3 ms·
>in a couple decades there won't be many people who can write seems quite wrong to me. If anything the trend seems to go the other way - when I was younger pr
by tim333 2y ago
>in a couple decades there won't be many people who can write
seems quite wrong to me.
If anything the trend seems to go the other way - when I was younger pre internet most communication was face to face or voice over the phone.
Now the predominant thing seems text - sms, whatsapp, this text box I'm typing into now. I saw a stat the other day that online / app dating had gone from a minority to over 50% of how couple meet. And that is mostly a combination of some photos and text. Be able to write text or fade from the gene pool!
That said long form text may be different but those who write novels and the like were always a minority.
(source for the dating thing - not sure how accurate but kind of scary https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1fzqgvk/how_couples_met_19302024/ https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1fzqgvk/...)
- safety1st 2y ago10-15 years ago I think this take was correct, the Internet was about writing. It isn't anymore, not for newer generations - e.g. Gen Z spending most of their time on Tiktok and phones, and not knowing how to use a word processor. In the span of ~30 years pg is talking about I can absolutely imagine some job where you speak to the AI and it writes the documents for you and you never learned how to write one yourself. It will not be a good job but millions of people will hold it. They will not be able to write with much sophistication themselves ergo they will not be able to think with much sophistication either. Online dating is not about writing. It was before Tinder, but it's not anymore. Like Instagram, it's about being skilled with photo filters and/or hiring a professional photographer. No one bothers to hire a profile writer - because no one reads the profile. If the other person's photos are hawt you will click a button and the AI will send some funny jokes and if you're hawt too you'll share locations and shag. Idiocracy or some Eloi/Morlocks world will be real
- hackable_sand 2y agoLess internet for you. More going outside for you.
- tim333 2y agoCurious about your hypothesis, I went on Tiktok and clicked trending. The top thing (clips from Superstore I think) had 16535 text comments on it though mostly stuff like >"Don't you hate Tuesdays?" "AHHHHHH" so not really long-form essays. Maybe the future is that stuff?
- astrobe_ 2y agoThe present is already non-written communication with Emojis. This supports TFA's thesis, as these forms of communication are about emotions, not thinking. Maybe it is a bit unfair to pick a media that focuses on video/image, though.
- amadeuspagel 2y agoTikTok videos are embedded in text -- titles, usernames, descriptions, comments. It's very different from TV, and if anything if it replaces TV it will make newer generations more literate, not less.
- Swizec 2y ago> It isn't anymore, not for newer generations - e.g. Gen Z spending most of their time on Tiktok and phones, and not knowing how to use a word processor. This is a classic fallacy as old as society. “Whatever the hoi polloi are doing is by definition not the good stuff”. But long-term whatever the masses are doing always wins. You know Shakespeare? He was the rube who thought plays could be entertaining to the masses. How quaint and silly, who would expect a commoner to appreciate a play. pfft. Mozart? Taylor Swift of his day. Printing press? Don’t even get me started, ew the commoners think they can just, like, write things down? How rude. I’m as much an anti-fan of the short video communication trend as anyone, but it works. When bandwidth is cheap and video recording ubiquitous, video is a great medium. Who cares what you say, show me. edit to add an uncomfortable truth: The in-crowd talks to develop ideas. What you see in writing is weeks, months, or even years behind the bleeding edge.
- samatman 2y agoThere should be a term for the fallacy on display here. The Spurious Generalization Fallacy perhaps? At no point did you address whether the shifting habits of younger generations will be bad for their literacy, instead making a general point that new trends in society are routinely panned by older members of such a society. As a counterpoint, before radio and the phonograph, musical ability was quite widespread. Now, it's much rarer. You haven't even attempted to address whether various developments in society and technology might do this to literacy the way earlier trends did to musical skills. I think that result is quite likely, by the way.
- Swizec 2y ago> You haven't even attempted to address whether various developments in society and technology might do this to literacy the way earlier trends did to musical skills. I think that result is quite likely, by the way. Fair, I was making a different point. Yes literacy might be reduced, my argument is that this isn’t necessarily a problem. Our abilities shift to take advantage of technology. A lot like how we got really bad at memorizing long epics because we can just write them down instead. That said, I don’t think writing/literacy will go away as much as we might fear. The new technologies are not a good enough replacement (yet?)
- dig1 2y agoThe issue with the modern internet is that it's primarily used for communication (via short writing), often resulting in poorly written messages. Animals communicate through sounds, but this doesn't mean they can talk. I agree with PG on this point and have noticed that people around me are often surprised when they receive well-written wsapp/sms messages that include proper punctuation and other linguistic markers. Additionally, many people rarely engage in handwriting today, and handwriting is known to improve clear thinking and literacy skills.
- watwut 2y agoWhich is still massively more then amount of writing people did pre-internet.
- brabel 2y ago> Which is still massively more then amount of writing people did pre-internet. I wonder if your answer it intentionally badly written or that's a sign of the problem already affecting even us on HN :D
- thih9 2y ago> That said long form text may be different but those who write novels and the like were always a minority. I think this is the article’s point - that this minority is going to shrink even more.
- screye 2y agoThat minority only flourished for a brief period in the 20th century when universal literacy was achieved through schooling and proliferation of white collar work. For most of history, writers were a tiny minority. It exploded 100x in the last few decades. If it goes down 10x, it's still way above where we were in the 1800s.
- thih9 2y agoThat's a fascinating point of view, thanks for sharing. I know that the concept of dark ages is overblown, but still - something about relying on AI like this makes me think of the end of classical antiquity.