6 ms·
34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
- man4 2y ago[dead]
- russellbeattie 2y agoPfffft. Old news. How about a 49x49x49 cube instead? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZeylpCG3IE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZeylpCG3IE
- PaulRobinson 2y agoFrom the original article on the 34x34x34 "record": > It took about 1 year, and 1000 work hours to make the cube. Imagine doing all that work, all the planning, designing, printing, assembly, and feeling the title will be yours soon, knowing the record has stood unbroken for 7 years, confident you're the only person even trying... ... And then 4 weeks before you finish a guy appears on YouTube with his 49x49x49... Ooof.
- falcor84 2y agoNah, TFA was published on May 10, 2024, so he did hold the record for almost half a year.
- mega_dean 2y agoIn the 49x49x49 video, he goes over previous world records of "Highest Order nxnxn Twisty Puzzle", and I thought it was weird he didn't mention the 34x34x34. But in the youtube description, he links to this forum post where he announces it on August 10 (a few weeks before the video, but still well after May 10): https://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=39559 https://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=39559 There is a comment from the creator of the 34x34x34: > Ah there's so much I want to say, where to begin? Well, soon after finishing the 34x34, I notified Greg, who immediately notified me about the 49x49. At that point, Preston had already checkered the 49x49, so I did not consider the 34x34 a world record. It seems nobody noticed this, but nowhere in any of my videos did I claim the 34x34 was a world record :lol: But still, everyone just assumed it was :lol:
- Aardwolf 2y agoApparently an even-sized cube is harder to make though so it should count as the record for even-sized cube
- Vampiero 2y agoThe previous record was 33x33x33. Imagine going through all that just to beat it by one unit while using the same design, that's so cheap. I'm so glad he was beaten by the 49x49x49.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoI don't think the 49 guy was even attempting in a hurry. It took him 4+ years, right.
- queuebert 2y agoFYI this is exactly what being a research scientist feels like.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoI’m sorry I was not good with my search. I actually found a 33x33x33, and then the next highest that popped up was this 34x34x34. Next time, I will see if I should spend more time searching for higher records in any record-breaking event.
- tetris11 2y agoAfter the 22x22x22, the how seems to no longer be an issue and it's more about scaling the cube to the minimum density of the printer. That, and clearly money.
- qwertox 2y agoThe video at the bottom of the page is a work of art. Now someone should build a robot to actually work that thing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocy09pzME4E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocy09pzME4E
- Modified3019 2y agoWow no kidding, I actually watched the whole thing. The stop motion of the build was very satisfying. It’s also amazing how smoothly it moves, even being as heavy as it is.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoA few days ago, my younger daughter was trying to have fun and suggested that we watch an important video about solving a 1x1x1 Rubik’s Cube. I went along, and we spent some time moving up the numbers; that’s when we needed to search for the largest number of NxNxN possible, and we landed on this video and the article.
- nick__m 2y agoIsn't a 1x1x1 rubik's cube a dice ? Or i am missing something about the size notation ?
- Brajeshwar 2y agoMy daughter was making fun of me!
- tetris11 2y agoYou still have to solve the minimum number of rotations to get the "1" at the top and the "3" in front
- jandrese 2y agoIsn't the minimum number of rotations always 0? IE you start with an already solved cube? Maximum number of rotations is more interesting, although in the 1 cube that is just 2.
- Oreb 2y agoFrom a puzzle-solving point of view, these very large cubes aren't that interesting. When you increase the cube size, there are new things to figure out, but only up to a certain point. Figuring out how to solve a 4x4x4 when you know how to solve a 3x3x3 takes some significant work. I think I spent a whole weekend to successfully solve a 4x4x4 the first time I got one, despite being reasonably good at solving the 3x3x3. Solving a 5x5x5 for the first time took just a couple of hours, there wasn't much new to learn. The 6x6x6 was easier still. When I got to the 7x7x7, there wasn't really anything new at all. I could solve it immediately, it just took more time. Anything beyond 7x7x7 is pretty much the same. It's just more annoying, because the puzzle gets physically harder to handle, and because you have to do the tedious work of counting how many layers away from the centre a piece is. The 7x7x7 is the biggest cube used in official competitions, for a good reason. The motivation for making enormous cubes like the 34x34x34 is just the engineering challenge, and breaking records. Nobody is going to want to solve such a thing, at least not more than once.
- matsemann 2y agoJust to elaborate: Solving a 5x5x5 or a 7x7x7 is basically just turning the cube into a 3x3x3 by lining up the edges and fill in the centers. Which is a new thing, but quite easy to figure out. And then solve it as if it was a 3x3x3.
- Oreb 2y agoThat's not the only way to solve big cubes, but it's indeed the most common way (known as "reduction"), and what most people naturally come up with if they try to solve 4x4x4 or bigger on their own. In addition to what you said, there is also the issue of parity (basically, when you reduce a 4x4x4 to a 3x3x3 by solving centers and edges first, you will often end up with a 3x3x3 cube in an unsolvable state, and you need to figure out some tricks to convert it to a solvable state), but if you know how to solve parity problems on a 4x4x4, you can do it for a cube of any size.
- golf_mike 2y agoJust out of curiosity (no rubiks cube affinity at all), but how can there be an unsolvable state when there are 'tricks' get in a solvable state? Does that not imply that there are no unsolvable states at all? Or is that maybe related to a certain method of solving?
- user2342 2y agoAre there recommendable sources on how to learn solving/the concepts of a classic cube?
- QuadmasterXLII 2y agoare you looking for a classic cube specific source, or techniques that will solve much slower but generalize to other shapes of permutation puzzle?
- user2342 2y agoRather for the classic 3x3x3 cube. I played with it in the 80ies, but never understood the concepts behind it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bembo 2y agoThe website this post is on is a wiki that explains how to solve a lot of different puzzles like the rubix cube.
- user2342 2y agoThanks. Looks promising!
- Hackbraten 2y agoI’m having a really hard time to understand even the “beginner’s method” on that wiki. For example, it entirely glosses over how to solve the „first two layers“ (F2L) on the left and back faces. It only ever explains F2L for the front and right faces. However, I can’t possibly achieve a „yellow cross“ that way. I wonder why I can’t seem to find any source that actually explains it.
- Oreb 2y ago
- boneitis 2y ago(Snark warning, but even more than that, I find myself amused and amazed by the overall story) Ah, yes. Ruwix, the beloved Rubik's cube tutorial site that abused and cheated their way to the top of SEO rankings[0] in ethically dubious manner by directly victimizing end-users. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27427330 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27427330 ("How I uncovered a black-hat SEO scam")
- spiderice 2y agoWow.. that was a fun rabbit hole to go down. Makes me wish HN wasn't pushing a bunch of traffic to them this morning.
- zuminator 2y agoI've read that the minimum number of moves for solving a 3x3x3 cube in its most scrambled state ("God's number") is just 20 moves, and this was verified through brute force search. I'm uncertain as to whether there is an algorithm for solving an arbitrarily scrambled cube in just 20 moves, or if it's just known that it is possible to be solved in 20 moves, but probably the latter. Anyway, I can't seem to find a corresponding God's number for the 4x4x4 cube but it seems perhaps the lower bound is in the 30-40 move range. I not a cuber (?) by any means so I don't know if there's any sort of formula to even approximate the lower bound for solving successively higher level cubes, but if there is, I'd be very curious to know what the approximate God's number is for this 34x34x34 beast. Anyway if we were to go with just a very naive guess that each higher level takes 1.5x the moves of the previous level so 3x3x3=20, 4x4x4=30, 5x5x5=45 and so on, that would yield 34x34x34= 5,752,532 moves (or 5,817,104 if you round up 1 at every fractional result), which at a second per move, would take over 2 months to solve. I suspect that in practice, any algorithmic means to solve such a cube would take somewhat longer, so much so that a thoroughly scrambled cube might never be unscrambled.
- fanf2 2y agoThe web site for God’s Number is http://www.cube20.org/ http://www.cube20.org/
- incognito124 2y agoYou mean the maximum number of moves?
- mr_mitm 2y agoThe way I read it was that it's the maximum minimum number of moves.
- marsten 2y agoBased on the bounds discussed at https://old.reddit.com/r/Cubers/comments/8chfuu/i_found_a_general_formula_for_an_upper_bound_of/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Cubers/comments/8chfuu/i_found_a_ge... it appears that a 34x34x34 cube can be algorithmically solved in under 100,000 moves. Maximum number of moves scales as n^2.
- ambyra 2y agoThis is strange, probably not fun to play. I think an exploded view (t shape) on the computer would be cool.
- SirMaster 2y agoWhy are the corners so big?
- nachox999 2y agothey wanted to make sure nothing could cut in
- NeoTar 2y agoEach corner piece needs to make contact with the core. Consider when the top layer is rotated 45 degrees relative to the layer below. The corner is now about 0.707 units from the centre of the face, but the layer below only extends 0.5 units out from the centre. If the corner pieces were smaller than about 0,207 units it would become disconnected from the cube as a whole. So, any cube larger than (I believe) the 5 by 5 either needs to have bulging faces, or have the edge/corner pieces larger than the others.
- SirMaster 2y agoHmm, it looks like even a 7x7x7 doesn't need to have much. I guess it has a tiny amount larger edge and corner pieces though... https://www.amazon.com/Shengshou-7x7x7-Cube-Puzzl-black/dp/B009UFG67W https://www.amazon.com/Shengshou-7x7x7-Cube-Puzzl-black/dp/B...
- NeoTar 2y agoYou are correct, the 7 x 7 x 7 is the minimum where a perfect cube of cubes is impossible. The Wikipedia article shows the issue with the corner cubes. Apparently the 7-cube bulges slightly which helps to hide that the larger sized edges / corners https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-Cube_7 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-Cube_7
- dllu 2y ago3D printing technology is amazing now. I used to struggle with my ABS prints warping 12 years ago with a PP3DP --- I couldn't even print a giant 3x3x3 rubik's cube that worked. Now there are lots of 3D printers that are essentially just zero configuration and everything works out of the box. I even printed a lens mount for my camera and it came out quite well aligned. So it is very nice to see some regular consumer 3D printers being good enough for a functional 34 x 34 x 34 cube.
- ksymph 2y agoSmall error: Oskar van Deventer's 17x17 is at 2009 in the timeline, but the description says 2011.
- corry 2y agoA few months ago I learned to solve the classic 3x3x3 using the beginner's method [0]. Basically, you memorize a set of algorithms based on the current state of the cube and what overall stage of solving you're at (you first solve the white layer, then the middle layer, then the final layer). What's funny is that I feel no compulsion to learn other methods, no compulsion to get faster at it, no compulsion to move up to larger cubes like 4x4x4 etc. I just find it soothing and meditative. In fact, doing a few cubes has replaced some amount of doom-scrolling for me. Hard to describe exactly. Scratches some hand-eye / brain-motor itch. [0] This is the guide I used: https://assets.ctfassets.net/r3qu44etwf9a/6kAQCoLmbXXu29TTuArrk1/404118e1f9bfb6f9997157a284bbc572/Rubiks_Solution-Guide_3x3.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/r3qu44etwf9a/6kAQCoLmbXXu29TTuA...
- Snacklive 2y agoYes, i understand perfectly this is exactly what i do with my cube, it is sitting in my desk and i give it a few solves daily, it really helps to keep my mental in a good state. I will probably buy another this time stickerless to not worry about them deteriorating over time
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 64x64cube 2y ago[dead]