic, or societal. But the very people who fall into these gaps are the ones who tend to need more complex care, which AI cannot provide. Do the people who propose this type of thing realize how insulting it sounds? It's like saying to people "you're too poor for us to give a shit, here go talk to a rock for a little while, but pls let us record it so we can sell it to data brokers" It just sounds like ragebait designed to get laypeople to hate the tech industry
- hackit2 2y ago> "you're too poor for us to give a shit" That is kind of the point that is part of the healing process is to understand to be your own judge of your own life and make changes to benefit you.
- spoonfeeder006 2y agoIf that was all there was to it then why do white people in the USA have 10x as much wealth as black people? Are you saying that white people are 10x better at going on the healing process, being their own judge, and making changes that benefit them?
- tivert 2y ago> It's like saying to people "you're too poor for us to give a shit, here go talk to a rock for a little while, but pls let us record it so we can sell it to data brokers" > It just sounds like ragebait designed to get laypeople to hate the tech industry It's saying the quiet part loud.
- Kiboneu 2y agoI don’t think it would take this article to get (in your words) “laypeople” to hate the tech industry.
- dogleash 2y ago>It just sounds like ragebait designed to get laypeople to hate the tech industry Why? The sentiment of "you're on your own, go talk to a wall and figure yourself out" is about par for the course regarding society's collective attitude towards mental health. What support is shown in society for metal health is all feel-good shit for normies so they don't notice how goddamn bleak it looks from the side of someone who isn't confident they're able to hold it together.
- voisin 2y agoAnyone have experience with AI therapy that can weigh in on the value? Is it effective? I’ve never done therapy. Mainly because everyone I know who has spoken about it seems to go through an exhausting search for years of finding a good match, and it seems to take months of visits before the assessment can be made.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoYes, very weird timing - I test-drove a GPT I personalized for talk therapy purposes just an hour ago. I cried 10 mins into testing it so there was some kind of release, and have something I can try in the real world that might help me. I have a two month gap in therapy while my therapist is on maternity leave and while I have a real life standby in case I need it, I decided to cobble together my own chatbot therapist to see how it would go. I'm mostly familiar with CBT, having read Beck's Second Edition[1], some of Eugene Gendlin work on listening. Supplying it with my favorite resources on reflective listening[2], cognitive distortions, and cognitive restructuring material, and basic framing ie: "Tell me about your week," it was deceptively simple to get off the ground. There's one hurdle that I foresee - I have to be self-accountable and actually participate. I already have a habit of attending therapy once a week for one hour, but we'll see. It does change the accountability dynamic. 1. Beck, Judith. 2011. Cognitive Behavior Therapy, Second Edition: Basics and Beyond 2. https://www.maxwell.syr.edu/docs/default-source/ektron-files/reflective-listening-neil-katz-and-kevin-mcnulty.pdf?sfvrsn=f1fa6672_7 https://www.maxwell.syr.edu/docs/default-source/ektron-files...
- hackit2 2y agoReflective Listening can be a slippery slope to hell. Yes people will love trauma dumping all their inner most unresolved issues onto you but it doesn't help you develop mature mutual reciprocal relationships with people. Unless you like being a empathetic listening ear to peoples problems and being deferential to their wants, need, or desire instead of your own.
- kelseyfrog 2y ago>Unless you like being a empathetic listening ear to peoples problems and being deferential to their wants, need, or desire instead of your own. So like a therapist?