There is also a disconnect (related to your comment) between what the left (and centre) are accusing, and what libertarians defend against. The left are simply

There is also a disconnect (related to your comment) between what the left (and centre) are accusing, and what libertarians defend against. The left are simply claiming that this was caused by market liberalisation. Increasing market liberalisation would make it worse. The free marketeers are then countering by saying it was never totally free. You can't use that situation to judge anything.