3 ms·
You can do the same thing with any compiled language, but I suppose that's a feature of Go since it's a compiled language.
by TazeTSchnitzel 14y ago
You can do the same thing with any compiled language, but I suppose that's a feature of Go since it's a compiled language.
- riobard 14y agoYou can do the same thing with any compiled language This is not necessarily true. Remember the DLL hell? Go does not support dynamic linking at all (some say this is a disadvantage), so you are forced to produce a single self-contained binary.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoDLL hell only happens if you use dynamic linking. Static linking is always an option. (actually, is it? I don't tend to use a lot of libraries, how much stuff that isn't part of the OS can you not statically link?)
- Strom 14y agoI belive you need to also provide re-linking mechanisms for your customers if you statically link something licensed under LGPL.
- podperson 14y agoDLL hell happened (in Windows) because you had to dynamically link against system libraries which could change in incompatible ways making your code fragile. Depending on the nature of the development toolset, you may not be able to avoid DLL hell. E.g. you may not have the right to build the library into your code and/or the toolset may force you to link against external code libraries. The original goal of Microsoft's DLL strategy was to save disk space (and presumably memory) but the end result was a compatibility nightmare. Retrospectively, it seems to have been both a bad technical decision (disk space turned out to be a bad thing to trade against other considerations) and badly implemented (too many DLLs went live and then broke backwards compatibility in updates). It seems like other companies managed to allow dynamic linking without creating so much fragility.
- gouranga 14y agoIt's a great idea and still is. Linux does pretty much the same thing. It actually broke because they didn't allow multiple versions and windows linked to the latest version at runtime. They fixed all this with WinSXS which allows a PE file to specify a manifest i.e. a list of required versions of DLLs to load. This is all neatly explained here: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa376307.aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa376307.aspx
- tedunangst 14y agoIt would be more accurate to say dll hell happened because vendors decided to install their 3rd party dependencies in the windows directory. There are not as many problems with actual Microsoft dlls.
- 4ad 14y ago> Static linking is always an option. Not if you use C and glibc (most common combination of them all, most software requires glibc). Even if you compile glibc statically in your program (not an option by default at least in Ubuntu), glibc itself will load more shared objects at runtime.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoOh, huh, I didn't know about that.
- yorhel 14y agoI've had very positive experiences with statically linking against musl[1], As long as your code and the required libraries don't use dlopen() tricks (e.g. as glib GIO does), you can quite reliably create a single statically linked binary for your program. Admittedly, this isn't as easy to setup as Go is. [1] http://www.etalabs.net/musl/ http://www.etalabs.net/musl/
- tedunangst 14y agoYou can statically link if you also compile a static glibc with modules disabled. But it's a pita and you can still have kernel compat problems.
- genbattle 14y agoWith other languages such as C/C++ if you link a library into your program statically, that library may dynamically load other dependencies. In Go, all dependencies have to be statically compiled into that package. Rob Pike made a good point about this in one of the Go talks [1] (I think it was the "Meet the Go team" talk) when they were talking about package management and the static linking, and how in C++ you could get massive chains of useless includes (I think is came out of a question on the speed of the Go compiler). His reasoning was that all the code you need to compile a package should be in the one package binary. You shouldn't need to worry about having other 3rd-party packages that your dependency depends on installed on the target system. [1] http://blog.golang.org/2012/07/go-videos-from-google-io-2012.html http://blog.golang.org/2012/07/go-videos-from-google-io-2012...
- pjmlp 14y ago> In Go, all dependencies have to be statically compiled into that package. This is not true. If you make use of cgo, the dependencies are linked dynamically.
- 4ad 14y agoUsing cgo is an exception rather than the rule, and when Rob talks about package dependencies he means any file required for building that package, not only the shared objects. This includes C/C++ header files. Even with cgo, to use a package that uses cgo you only need that package archive, you need not care about what files that created that package.
- pjmlp 14y agoLike in every other compiled language that has modules.
- genbattle 14y agoYes, you are right. I was referring to pure Go packages.