3 ms·
> The expectation in SF is that population will increase and the housing supply will not be allowed to increase, so occupants will have to pay more in the futur
by eru 2y ago
> The expectation in SF is that population will increase and the housing supply will not be allowed to increase, so occupants will have to pay more in the future, creating the expectation of future appreciation.
See, I don't understand this.
So I grant you that rents will increase in SF. That's what you are describing. (Conversely, current rents are lower than rents in five years; and there's no market mechanism to bring that rent increase from 2030 to 2025.)
But I don't get the proposed mechanism to turn that relative discount of 2025-compared-to-2030 rents into a relative discount of 2025-compared-to-2030 house prices.
There's a clear mechanism in the markets to bring assets prices from the future to the present, but there's no clean mechanism to bring rent increases from the future to the present.
That's because you can buy a house now, and hold it for the next five years. But you can't turn a 2025 month of rental services into a 2030 month of rental services.
> The expectation in Ohio is that the population will be approximately flat and new construction will be less inhibited, so expected housing price appreciation there might be less than competing investments. That discourages external investors, but the current-day prices are still held at their current level from demand by local residents because they still need somewhere to live.
That argument seems very confused to me.
So is the return to funds invested in housing in Ohio higher or lower than in San Francisco? (That includes both capital appreciation and rental income (or the 'opportunity profits' [0] of not having to pay rent)).
You seem to be mixing up (imputed) rental income and the cost of houses as a capital good.
Local residents are responsible for the rent in either place. Both of us agree that we expects rents to grow quicker in San Francisco than in Ohio.
> Investors could then come in and bid up the current price in anticipation of this, but they'll only do this until the current price rises to match the risk-adjusted returns from competing investments.
> That discourages external investors, but the current-day prices are still held at their current level from demand by local residents because they still need somewhere to live.
Contrasting these two sentences, looks exactly backwards from what we are trying to explain? You need to explain why current house prices in San Francisco are so _low_, and Ohio house prices are so _high_, both compared to their expected 2030 levels.
[0] I'm not sure if 'opportunity profits' is an established term. I mean the opposite of 'opportunity costs': the imputed implicit profit of avoided costs.