4 ms·
Yeah, that's the motte-and-bailey argument about 230 that makes me more scrutinous of tech companies by the day motte: "we curate content based on user prefere
by johnnyanmac 2y ago
Yeah, that's the motte-and-bailey argument about 230 that makes me more scrutinous of tech companies by the day
motte: "we curate content based on user preferences, and are hands off. We can't be responsible for every piece of (legal) content that is posted on your platform .
bailey: "our algorithm is ad-friendly, and we curate content or punish it based on how happy or mad it makes out adverts, the real customers for our service. So if adverts don't like hearing the word "suicide" we'll make creators who want to be paid self-censor".
if you want to take hands on what content is allowed on that granular a level, I don't see why 230 should protect you.
>I'd also like to point out that if a court sets a precedent that algorithms == opinions it should spell the end of all software patents.
I'm sure they'd word it very carefully to prevent that, or limit it only to software defined as "social media".
- aidenn0 2y agoThis is the actual reason for s230 existing; without 230, applying editorial discretion could potentially make you liable (e.g. if a periodical uncritically published a libelous claim in its "letters to the editor"), so the idea was to allow some amount of curation/editorial discretion without also making them liable, lest all online forums become cesspools. Aiding monetization through advertising was definitely one reason for doing this. We can certainly decide that we drew the line in the wrong place (it would be rather surprising if we got it perfectly right that early on), but the line was not drawn blindly.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI'd say the line was drawn badly. I'm not surprised it was drawn in a way to basically make companies the sorts of lazy moderators that are commonly complained about, all while profiting billions from it. Loopholes would exist, but the spirit of 230 seemed to be that moderation of every uploaded piece of content was bound to not represent the platform. Enforcing private rules that represents the platforms will seems to go against that point.
- Nasrudith 2y agoRemember your history for one. Most boards at the time were small volunteer operations or side-jobs for an existing business. They weren't even revenue neutral, let alone positive. Getting another moderator depended upon a friend with free time on their hands who hung around there anyway. You have been downright spoiled by multimillion dollar AI backed moderation systems combined with large casts of minimum wage moderators. And you still think it is never good enough. Your blatant ignorance of history shines further. Lazy moderation was the starting point. The courts fucked things up as they wont to do by making lazy moderation the only way to protect yourself from liability. There was no goddamned way that they could keep up instantly with all of the posts. Section 230 was basically the only constitutional section of a censorship bill and was designed to specifically 'allow moderation' instead of opposed to 'lazy moderator'. Not having Section 230 means lazy moderation only. God, people's opinions on Section 230 have been so poisoned by propaganda from absolutely morons. The level of knowledge of how moderation works has gone backwards!
- johnnyanmac 2y agoYou say "spoiled", I say "ruined". Volunteer moderation of the commons is much different from a platform claiming to deny liability for 99% of content but choosing to more or less take the roles of moderation themselves. Especially with the talks of AI My issue isn't with moderation quality so much as claiming to be a commons but in reality managing it as if you're a feudal lord. My point it that they WANT to try to moderate it all now, removing the point of why 230 shielded them. And insults are unnecessary. My thoughts are my own from some 15 years of observing the landscape of social media dynamics change. Feel free to disagree but not sneer.