5 ms·
I think I agree with Bernstein that the talk is mostly incoherent about this "privacy" vs. "security" tradeoff. However, I do want to call out his "Amazon was
by tptacek 2y ago
I think I agree with Bernstein that the talk is mostly incoherent about this "privacy" vs. "security" tradeoff.
However, I do want to call out his "Amazon was doing good business before 1999 and the end of the crypto wars", and "companies allocate just a small fraction of their security spend to cryptography":
* Prior to the end of export controls, Amazon was still doing SOTA cryptography
* Export controls themselves boiled down to clicking a link affirming you were an American, and then getting the strong-cryptography version of whatever it was you wanted; there were no teeth to them (at least not in software products)
* Prior to the widespread deployment of cryptography and, especially, of SSH, we had backbone-scale sniffing/harvesting attacks; at one point, someone managed to get solsniff.c running on some pinch point in Sprint and collected tens of thousands of logins. Lack of cryptographic protection was meaningful then in a way it isn't now because everything is encrypted.
- nebulous1 2y agoI don't think he was arguing that things weren't more secure after the export controls were dropped. I feel like that's why he was arguing to drop them at the time. He's just saying that all the signs point to Amazon/internet commerce becoming a behemoth either way. So we'd just end up in the same situation wrt what the talk sees as the current state of things, but with compromised cryptography.
- tptacek 2y agoHe was right about export controls. Nobody disagrees with him. I don't even think Meredith Whittaker does. But many times, I've come across a folk belief that strong cryptography was rare in North America before export controls were eliminated; it was not.