You can disagree with any of this list, of course, but that's not what the previous poster was doing: it's just a shallow dismissal, and a claim that it was wri

You can disagree with any of this list, of course, but that's not what the previous poster was doing: it's just a shallow dismissal, and a claim that it was written for what are essentially bad faith reasons. That's quite a different thing than "I disagree with this because X" (which is what you're doing).