3 ms·
It's easy to distinguish the worthless degrees from the valuable ones. Google the starting salaries of each major. If a person picks a useless major, the decis
by WalterBright 2y ago
It's easy to distinguish the worthless degrees from the valuable ones. Google the starting salaries of each major.
If a person picks a useless major, the decision is on them.
- huuhee3 2y agoSociety (and parents) still should have some responsibility on educating young people about career prospects of different degrees. Too many in older generations think any degree will land their children a job, and thus encourage them to study whatever they like.
- Ekaros 2y agoI think school system is hugely failing students if they are not instructed and then capable of spending one or two afternoons on simply googling and looking at career prospects and what different jobs actually might entail. And then at least with minimal criticality thinking is that for them. I am pretty sure there is no careers you cannot find some information on with rather simple searches.
- ryandrake 2y agoThis belief that "a degree, any degree" is sufficient must have started after I went to University (mid-90s), because when I was a teenager, it was drilled into us that we need to not only go to University, but we need to major in something lucrative. Nobody, from parents to guidance counsellors, was saying "Oh, just go to college and major in anything, it doesn't matter!"
- WalterBright 2y agoThe younger generation that grew up with Google never think to google "starting salary for [my] major"? They need to be coached to do it? Try it. Gott im Himmel!
- Nevermark 2y ago> It's easy to distinguish the worthless degrees from the valuable ones. Google the starting salaries of each major. Agreed. > If a person picks a useless major, the decision is on them. Not just them. Their parents, the school, etc. There are so many "simple" things to know. Too many for them to always be obvious, even when they "obviously" should be. A mistake that a million young students make is a mistake worth updating the educational system to handle better. And as an objective practical matter, it is always on society. Society systematically loses masses of individual potential by not providing more guidance when it matters. (And perversely turning education into an easy loan factory, regardless of expected income, the opposite of good guidance.)
- WalterBright 2y agoI picked my major entirely on my own. My parents didn't advise me about it, nor did the school. I have been known to advise young people that their intended major was akin to taking a vow of poverty, and they all insisted they were following their dream, and are now working at minimum wage jobs. I don't have a whole lot of sympathy for students who discover after they graduate that their chosen major has no value. How do they go through 4 years of college never checking such things? Google "starting salary for history majors", for example. At Caltech, everyone knew that ChE paid the best, and AY degrees were worthless (this was long before google). The AY majors usually did a double major - AY for fun, and the other degree for money.
- Nevermark 2y agoI would assume that students getting into competitive schools were more informed (whether or not that resulted in a good decision). > I don't have a whole lot of sympathy It is a big objective problem, for the students and society. So even without feelings, some kind of incentives need to be better aligned with reality. Limiting student loan repayment terms, with a limited percentage of student income recoverable to banks, would certainly incentivize banks not to help students get in trouble. Telling basket weaving majors that they are welcome to do it for love, but to expect to be paying for the degree themselves up front, or with an ongoing job, represents the desired outcome, in simplified terms.
- selimthegrim 2y agoSo which undergrad majors do you propose Caltech abolishes? I can think of a couple with awful starting salaries.
- WalterBright 2y agoAs I mentioned before, there are no jobs for AY majors, even from Caltech. I don't suggest abolishing it. There were many AY majoring students, and they had open eyes about it. There wasn't any whining about it.
- selimthegrim 2y agoI think putting chemistry and biology in that box might be a little much too