3 ms·
This comic convincingly delivers a lot of half baked misplaced blamed for societal problems. Luddism harms workers. We know this because sometimes Luddism succe
by bloppe 2y ago
This comic convincingly delivers a lot of half baked misplaced blamed for societal problems. Luddism harms workers. We know this because sometimes Luddism succeeds. Chinese artisan guilds were more powerful than their English Luddite counterparts during the industrial revolution, and successfully prevented new technologies from taking hold there. As a result, they avoided England's growing pains, while condemning themselves and their children to lower economic growth and far more abject poverty.
There's a much healthier way to deal with the growing pains: redistribution. When the return on capital is higher than the return on labor, we're being failed by our tax regime. Redistributing gains means everyone benefits. Destroying machinery means everyone loses.
The weird tangents about AI art and phones for children are also dishonest. Copyright law and healthy child rearing are pretty orthogonal to job automation.
Ultimately, any society that chooses the path of Luddism will defeat itself, because there will always be another society that embraces technology, and they will not be subject to your regulations, and they will outcompete you, and I want to live in that society.
- John_Cena 2y agoIf you can't rely on the government to legislate in your interest, rebellion is always a valid option. I see the vandalization in this context as the same. When time keeping was expensive you can be sure industrialists used it as a tool of tyranny. There's a difference in embracing technology and being at the end of it.
- bloppe 2y ago> rebellion is always a valid option I'll allow it, but at least be honest about the point and constructive in your choice of targets. Undirected rage does not engender sympathy.