3 ms·
How would you translate "I think, therefore I am"? "I think, therefore I exist"?
by tlrobinson 18y ago
How would you translate "I think, therefore I am"?
"I think, therefore I exist"?
- nostrademons 18y agoDescartes meant the latter, correct?
- foulmouthboy 18y agoThe former sounds much nicer.
- astine 18y agoBoth. In this context, 'to be' is used in the same sense as 'to exist.' I'm not sure how you could use a different sense of 'to be' without rendering the sentence incomprehensible.
- euccastro 18y agoThat's how it's usually translated in Spanish. Cogito, ergo sum. -> Pienso, luego existo.
- riahi 18y agoThat's interesting, because staying truer to the latin would result in "Pienso, luego soy"
- euccastro 18y agoThere's also an interesting confusion in Spanish, where "luego" can be understood as either "therefore" or "after"/"next thing". I think it's the same ambivalence you'd have with "I think, then I exist." I don't know whether the latin original had that ambiguity.
- samuel 18y agoBoth translations from latin are indeed correct. But Descartes first used the french "Je pense, donc je suis" so yours is probably more correct.
- euccastro 18y agoI find this example harder to swallow: "The question of whether to exist or not to exist comes to mind."
- silentbicycle 18y agoPerhaps something along the lines of "My consciousness proves my existence" or "My awareness precedes my existence", depending on the interpretation.