5 ms·
I volunteer as a mentor in a group where most mentees are recent college grads or early 20s juniors. ADHD is a perennial topic of discussion because most of the
by Aurornis 2y ago
I volunteer as a mentor in a group where most mentees are recent college grads or early 20s juniors. ADHD is a perennial topic of discussion because most of them (no exaggeration) have either received a diagnosis or have self-diagnosed as ADHD.
One very common struggle I see is when they take internet advice that tells them it’s okay to offload their own struggles on to other people. Unfortunately this blog gives similar advice:
> Focus on managing how your limitations affect others rather than trying to eliminate those limitations. This means:
> Being explicitly upfront about your administrative weaknesses early in relationships
> Giving trusted contacts alternative ways to reach you when truly urgent
> Building a reputation for being aware of your limitations rather than in denial about them
This commonly translates to them adopting ADHD as part of their public persona within the company, which they believe will grant them some degree of protection from consequences.
From what I’ve observed: More often than not this provides a false sense of security. They don’t intend for it to become a free pass, but after “coming out” as ADHD they get the wrong impression that the pressure is now off.
I think they intend to continue working on becoming better at managing their struggles, but it’s really easy to let the opposite happen: Once they think their diagnosis can be used as an excuse, they relax and let their behavior slip even further.
So be careful about getting the wrong idea from this line of thinking. It is good to acknowledge your difficulties and do things like ask other people to follow up if you don’t reply in a timely manner. It is important that you own up when you’ve dropped the ball. However, none of these things should be interpreted as a free pass or a loophole that shields you from consequences. That line of thinking, in my experience, is where people get themselves in trouble.
- ok_dad 2y agoImagine telling a quadriplegic something like this, though. The neurodiverse, which ADHD is a part, are always being told we still need to measure up to the standards of the non-disabled in some form or another. It’s always about how we shouldn’t offload our struggles on others. There’s no wheelchair for us, almost no one cares if our workplaces aren’t accommodating.
- falcolas 2y ago100% this. This often manifests as "It's not your fault but it is your responsibility." Which is a great thinking framework when it helps you accept what you have and do what you can do mitigate it. But here's the kicker: our "what we can do" will never be enough to be neurotypical. We'll need help, even when we're using all our coping mechanisms. And if we don't get that help, the outcome is simple: we're going to fail.
- exmadscientist 2y agoIn my experience, the line is drawn, brightly, in one place: does the "disabled" person genuinely try to work with others, or do they expect to be given a free pass because they played the disability card? I have worked with some severely disabled people. (Probably more than you have, given one of my past jobs.) Most of them worked their ass off to make things work out and for that they have my eternal respect, my cooperation, and the benefit of the doubt. I have also worked with some people who just throw their hands up and say "but I'm disabled" whenever they are asked to do anything they don't want to do. I do not respect those people.
- falcolas 2y agoWhat kind of disabilities? Visible (missing or non-functional limbs) or invisible (chronic pain, adhd, depression) ones? More specifically, how do you know whether they could or couldn't do the things you were asking them to do, especially if it was an invisible disability? Doing it before isn't a good indicator. Other people with the same disability doing it isn't a good indicator. Not visibly trying isn't a good indicator. Having a blowout (or not) isn't a good indicator. Being too tired (or too wired) isn't a good indicator.
- lazide 2y agoThe issue here is at the end of the day, there is work to do, and results matter. Everyone has finite shits to give. If everything is going fine, other people will often be willing to pick up slack or adjust. If other people are exhausted, overworked, or have no more shits to give - they won’t. Or more precisely, at some point they can’t. Or suffer negative outcomes themselves. Disabilities are called that because they make things harder, for the people who have them, and for those around them. Same with disorders.
- bippihippi1 2y agoI think it's valid to still hold people to a certain standard, but the standard is adjusted to match your disability while focusing on executing the core job functions. * Don't you think we would be on time if we could? * It's not a matter of trying harder. Yes we still have to do our core job functions the same as anyone else, but it's not fair to measure us on a quality the disability affects. We don't get to ask a partially blind person to just look harder. We give them accommodations that let them do their job without relying on seeing. It's called accommodation, not shielding from consequences. I get to be late because I am not able to be always punctual. So my job has to accommodate me to help me do my job without relying on being on time. Just because I can sometimes try hard and be on time doesn't mean it's not a disability.
- throwup238 2y agoAlmost anyone can diagnose if a person is blind if they’re acting in good faith but ADHD is far harder to pin down. At the moment the layman standard seems to be “can you convince a doctor/nurse practitioner to prescribe you amphetamines?” The ADA covers mental disabilities like ADHD so anyone who actually needs accommodations can receive them if they follow the proper channels and get a legitimate doctor specializing in ADHD to diagnose them. In a career spanning nearly two decades I’ve only ever met one other person who followed the proper ADA accommodation route with HR (as opposed to accommodations for blindness, deafness, or chronic pain which were legion). Speaking for myself, even with a legit diagnosis it was little more than a cover and self justification for drug abuse (yay NP who prescribed both Vyvanse and Adderall).
- bippihippi1 2y agohow does you thinking some people fake disabilities and that you have a substance problem have anything to do with my comment on people framing accommodations as an excuse to slack off? Are you suggesting that you think your diagnosis is invalid and that should be taken as a data point in our discussion? I think the answer is for you to stop taking drugs, not that there aren't people woth ADHD who need accommodations to do their job well. It's also not anyone else's job to diagnose you but your doctor.
- satisfice 2y agoThis is why I don’t want to be diagnosed. I only claim to have probable ADHD when I am trying to help other people who do or might do. Without claiming any disability, I say what I’m good at and offer to do it. I am respected for what I contribute and forgiven for what I don’t. I married someone who does planning, she married someone who makes money on his ideas. She runs my business, I talk to clients and teach my classes and (slowly) write books.
- TomK32 2y ago> One very common struggle I see is when they take internet advice that tells them it’s okay to offload their own struggles on to other people. Unfortunately this blog gives similar advice: Sorry, but this is necessary though. Russell Barkley (he has a great Youtube channel) suggests a strict regime for children with ADHD (even with medication) and even as adults will need to inform those closest to us because we work differently. I don't want a free pass, what I need is someone giving me tasks that I can break into smaller pieces and get a feedback loop going for those so I won't loose track or get distracted. Diagnosis is an important step, but it has to follow for most with medication and for all with psychosocial work which can have negative side-effects.