3 ms·
Exercise Paradox
- oakesm9 2y agoKurzgesagt did a good video on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSSkDos2hzo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSSkDos2hzo
- Mistletoe 2y agoAnyone with an app or watch that tells them how many calories they burn in exercise would have to agree. I ran 7 miles yesterday for my long run for the week and only burned 924 calories it says. You could undo that with a single poor decision at a fast food establishment. https://www.reddit.com/r/coolguides/comments/1c4pvnp/a_cool_guide_to_fast_food_items_with_the_most/ https://www.reddit.com/r/coolguides/comments/1c4pvnp/a_cool_...
- zelos 2y agoI think it's worse than that, though. Burning 924 calories running then means (if I understand the paradox correctly) that you probably end up then burning a decent fraction of 924 fewer calories over the rest of the day, thanks to metabolism changes and being less active.
- al_borland 2y agoThis can work the other way as well. On many occasions if I ate really, really poorly, I would wake up the next morning drenched in sweat. My body would turn up things up to try and burn off what I did. The body does a decent job of trying to maintain where you’re at (within reason). If it didn’t very minor things could compound into drastic effects over time. Of course I noticed this, relied on it too much, and pushed past the limits of what it could handle. Oops.
- eks391 2y agoI exercise semi regularly and use a watch + phone combo to watch my health stats regardless of my physical activity, to include calories, so I feel like my experience is decent data. On a day that I don't work out, I burn about 2000 calories. On days that I work out (weekly run), I burn 2800 calories, but I am so hungry that I have to eat huge meals and I have consumed the additional 800 I burned within 12 hours. Perhaps weekly runs are sufficiently infrequent for my body to not get "used to" the run, fitting it into the 2k calorie burn, thus I go way over on those days no matter what, but my body is getting those extra calories no matter what, to make up for it due to how significantly more hungry I am after. Everyone I know who lost weight basically just starved themselves (net calorie loss).
- mingus88 2y agoAnd you’re more likely to treat yourself after such a workout. I’m assuming the tribe in this study didn’t have access to junk food because in my experience it takes a lot of discipline to stick to a diet if you repeatedly work out to exhaustion
- pizza234 2y agoBut this is not the finding of the research, which is, according to their finding (I'm personally skeptical) that physical activity doesn't have an impact on daily calories expenditure. In short, accoding to their finding, in your case, yesterday, your body compensated buring those 924 in some way, so that you consumed approximately as much as a day when you didn't run (again, I'm very skeptical of the research). Having said that, the article itself doesn't mention how much physical activity the Hazda did. Walking is "physical activity", but not significant.
- watwut 2y agoThe research is population level research on estimated calories expenditure of some tribes and HDI countries. It shows exactly zero about what happens when you replace netflix with exercising in your day. It also shows exactly zero about what happens when you replace going 5km by car every day by walking those 5km every day.
- tzs 2y agoGetting food is the main thing. They do not store food so every day the men hunt and the women gather. So for the men lots of walking, a fair bit of running, carrying dead animals back home. The men also gather honey from beehives high up in tall trees. The women dig up roots and tubers and gather other plant food, and carry it back home. They also gather honey from beehives that are not high up in tall trees. I've read that it amounts to about 75 minutes a day of MVPA (moderate to vigorous physical activity), but they are active for much more of the day.
- ggu7hgfk8j 2y agoFor me, the fear of undoing it means I eat healthier. Should i eat 1000kcal chocolate bar for some brief pleasure? Sure why not Should i eat 1000kcal chocolate bat for some brief pleasure, more than undoing the hour of torture? Hell naw
- e63f67dd-065b 2y agoSmartwatches are poor estimators of energy expenditure of exercise: https://www.strongerbyscience.com/research-spotlight-wearables/ https://www.strongerbyscience.com/research-spotlight-wearabl... The same authors publish regular research reviews on nutrition and health at https://massresearchreview.com/ https://massresearchreview.com/; the general conclusion remains that exercise is a poor intervention for the purpose of weight loss is true. But estimating the effects of exercise is incredibly difficult, it varies wildly and is subject to many confounders.
- KittenInABox 2y agoI've commonly heard this as "you can't outrun a bad diet". As more I learn about weight loss the more I harden in my belief that obesity is more like having a medical condition than it is a personality flaw. Maybe if we had more epidemiologists examining chemical/environmental/etc causal factors to the sharp uptick in obesity and less culture war/shame/"just have more discipline" about it we could've avoided a ton of medical expenditure on the medical needs of obese patients (not just diabetes but I mean larger beds/equipment, nurse injuries in moving obese patients, etc). What I don't understand is: how does the exercise paradox exist but it's also super common for an athlete to put on tons of weight immediately after stopping their exercise due to an injury or similar?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> commonly heard this as "you can't outrun a bad diet" It’s worse than that. If your metabolism is fucked your body could literally reduce critical functions to starvation levels before conceding and letting you burn more calories than you consume.
- watwut 2y ago> how does the exercise paradox exist Because exercising is actually burning calories. And if you exercise a lot, you will need to eat more and in a way that would make someone sedentary gain weight. People who exercise more, need to eat more and are spending more calories per day. Otherwise said "you can't outrun a bad diet" is oversimplification, exercise paradox is something that happens in some conditions and is oversimplification. And likewise, calories in calories out is oversimplification.
- fendy3002 2y agoI take it as fat mass being transformed into muscle mass. It's not too much weird since bodybuilders or strongmen need high calories to maintain / build their mass.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoI don’t see how this can be true in the limit. If you are a women and burn > 2000 calories exercising then surely your total will be higher than the sedentary total of 1900 calories :).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stevebmark 2y agoThe human body doesn’t indiscriminately burn its weight in calories as fuel. Energy intake and expenditure is complicated. If someone expends energy through using up their stored glycogen, as most of us do, that may not use energy from fat mass.
- nutrie 2y agoI generally lose 1 kilo a day on bikepacking trips (or 100 km every three or four days). No yo-yo effect.
- strken 2y agoMy mental model of bodyweight is that my body can adapt to use less energy to some degree, probably a few thousand kJ at most. If I exercise or drop my caloric intake and it's still within that range, I won't have to dig into fat reserves much. If I do more than that, I absolutely will. As you say, doing low to moderate intensity exercise for a long time -- like walking 20km a day for a week, which is double what the Hadza walk -- is enough to cause me to lose weight unless I'm eating more to make up for it.
- nutrie 2y agoYeah, everyone’s different. My intake is around 10k kcal when cycling throughout the day, and it’s like nothing. How much I climb matters though, by a lot (at least 2 000 m). Strangely enough, hiking doesn’t cut it for me, it doesn’t go down much even after 50 km/day, which is wild (I still do it though).
- notjes 2y agoSo of those 2k calories the average human body needs to sustain itself, only a fraction of it, or none at all, is needed to perform many hours of physical labor. This means physical labor done by humans is cheap or free.
- airstrike 2y agoLink to paper (PDF): https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3405064/pdf/pone.0040503.pdf https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3405064/pdf/pone.00...
- wormlord 2y ago> This paradox challenges the common belief that more exercise equates to more calories burned and consequently, more weight loss. This is pretty obvious if you have ever done strength training/tried to lose weight. Working out makes you really hungry. It is a lot easier to lose weight while not exercising just by only eating when you are hungry, and not eating garbage. I've heard it called "inuitive eating". This is also why I personally don't believe in bulking. You should just hit your macros and try to progress naturally. If you do cycles of cutting and bulking you are really just making your progress inconsistent and fucking up your digestive tract. Controversial opinion I know.
- vivekd 2y agoMaybe the issue is that how much you weigh is a terrible metric for how fit you are.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xnx 2y agoStrength and aerobic exercise has so many benefits (mood, sleep, longevity, energy levels, reduce chronic disease, etc.), but "weight loss" (really "fat loss") is barely one of them. This is one of the biggest misconceptions in general health understanding (along with exercises reducing fat in specific spots). It is beneficial to both the exercise and food industries to perpetuate this myth. Exercise products are more attractive to people if they think it can make them look more attractive. Excessive calorie consumption is acceptable if you think you can "work it off later".
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoIt feels like that a lot of people use exercise (and diets for that matter) as a kind of self-flagellation, working off the guilt of eating "bad". But do people really want to live in guilt like that? Is that what motivates them? Thing is, I'm healthier now that I don't feel guilty about what I eat, and also don't feel like snacking / "cheating" nearly as much. A lot of people don't eat normal, they have no healthy baseline; they don't eat regularly, they eat reactively to "I am hungry" or "Oh shit I need to figure out something for dinner". This is especially an issue in the US where it seems that eating takeout is the norm (and what you have is decided on the spot instead of planned in advance), but please correct me if I'm wrong. This takeout culture is also growing in Europe, especially with apps and services that make it easier to just reach for it. For a good period we ended up having takeout once a week, often reactively / last minute, and it's nowhere near the healthiest choice (but a chips, cheese, kebab, sauce and salad lasagna is so good)
- bob1029 2y agoThis is one of the hardest lessons I learned. I used to think I could escape my consumption habits with enough exercise. It was fun to believe I could go on a multi-day bender and then work it all off with a heroic CrossFit session. But, this is actually like bailing water out of a sinking cruise liner with a teaspoon. It is 1000x more effective to simply not consume the calories in the first place. The energy density of modern food is incomprehensible to our ancestry. I focus about 80% of my willpower on the diet & meal prep aspects. The remainder is toward exercise. I find that when my diet slips, it is far more destructive than when I miss a few days on the rowing machine.
- oersted 2y agoGenerally humans are very efficient machines, even ignoring the effect discussed here. Just look up the numbers, very generally, an hour of intense exercise tends to burn the same amount as quite a frugal lunch. I find that it is much easier to reduce say 500 calories of daily intake than to burn the same amount. Obviously, this is not a wise attitude to have, exercise has a lot of other benefits and it is critical to maintain good health. But yeah, if it's just about loosing weight the cost (time, willpower, money, fatigue...) to benefit ratio is surprisingly low.
- Swizec 2y agoThis is trivially observable as untrue to anyone with an athlete level of physical activity. Eating enough food to sustain training for a marathon is work. Consuming enough calories every day during peak training for a marathon is exhausting, disgusting, and you’re always hungry. Food loses all connection to enjoyment and you’re just shoveling calories in your face all day. You could stop but then good luck training the next day. I have so far not gained any weight during these cycles. Usually I end up losing some. So the calories gotta be going somewhere.
- galdosdi 2y agoMaybe, but so what? Exercise has so many positive second order effects, and then those may help with weight loss indirectly. - Improved mood, focus, calm, etc, make it easier and more pleasant to adhere to a better diet - Can improve sleep quality. Low sleep quality is linked to overeating and obesity and other problems. In fact, poor diet, poor sleep, and poor exercise are all interlinked. So start anywhere and expect the others to get easier to deal with over time too. - So what if weight doesn't change, but it's due to fat decreasing and muscle increasing? That's a good thing -- weight is an imperfect measure of obesity. Muscle, just by existing, burns more calories. And unlike abdominal fat, is not linked to organ problems. - And on and on and on. Just do anything to get healthier. Every healthy action will synergestically reinforce every other healthy action. Don't be a narrow beancounter looking at just one component, because your body is not just a handful of components narrowly linked together via thin black box abstraction layers; it's a big spaghetti code system that cannot be seperated cleanly out into pieces. Not exercising is really, really unhealthy, contrary to modern customary belief, so you might as well, rather than fixating on fixing only some other component while keeping this important component broken. - Moderate exercise seems to actually moderate appetite a little. And heavier exercise seems to make hunger less cravingy and more indiscriminate, making it easier to adhere to a diet (eg, a couch potato might really crave a specific candy or chips, but someone who just ran some miles will ecstatically and happily devour some beans and cabbage and oatmeal and whatever) - Improves digestion quality and gut motility! - Besides, isn't the goal of weight loss to get healthier in general, anyway? Focus on the overall goal and start anywhere, anywhere that is easiest. If getting better sleep is easier, do that. If cutting toxins like alcohol and nicotine is easier, start there. If improving diet is easier, start there. If improving positive human relationships and sense of purpose is easier, start there. If exercise is easier, start there. Start anywhere, and keep improving anywhere the wins are most easily found, and gradually everything else will become easier. One more tip: It's easier to change what you eat than how much. Also, calories in calories out is bunk. It's true to some degree in that they are related, but ignores the fact that (1) how much your body is spending is highly variable, even somewhat independent of movement -- imagine how much energy your body has to spend to fight an infection for example (2) why would anyone imagine every calorie consumed will actually be absorbed? the gut is highly complex and depending on many factors calories could be absorbed or go right out the other end unused, and the gut flora interacts complexly with all this. Focus on eating healthy things first above healthy amounts. It's easier, and will have a positive impact all its own, creating another stepping stone towards other goals.
- pizza234 2y agoAt the very least, this article should be clarified (or maybe, the backing research is garbage, which is a possibility). In the context of weight management, the concept of "weight loss" should never be considered. This is because two people with same weight may have wildly different body compositions; this also applied to the same people but in different conditions. A person may have different body compositions, but same weight, in two different periods of their life, which can very well be before and after starting a physical activity regime. Regardless, I'm extremely skeptical. When one has a sedentary lifestyle, and turns to consistent sport activity, it's very typical to quickly lose fat and gain muscles for some time, which is in conflict with the research.
- baseballdork 2y ago> In the context of weight management, the concept of "weight loss" should never be considered. This is because two people with same weight may have wildly different body compositions; this also applied to the same people but in different conditions. Weight loss should _never_ be considered? How does that follow? Lots of people definitely need to lose weight.
- projektfu 2y agoI took it to mean that the goal is a reduction in adiposity. For most cases, weight loss will mean that, but it is also possible to become sarcopenic or chronically dehydrated, be lighter, and be in worse health. Most studies look at more than just weight, they minimally assess BMI and ideally estimate body fat percentage. Some go further, looking at relative risk of other endpoints such as heart attack, heart failure, stroke, diabetes, injury, hospitalization, death, etc.
- pizza234 2y agoTake a person that with X% body fat and Y% muscles. They start going to the gym; after some time, they'll have (random numbers) (X-2)% body fat, and (Y+2)% muscles. On a scale, their weight will be the same, but in reality, their body composition (and looks) will be considerably different. This is a very important concept. Beside the obvious case where somebody just looks at the scale, and they don't realize their progress, body composition as opposed to weight is extremely important when doing diets, because an improper diet may lead to excessive muscle loss, which is accidentally perceived as a success (on the scale) rather than a failure (because the body composition hasn't changed as intended).
- lapcat 2y agoWeight, and weight loss, are not good measures of bodily appearance or health. It's bad to be frail, malnourished, and dehydrated (a significant amount of body weight is water). What really matters is the amount of muscle and fat in your body, and exercise is certainly a good way to build muscle. Moreover, exercise is great for cardiovascular health, which is also essential. In other words, the so-called "paradox" is largely irrelevant, and avoiding exercise is ill-advised. A link in the same Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefits_of_physical_activity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefits_of_physical_activity
- lux 2y agoI gained about 50 lbs in my 20's by getting a sedentary job and eating poorly after moving out on my own. I spent a solid 2 years trying to lose weight by working out actively and lost nothing. When I changed my diet, I dropped it all over time and kept it off for the last 15+ years. I tell people I know trying to lose weight to separate the ideas of exercise and diet, but few listen and most are quite resistant to the idea. To me, I think of exercise as maintaining a healthy heart, posture, etc. but keep it completely out of the picture for weight management. The other side of this is motivation. If you don't see yourself losing weight from exercise, it demotivates you and that demotivation then carries into other areas like diet. So if you keep those separate, you won't make poor choices in your overall health as a result of feeling demotivated by the lack of results from exercise and you won't fall off the bandwagon so easily.
- ASalazarMX 2y agoAs a fairly muscular guy who has dealt with overweight for more than two decades, I wholeheartedly agree. Half an hour of weightlifting burns like 120 calories, about two corn tortillas. It's stupid how efficient the body is at extracting energy from food. I've also accepted that changes in activity strongly influence your health, and changes in eating strongly influence your weight.
- dp-hackernews 2y agoThis! ^^
- lux 2y agoThe crazy thing to me is that since losing that weight people don't believe me and think I must be lying that I ever weighed more. I've even whipped out a photo once to prove it.
- dp-hackernews 2y agoThis! ^^
- hammock 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_point_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_point_theory
- irthomasthomas 2y agoExercise and work up an appetite.
- projektfu 2y agoAlso on Wikipedia: The Cochrane Collaboration found that exercising alone led to limited weight loss. In combination with diet, however, it resulted in a 1 kilogram weight loss over dieting alone. A 1.5 kilograms (3.3 pounds) loss was observed with a greater degree of exercise.[29] Even though exercise as carried out in the general population has only modest effects, a dose response curve is found and very intense exercise can lead to substantial weight loss. During 20 weeks of basic military training with no dietary restriction, obese military recruits lost 12.5 kg (28 lb).[30] High levels of physical activity seem to be necessary to maintain weight loss.[31] A pedometer appears useful for motivation. Over an average of 18-weeks of use, physical activity increased by 27% resulting in a 0.38 decrease in BMI.[32] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Management_of_obesity#Exercise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Management_of_obesity#Exercise [29-32] endnotes in Wikipedia Also interesting, a meta-analysis: Effects of Different Exercises Combined with Different Dietary Interventions on Body Composition: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis Yongchao Xie, Yu Gu, Zhen Li, Bingchen He, Lei Zhang https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11397086/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11397086/
- apeescape 2y agoCould it be that the body adapts to an active lifestyle over time, and that's why _intense_ exercise acts as a shock that burns calories (it won't be intense anymore after you're used to it)?
- Imnimo 2y agoWhen he was competing, Michael Phelps famously ate something like 8,000 calories a day. How do we square this with the Exercise Paradox?
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoLikewise, heavy labour like idk, the crab fishing. I think the researches are skewed; by the sound of it, the physical activity of the people researched is normal / average for them. But the people in the comments compare with athletes doing their athlete thing, going well beyond what is normal for them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- valbaca 2y ago"You lose weight in the kitchen; you gain health in the gym" is the adage that has served me well. Just like keeping one's house organized, the best thing is to reduce Junk In rather than trying to get Junk Out.
- maxglute 2y agoI think one of those cases of ecological/population fallacy "interpretation of statistical data that occurs when inferences about the nature of individuals are deduced from inferences about the group". There is enough genetic diversity that some individuals can out work their caloric intake (bmr + tdee). You see it all the time in enviroments where high level athletes train. You'll have groups that still need to manage intake to keep weight off, and you'll have groups that can eat everything in sight and still stay lean, or even be forced to go into surplus to maintain. IMO (bro science) it seems to largely boil down to whatever factors that affect rate at which individuals shit. Most of the naturally skinny people I know, either eat not much, or eat normal amount but shit often. When the normal range of people pooping is 3x per day to 3x per range, it matters how inefficient your body absorbs/wastes the calories you put in. Some people's bowels are natrually bulimic, purges everything all the time and keeps weight down. Maybe it's not useful to apply to genpop (abs built in kitchen etc), but I don't feel it's a paradox.
- readthenotes1 2y agoThis is mostly a paradox because of bad science isn't it? Wasn't the advice "manage what you eat if you want to lose weight" until money was given to scientists say otherwise, e. G., https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/08/09/coca-cola-funds-scientists-who-shift-blame-for-obesity-away-from-bad-diets/ https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/08/0... And don't we also know that overcompensatoey eating is a well known problem for people who adopt an exercise program to lose weight?
- dp-hackernews 2y agoCalories are a measure of energy, NOT nutritional value. Forget calories, think utility. Some types of calories are good for you, others may as well be poison - therefore, the dose is the poison. By consuming calories in accordance with their utility you will do a better job at staying (or getting) metabolically healthy than only counting calories. TL;DR: Eat more fat and protein from natural, preferably animal, sources, and you will naturally be less inclined to consume junk calories from carbohydrates and you will quickly feel better for it. Watch this video below to understand more, for why this is the case, and why colories in v's calories out is a very poor model. --- "Is a Calorie a Calorie? Processed Food, Experiment Gone Wrong" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxyxcTZccsE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxyxcTZccsE