6 ms·
> Some alternative theories I've come across: > - There's a theory that cholesterol is good for you. It's necessary for brain functioning. Low levels of "bad" c
by Aurornis 2y ago
> Some alternative theories I've come across:
> - There's a theory that cholesterol is good for you. It's necessary for brain functioning. Low levels of "bad" cholesterol have been linked to depression.
These aren’t alternative theories, they’re just reductive takes that try to ignore the big picture.
Reductive takes are really seductive for people who want to reduce everything into “good” or “bad” categories, but the body doesn’t work like that.
The part that confuses people is that the message has been simplified to “cholesterol bad” for so long that people are confused to discover that cholesterol is actually used by the body. Upon discovering these facts, reductive logic switches from “cholesterol bad” to “cholesterol good”, which is just as reductive.
The truth is that cholesterol is useful within the body, but that doesn’t mean that more of it is better. Despite all of the proponents of alternative theories trying to spin a different story, the bottom line is that cumulative lifetime LDL exposure is still correlated with heart disease.
That is the only thing you need to know about the debate if you want to reduce it to something simple. More LDL over time means more heart disease. A lot of people will try to “well actually…” various things around this, but it’s true.
Even the comments below are trying to tell you your own observation is impossible (that diet can’t affect cholesterol levels) when that’s clearly not true.
Cholesterol has become a hotbed of alternative medicine that doesn’t follow the science but sells well on social media. Don’t put too much confidence behind “alternative theories” when we have decades of evidence that excessively high cholesterol levels over a lifetime are correlated with heart disease.
- KempyKolibri 2y agoJust want to say you have solid takes. You're getting all my upvotes. Thanks for fighting the good fight against this kind of nonsense.
- perrygeo 2y ago> excessively high cholesterol levels over a lifetime are correlated with heart disease You're talking about blood cholesterol levels. Yet we're talking about dietary cholesterol. Totally different things, it's now well known that they're unrelated. The cholesterol in our bodies is produced by the liver by a completely different process. The old science is pretty foolish for assuming dietary -> blood cholesterol, as if we didn't have a digestive system. If your point was "stick to the settled science and don't believe the alternatives" you couldn't have picked a worse example. To the original topic, dietary saturated fat does appear to increase the risk of heart disease by increasing LDL cholesterol. In other words, blood cholesterol is a problem but it's driven, at least partly, by saturated fat intake. High dietary cholesterol food like eggs do not increase serum levels, unless you deep fry them in butter.
- KempyKolibri 2y agoThey are related, dietary cholesterol does affect serum cholesterol: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30596814/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30596814/
- davebrown10 2y agoExperimentally and experientially, saturated fat has no lasting impact on cholesterol levels. Those are genetically determined. https://www.ketogenicforums.com/t/dave-feldman-its-about-energy-not-cholesterol/29312 https://www.ketogenicforums.com/t/dave-feldman-its-about-ene... Serum levels of saturated fat are not related to dietary saturated fat intake. https://news.osu.edu/study-doubling-saturated-fat-in-the-diet-does-not-increase-saturated-fat-in-blood/ https://news.osu.edu/study-doubling-saturated-fat-in-the-die... What puts a person at risk for chronic inflammatory diseases is excessive polyunsaturated fatty acid intake; in particular, arachidonic acid. Excerpt: "The Mediterranean diet is low in arachidonic acid and rich in healthy fats such as monounsaturated fats found in extra-virgin olive oil (EVOO), nuts and omega-3 fatty acids from fish, which has been shown to lower the risk of inflammation, heart disease, cancer, diabetes and obesity, and other degenerative diseases." https://advancedmolecularlabs.com/blogs/news/new-red-meat-study-controversy https://advancedmolecularlabs.com/blogs/news/new-red-meat-st... In the middle decades of the 20th Century the heart attack rate was extremely high. Much of that mortality is likely attributable to the release of heavy metals into the environment. Heavy metals such as lead tend to cause arterial plaques to rupture. Excerpt: It must be theoretically expected that there will be a synergistic (multiplicative) interaction between low Se intake (leading to undersaturation of the blood plasma with selenoprotein P), large exposure to toxic heavy metals (which may be expected to lead to simultaneous inhibition of selenoprotein P and extracellular thioredoxin reductase), a high dietary LA/oleic acid intake ratio and high rates of superoxide anion radical production from endothelial NADPH oxidase as causes of more rapid LDL oxidation - with a high rate of LDL oxidation leading in turn to high rates of atheromatosis development. Against this background it is not unreasonable to speculate that excessive exposure to a number of toxic metals from a wide range of different sources may have been one of the main causes of the post-war epidemic of coronary heart disease both in North America and Western Europe. These include lead from car exhaust and from drinking water (especially in the British Isles), as well as mercury and silver from dental amalgam fillings and cadmium from acid rain, commercial fertilizers and tobacco smoke...This hypothesis would appear to be in reasonably good agreement with what is known about the historical curves both for coronary heart disease mortality and for the use of lead as an additive in gasoline in Western Europe, compared to North America. The use of lead as an additive in gasoline started earlier and ended earlier in the United States than it did in the countries of Western Europe. And the epidemic of coronary heart disease has followed a similar time course with both its start and its culmination occurring earlier in the United States than in Western Europe." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3031257/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3031257/
- jodrellblank 2y ago> "More LDL over time means more heart disease." ... in the Standard American Diet. Dr Paul Mason's video "The truth about high cholesterol"[1] at 9:40 he cites a study showing that increasing levels of "light buoyant undamaged LDL" do not correlate with increased heart disease risk over 15 years and 11,000 subjects. Then at 10:20 shows study results that increased levels of oxidised, damaged, small, dense LDL do correlate with increased heart disease. IIRC it's damaged by oxidation, glycation, plant phytosterol cholesterol-mimics (driven by increased seed oil consumption) and involved with disruption to lipid rafts which some medications cause, e.g. statins and anti-psychotics. That talk is 1 of 3, they are here: [1] The Truth about high cholesterol: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdgS3PuSuyg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdgS3PuSuyg "can we tell if we have normal or damaged LDL? Yes" Part 2: The shady truth about statins: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7r4j1u42V8& https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7r4j1u42V8& (studies showing they do lower cholesterol, and that doesn't lower the risk of heart disease). Part 3: "Hard science on the real cause of heart disease - why you should avoid seed oils" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-xCr3mvFCHM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-xCr3mvFCHM [2] A comment I've made before about his views on saturated fats generally: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32966148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32966148 linking to his talk "Saturated Fat is not dangerous" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUY_SDhxf4k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUY_SDhxf4k "Why your doctor thinks cholesterol is bad" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-nq60_oEIc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-nq60_oEIc
- KempyKolibri 2y agoThe problem with the “lbLDL is harmless” argument is that, while it was an interesting theory ten years ago, we have very strong evidence this is not the case now. I could go through exactly why people thought this is the case, and why the hypothesis turned out to be wrong, but this paper does a better job than I could: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7369156 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7369156 Paul Mason is a renowned spreader of misinformation on this topic (and many others). My favourite moment of his is when he tried to teach a clinical research scientist that the lipid hypothesis was false, and in doing so revealed that his entire argument against the lipid hypothesis was based on an undergraduate-level misreading of a study, after which he just ran away from the conversation instead of admitting he was wrong. Absolute chef’s kiss moment, enjoy: https://x.com/avibittmd/status/1335491375073271808?s=46 https://x.com/avibittmd/status/1335491375073271808?s=46