12 ms·
Things I like about programming in Go
- phasevar 14y agoI've been a Python developer for a decade. Go is the first language to successfully pull me away from Python. I've been developing in it for almost a year now and for every reason this blog post points out, I'm in love with it.
- xaa 14y agoHow has the library situation been? As a fellow Python developer, I'm very spoiled on libraries and every time I've looked at go, it doesn't seem to be gaining traction in that area. The page full of go libraries the OP points to is laughably small -- even Haskell does better. The core language though seems quite nice. Although it looks to not support OpenMP, which is a shame. EDIT: I understand that Go is young and thus can't match up directly with Python/Java/Perl/C in sheer number of libraries. I'm more concerned with the rate of change of language adoption and new library creation, which doesn't seem to be large. But, the enthusiasm in this thread is quite encouraging.
- phasevar 14y agoBeing a new language it can't compete on the number of libraries. However, it does cover the ones I need the most for writing network servers. JSON, Websockets, Databases, SMTP, etc.. If I need to integrate features into a server that are more easily done in Python, I'll just launch a Python process from Go and communicate with it over pipes to get the functionality I need.
- luriel 14y agoCan you be more specific regarding what libraries you need/miss?
- xaa 14y agoMachine learning, natural language processing, linear algebra. Extra points for bioinformatics-related stuff. These are things that, obviously, aren't going to be on the top of a core dev team's priority list. They will come with time. But I can't do without them.
- luriel 14y agoThere are already libraries to do some of those things. There are for example several linear algebra libraries like gomatrix: http://code.google.com/p/gomatrix/ http://code.google.com/p/gomatrix/ I don't know so much about bioinformatics, but I know some folks are using Go in that field without too much problem. Of course, the more specialized your needs, the greater the chances you might have to roll your own. But given that Go 1 has hardly a few months old, this is not very surprising.
- taliesinb 14y agoI'm working on a Restricted Boltzmann Machine learner for Go. (https://github.com/taliesinb/gorbm https://github.com/taliesinb/gorbm). It is very early days (0.083 days to be exact) but I intend to support Hinton-style "deep learning" within the next few days. I have a feeling that Go's concurrency features will make it a good fit for various ML workloads. And it's a rare combination of expressive and metal-close, which is good fit for prototyping crunchy algorithms.
- objclxt 14y agoActually, yes! I picked up Go this week, and I'm actually really enjoying it. I did, however, hit a slight stumbling block because I needed to cryptographically sign some files to the PKCS#7 standard. The 'usual suspects' have library support for this (Ruby, PHP, etc etc): Go does not (so I invoke openssl from within Go instead). Putting that aside, it is a great language and one I'm really enjoying using. I primarily work in Objective-C, so it makes a nice change!
- luriel 14y agoI suspect the 'usual suspects' just wrap OpenSSL, you can use Go bindings for OpenSSL too, but I'm also sure Adam Langley, who is responsible for the Go crypto lib and the main crypto guru for Chrome will be happy to help get any bits that you are currently missing into the go.crypto repo. Hell, Go even has an official ssh library, I don't think any of the 'sual suspects' has that ;) http://go.pkgdoc.org/code.google.com/p/go.crypto/ssh http://go.pkgdoc.org/code.google.com/p/go.crypto/ssh
- thrownaway2424 14y agoTen years ago I was saying the same thing about Python with respect to Perl. Sure, it had some nice language features, but the libraries were a little spares. Now look at the Python libraries today. Go's libraries are, IMHO, very thin right now. Just of the things I've recently looked for, there's no TLS v1.2, no XML parsing of any sensible variety, and the SMTP library is a sad joke. But I'm still using Go daily. And guess what? It's also fun to get to write the libraries.
- enneff 14y agoWhat does Go's encoding/xml package (http://golang.org/pkg/encoding/xml/ http://golang.org/pkg/encoding/xml/) not do for you?
- georgemcbay 14y agoGo is a new language (while it was developed in public, release 1 was just months ago) so of course the library situation is less well defined than in older languages. On the positive side, the standard libraries are very consistent, the good 3rd party libraries tend to follow the conventions of the standard libraries (lots of decisions made in the language and tooling make it easier to do things the Go way than to treat it like it is another language) and if you really need some large chunk of functionality that Go doesn't provide and you don't have the time or willingness to make a pure Go version, you can easily pull C libraries in via cgo.
- kisielk 14y agoI'm basically in the same situation though I've been programming with Go for under 6 months now. A few features that have really begun to draw me away from Python: * A step away from object-oriented programming while still providing a way to associate functions with types via methods. I've been tending towards a more functional style in Python lately with functions and simple types instead of heavy OO code. * Static instead of dynamic typing. I find that I rarely actually benefit much from the dynamic typing features in Python and they can often be a source of bugs. A couple of things I still find myself missing regularly: * A full-featured unit testing library like Python's unittest * A simple interface for defining rich command-line argument parsers like Python's argparse
- genbattle 14y agoHave you looked into using the built-in testing[1] library for unit tests; it seems very full-featured to me. In Go the flag[2] package contains the command-line argument parsing functionality. Is it that you didn't know about these libraries, or that they don't meet your requirements? If the latter, what do you require from each of them that they do not already deliver? [1] http://golang.org/pkg/testing/ http://golang.org/pkg/testing/ [2] http://golang.org/pkg/flag/ http://golang.org/pkg/flag/
- kisielk 14y agoI have used (and continue to use) both of these libraries. The testing library works fine but it doesn't include much other than the bare minimum. A more batteries-included library could include some assertion methods to test for value equality/inequality and provide some pre-canned error messages. As for the flag package, it's fine for simple command-line flags but doesn't have anything to deal with specifying positional arguments. Sure you can get them from the Args() method but you have to basically write another layer of argument handling to deal with them. I like Python's argparse module's approach and flexibility there.
- mdwrigh2 14y ago> A more batteries-included library could include some assertion methods to test for value equality/inequality and provide some pre-canned error messages. For value equality, just use reflect.DeepEqual[1]. The wiki also has a page on table driven tests, which is worth a read[2]. [1]: http://golang.org/pkg/reflect/#DeepEqual http://golang.org/pkg/reflect/#DeepEqual [2]: http://code.google.com/p/go-wiki/wiki/TableDrivenTests http://code.google.com/p/go-wiki/wiki/TableDrivenTests
- mamcx 14y agoAnd the sad thing is that have the same syntax obscurity derived of C. Is still not readable (like python or pascal), lack the fast-coding/reading and a lot of things that make python the most fun/readable language ever (IMHO!!). However, I wish that python have some of the cool things of GO (like gorutines) and other stuff like in cobra-language.com and: 1- Removal of null (using maybe as haskell) 2- Decimal instead of float as default Still, the new languages refuse to fix #1. #1 Must be declared a goal like have garbage collection right now.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tikhonj 14y agoYou can't really use Maybe like in Haskell without a static type system. After all, in Python, there is no actual Null-pointer exceptions; instead, you have TypeErrors that just happen to trigger on None. Even if you had some sort of option type, you would still get runtime errors because there is not enough information to deal with them at compile time. Now, you could add some sort of abstractions to make checking for None in your code easier. But when your "benevolent" dictator hates folds, you're not getting any advanced features like monads any time soon!
- mamcx 14y agoYep, the sad thing is that you can't get all in a single package. The type system in Haskell look very good. But the cobra language have a implementation very close and in line with the spirit of python...
- drivebyacct2 14y ago>Is still not readable Wha...? Have you spent any time with it at all?
- SiVal 14y agoWhat evidence is there, if any, that Go is significantly more performant than Python? I'm not disputing it (it seems to me as though it ought to be). I'm just asking if there is any evidence that it actually is (or will be). If no real evidence yet, I'd still be interested in opinions (with explanations.) I'm particularly wondering about code other than Web apps with hundreds of simultaneous users, such as single-user statistical AI/machine learning or other performance-demanding apps where Python has to delegate to libraries written in C.
- enneff 14y agoGo's http package is competitive with nginx, so that should give you an idea of the playing field that Go competes in.
- Loic 14y agoDo you have a pointer to some data? I am especially interested in the minimal latency even when serving from memory a response under light usage (100 concurrent users). This would be at first to provide "backend" services to currently running applications, so the latency overhead is important.
- genbattle 14y agoOptimized C/C++ will usually beat out Go code, while Go will usually far outstrip the cpython interpreter[1]. Go itself doesn't really have any optimization for vector processing using SIMD that would make it a "fast" language for doing things like machine learning, machine vision, etc.; hand-coded C/C++ is always going to beat out any other language here. If you're talking python vs. go though, Go will win hands down. To be honest my personal viewpoint is that we're better off reducing our dependence on SIMD CPU instructions and using GPUs for this sort of highly-parallel processing instead. Most Processors sold these days come with a GPU built-in, so why not make use of these SIMD units, rather than duplicating them on the CPU? This is just my opinion though, and is sort of irrelevant to the question. Go has an excellent interface to C (cgo) built in, and SWIG can also be used to wrap C/C++ libraries so they are usable in Go. If your aim is core-for-core speed, then your best option is probably to take some highly optimised C/C++ library and create a wrapper that allows you to access it from Go. This route would be at least as performant as any python implementation using the same technique, if not much faster. If your goal is having a highly-concurrent and safe implementation, it is better to implement such libraries from scratch in Go; this is the method most Go libraries use. Just as with benchmarks, I don't think anyone can give you a non-subjective answer on whether Go will be faster (so take mine with a grain of salt). [1] http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?test=all&lang=go&lang2=python3 http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?test=al...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jwingy 14y agoMaybe I'm not understanding it correctly, but on the point about "it's ok to block", does that mean Go will continue to serve other requests normally, but at the point of the blocking code, it automatically has a "callback" to the next command? (effectively saving the programmer the pain of having to write code in callback fashion) Having no prior experience with Go, I found the rest of the article informative!
- phasevar 14y agoYeah, Go has a concept called Goroutines which are like lightweight threads. The system multiplexes Goroutines onto system threads. This means if one Goroutine blocks while waiting on IO, the Go scheduler will automatically select another Goroutine to run while the first Goroutine waits on IO. Writing your code in blocking style is just easier to follow than the callbacks used in Node and other asynchronous event servers.
- jgrahamc 14y agoMy point was that you make a goroutine and within that goroutine you do stuff sequentially and you block if you need to.
- jbert 14y agoWill go really multiplex goroutines which are blocking on system calls as well as those blocking on go-level entities (e.g. channels)? The underlying OS threads will do that, but if goroutines aren't 1-1 with OS threads (which I don't believe they are), how is this achieved? Are all current syscalls intercepted? What about calls out to external C libs which in turn call blocking syscalls? (I could test, but if go happens to be running all my goroutines in their own OS threads, I could get a false positive "pass")
- enneff 14y agoThe Go runtime manages a pool of OS threads with which to make blocking syscalls, while only a few OS threads run Go code. Calls to external C libs are treated the same as syscalls.
- icebraining 14y agoYou can read the well commented scheduler code here: http://golang.org/src/pkg/runtime/proc.c http://golang.org/src/pkg/runtime/proc.c A fast read suggests both syscalls and call to C code (cgocall) are used to switch goroutines.
- dkersten 14y agoI don't know if/how Go does this, but what I would do is something like the following: I'd have a thread pool of worker threads which execute the goroutines, so that if a system call blocks the goroutine, the thread will block. The threads would also use work-stealing so that if a thread runs out of tasks (goroutines), they can steal them from another threads task queue. As long as system calls are reasonably rare, this will work with if threads 1-1 with processor cores/hardware threads, but if system calls are common, this this could cause livelock (all threads blocked by system calls, but runnable goroutines cannot run). I imagine that often this would solve itself as system calls unblock the threads when they complete, but to protect against this, I would also have a low priority maintenance thread (or some other mechanism to run this check every so often - perhaps a wrapper around system calls) which checks how many runnable threads are in the thread pool and if there are less than a certain amount (eg number of available hardware threads), then it would spawn additional threads (or, again, perhaps a pool of these backup threads is kept around for cheaper spawning/despawning). Then later as the system calls unblock, the threads can be retired again. Thats just off the top of my head how I'd handle it. I imagine with some more thought you can come up with a better mechanism.
- ardit33 14y agoI tried, and was exited about it, but the lack of easy IDE integration and the lack of a proper debugger were a turn off for me. For now at least. Two questions to people that use Go: 1. Does Go have a good debugger that is easy to use? i.e. I shouldn't have to mess with the command line, but preferably use it directly from something like eclipse. It should work even in Windows. 2. Is goclipse working properly? Last time I used id, while it would show the syntax fine, the build and run was not working. I had to use the command line. I think a language should be developed together with its tools. Right now Go is lacking in this department.
- dualogy 14y agoNo idea about debugging -- but for other "IDE conveniences", combine Sublime Text (syntax highlighting and general text-editing win) with "GoSublime" (auto-completion & more, https://github.com/DisposaBoy/GoSublime https://github.com/DisposaBoy/GoSublime )
- stevvooe 14y agoI know you say you don't want to mess with the command line debuggers, but Go works with gdb [1]. While gdb looks daunting and antiquated at first, once you learn your way around, you'll feel something is missing from IDE based tools. [1] http://golang.org/doc/gdb http://golang.org/doc/gdb
- malbs 14y agoThis is probably very obvious, but just a note for anyone interested in using gdb.. if you downloaded 64-bit go, you need to use the 64bit gdb to debug it If you attempt to use the 32 bit gdb, you'll get errors about the executable you're attempting to debug is in an invalid format
- CasualSuperman 14y agoGo has gdb support, so any program that uses it as a backend (like ddd) can debug Go code. http://golang.org/doc/gdb http://golang.org/doc/gdb Not as easy to use as a lot of debuggers, but it's widely known. I don't know about Goclipse; I do all my development on the command line.
- didip 14y agodoes Go have package management? How do you guys find 3rd party libraries?
- objclxt 14y agoYou can use 'go get' to download and install packages direct from repository links, and there is a reasonable definitive list of open sourced libraries available here: http://go-lang.cat-v.org/pure-go-libs http://go-lang.cat-v.org/pure-go-libs
- timclark 14y agoThe go command will install third party packages from source code repositories if you know about them. There is a dashboard of packages on the go web site but I believe further work is needed for discovery on the command line.
- cletus 14y agoI have a hard time getting past it being mostly unusable on 32 bit Linux [1]. That just seems like a fundamental flaw in the garbage collector that moving to 64 bit simply kicks the can down the street. And before anyone suggests "just use 64 bit", that actually a really crappy solution. In most cases it merely (almost) doubles your memory footprint for no real gain. [1]: https://groups.google.com/group/golang-nuts/browse_thread/thread/ab1971bb9459025d?pli=1 https://groups.google.com/group/golang-nuts/browse_thread/th...
- enneff 14y agoThere's a patch to make the current conservative GC a precise GC, which will totally fix this problem. It's in the process of being reviewed and integrated into the core. http://codereview.appspot.com/6114046/ http://codereview.appspot.com/6114046/ FWIW, the panelists on the recent "Go in production" panel at I/O responded that garbage collection wasn't an issue for them on 64-bit systems. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKQLhGZVN4A http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKQLhGZVN4A
- pcwalton 14y agoThat's awesome, kudos. How do you deal with maintaining the distinction between pointers and values on the stack and in registers? I didn't see any code to do that, skimming through that patch. Since it's a precise GC, you need to maintain the distinction. In Rust we have a very large patchset to LLVM to allow us to do this; it involves modifying nearly every stage of the LLVM pipeline. Curious how you did that in gccgo. Edit: I just looked at the source and it still seems conservative for the stack and registers. So it's not a precise GC yet and will not eliminate false positives. (This is of course totally fine, I just wanted to clarify for myself.)
- enneff 14y agoThis isn't my patch, so I can't speak to the specifics of it. Also, it isn't for gccgo, but the gc compiler.
- 14y ago
- eta_carinae 14y ago> And the fact that it's missing exceptions seems like a win because I much prefer dealing with errors when they occur. This person doesn't seem to have much experience with error handling. You shouldn't deal with errors the way you prefer it, you should deal with them the right way. Sometimes, it's where they occur, but very often, it's somewhere up the stack. We learned this lesson in the 90's.
- pmylund 14y agoAnd Go lets you do that. You just return the error. Try writing a few things in Go. I very much doubt you'll respond like this afterwards.
- DeepDuh 14y agoSo I assume it has multiple returns? Some smart built in error class I could actually see that removing the need for exceptions, yes. One new way I've found interesting in obj c is giving functions (an) error handling block argument(s). It nicely does what java unhandled exceptions warnings do: make the user aware of his actions.
- ralph 14y agoYes, it can return a tuple, in Python-speak, and has a pre-declared error type. http://golang.org/ref/spec#Errors http://golang.org/ref/spec#Errors
- icebraining 14y agoIt seems odd to assume he has that opinion because of lack of experience, considering we're discussing a language developed by people like Rob Pike, who share his opinion on error handling and can hardly be described as unexperienced.
- luriel 14y agoAnd people like Ken Thompson. Accusing the author of this article of being "inexperienced" is also very amusing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Graham-Cumming http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Graham-Cumming And even Java and C++ luminaries like Bruce Eckel have come out in support of Go's error handling and against exceptions.
- eternalban 14y agoCSP is an interesting take on concurrency but lends a degree of opacity to the scheduling of tasks. So far (working in Go) in minor (or well understood patterns) it is a non-issue, but I wonder what would happen at large scale. It is also worth noting that in Go 1 runtime, switching from 1 "processor" to N can certainly alter the behavior of your program e.g. the same precise [1] binary may lead to CSP/Go's version of "deadlock" e.g. "all goroutines are sleep" or not depending on simply 1 bit of difference in the binary. The current runtime also gives rise to some interesting (and very unintuitive) performance differences when hacking with the CSP mechanism e.g. peppering GO sources with unnecessary sleeps, etc. to hack the scheduler. [1]: well nearly the same. Somewhere in the binary, a call to set maxprocs is present. Same exact program differing only in the param to this call (i.e. 1 vs 2).
- kaib 14y agoWe (tinkercad) have actually ended up running once process per core and limiting the number of concurrent OS threads. This gives significantly faster task switching times and is more performant from a GC perspective. Given our system is highly distributed anyway shared memory would mostly be an optimization and not a primary facility.
- zoowar 14y agoLet's not forget excellent documentation that links directly to the source code.
- pjmlp 14y agoWith so many blogs writing praises about Go, I keep wondering how much people learn about programming languages in the universities nowadays. As a compiled language, Go gets usually compared to the experiences people have with C and C++. The reality is that 90% of Go features are available in the Pascal family branch of programming languages since the early 80's. So most features that people enjoy in Go are all features that would already be mainstream, if the Pascal branch had won over C to become mainstream. Even the ability to use a language like Go for systems programming has been proven in the Native Oberon OS and its descendents (A2) at ETHZ.
- krasin 14y agoWhat's about CSP (channels/goroutines), static duck typing (Go interfaces) and a very practical standard library? I had taken a look at Oberon back in 1999 and found it so much worse than Delphi for writing real programs. (which was a precursor of C#/Windows Forms, not Go).
- pjmlp 14y ago> What's about CSP (channels/goroutines), static duck typing (Go interfaces) and a very practical standard library? CSP and static duck typing belong to the missing 10% I noted. Still there are available in other languages that also support native code generation with modules. > I had taken a look at Oberon back in 1999 and found it so much worse than Delphi for writing real programs. (which was a precursor of C#/Windows Forms, not Go). Go method definitions are taken from Component Pascal, an extension to Oberon. Actually I find Delphi much more powerful than Go for large scale development in the enterprise world.
- agentgt 14y agoGo is interesting in that doesn't yet support Generics... but might some day. The reason that interest me is that I like Generics aka parametric polymorphism but I feel like Scala, Haskell and OCaml take it almost to the extreme particularly since those languages also have type inference. So it can be overwhelming for a new user. That being said if Rust was more mature I would prefer it over Golang (here is another hacker news comment on this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1951467 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1951467).