2 ms·
It seems like that is very relevant information that was not considered by the court. If this was a cryptographic hash I would say with high confidence that th
by bluGill 2y ago
It seems like that is very relevant information that was not considered by the court. If this was a cryptographic hash I would say with high confidence that this is the same image and so Google examined it - there is a small chance that some unrelated file (which might not even be a picture) matches but odds are the universe will end before that happens and so the courts can consider it the same image for search purposes. However because there are many false positive cases there is reasonable odds that the image is legal and so a higher standard for search is needed - a warrant.
- wonnage 2y agoThat's the exact conclusion that was reached - the search required a warrant.
- bluGill 2y agothe court implied even a hash without collisions would not count when it should.
- nullc 2y agoIt shouldn't. Google hasn't otherwise seen the image, so the employee couldn't have witnessed a crime. There are reportedly many perfectly legal images that end up in these almost perfectly unaccountable databases.
- cge 2y ago>so the courts can consider it the same image for search purposes An important part of the ruling seems to be that neither Google nor the police had the original image or any information about it, so the police viewing the image gave them more information than Google matching the hash gave Google: for example, consider how the suspect being in the image would have changed the case, or what might happen if the image turned out not to be CSAM, but showed the suspect storing drugs somewhere, or was even, somehow, something entirely legal but embarrassing to the suspect. This isn't changed by the type of hash.