3 ms·
> It's a failed experiment. Failed? Because one project went wrong? They are incredibly successful - one large success after another, and they archive more and
by mmooss 2y ago
> It's a failed experiment.
Failed? Because one project went wrong? They are incredibly successful - one large success after another, and they archive more and make more available to the public than any other 'archive'.
Maybe those other questions don't come up for traditional archivists, but IA delivered. The idea that archives should sit inaccessible to the public is bizarre, I think, to everyone but (some?) archivists.
It's easy to sit back and criticize others. They delivered. I use IA all the time.
- badlibrarian 2y agoThe primary duty of an archive is to protect and preserve materials. A library has a different set of responsibilities and requirements. Over the years Archive.org turned into a catch-all for Brewster's increasingly wacky projects and I must be looking at different data because I don't see a lot of wins. And since the various efforts aren't particularly related in risk or goals, perhaps they should be structured and run in a fashion so that one effort couldn't destroy the others. And foremost that the archival materials are safe. IA is a great resource but frankly the breadth is tiny compared to what's out there in the real world. Their jewels (and what seems like should be their expertise) is the web crawl but even that is a mess. Meanwhile you may want to familiarize yourself with what's out there in the real world: https://www.archives.gov/about/info/national-archives-by-the-numbers https://www.archives.gov/about/info/national-archives-by-the... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_national_archives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_national_archives
- mmooss 2y ago> The primary duty of an archive is to protect and preserve materials. A library has a different set of responsibilities and requirements. I think their name is confusing to a professional, perhaps. Here's IA's mission: https://archive.org/about/ https://archive.org/about/ "The Internet Archive ... is building a digital library of Internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. Like a paper library, we provide free access to researchers, historians, scholars, people with print disabilities, and the general public. Our mission is to provide Universal Access to All Knowledge." So they think of themselves as a library. Regardless, they are what they are. It doesn't matter what other institutions do.
- badlibrarian 2y agoThey have a number of initiatives. The Open Library initiative resulted in a lawsuit from four publishers that they lost on Summary Judgment -- in other words, their behavior was so clearly illegal that hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees and EFF briefs were unable to raise a single issue that the judge thought deserved a trial. Internet Archive Federal Credit Union was shut down by the feds for "Unwillingness to open accounts within the field of membership, make loans, and establish operations in the low-income community where the credit union was chartered to serve; Violations of the Bank Secrecy Act and USA PATRIOT Act; and Weakening financial conditions and mounting losses." The Great 78 project resulted in a pending $621 million lawsuit and their defense is that pops and crackles allows them to publish 400,000 records because it's Fair Use. I think we both know how that one turns out. In the Hachette lawsuit, where IA decided Covid gave them the right to let people download unlimited copies of modern copyrighted books, it came out in discovery that they weren't keeping accurate records of the books they were loaning out before the panic. The judge ruled that even the previous effort where they only loaned out one copy at a time was improper. So other libraries had to do work and make things inaccessible, too. There's more, but it's ongoing stupid behavior. In any other organization, a pattern of decisions like this would result in leadership change. To preserve the archived materials that do not exist anywhere, I'm going to speak up about it. They have a mission (you didn't quote it correctly) and none of this helps that mission. And as a 501c3 they deserve more scrutiny from the public, not less.
- mmooss 2y ago> They have a mission (you didn't quote it correctly) Perhaps you can show us where it was wrong? lol All leadership has failures; it would be a failure of management otherwise; a fundamental misunderstanding of risk. It's also irrational to look at only failures and not successes - like talking only about the player's 3 missed penalty kicks without ever mentioning their 101 successful ones. It's like describing Steve Jobs to someone who doesn't know them as the failure who founded Next, without mentioning the rest. Look at the endless failures in the FAANG companies, and all the VC investments, etc. Have you visited Meta's VR world recently? How is your Apple Car driving? Your self-driving Tesla? Those people must not know what they're doing. Attacking the failures in hindsight is just serving another agenda, and of course when something goes wrong, there's blood in the water for a toxic response. The question is, do you want to sacrifice all the great good of IA? And who will take on leadership next or start another project, knowing you and your angry mob will do the same when there are inevitably setbacks? Look at the response to IA, Mozilla, etc. (I copied and pasted the mission statement.)