3 ms·
Are you a manager? If so you need to keep these two points in mind: 1) The reason the oplympics works is that you can rank people accurately down to within mi
by tomjen3 14y ago
Are you a manager?
If so you need to keep these two points in mind:
1)
The reason the oplympics works is that you can rank people accurately down to within miliseconds. And peoples success doesn't depend on others help.
2)
If the bonus pool is fixed, you can give everybody the same one year if that makes sense given the input and one year you can give something to one guy and more to the rest. You can't do that with a fixed band system. That is its key flaw.
- it 14y agoAlso, if you are working on a team then the incentives should be based on team performance, not individual performance. You get what you reward.
- grandalf 14y agoI was not arguing that a team based bonus is not also a good idea. In my experience three qualities that are very unevenly distributed are motivation, initiative, and talent. Depending on the business some combination of these represents the ideal employee.
- it 14y agoAlso, if you are working on a team then the incentives should be based on team performance, not individual performance. You get what you reward.
- grandalf 14y agoWell if the manager can't define a system that everyone buys into for measuring results, there is a problem. Ultimately it's going to be a judgement call to some extent. The bands are just there to force the manager to avoid adding noise to the signal. If she has to follow the rule and allocate bonuses w/in the bands, she doesn't have to be the bad guy.
- huggyface 14y ago1) The reason the Olympics works is that you can rank people accurately down to within miliseconds Aside from things like diving, ice dancing and synchronized swimming, though supporting your statement those activities are absolutely loaded with controversy because the subjective nature -- as opposed to the objective reality of a stopwatch -- leads to endless differences of opinion. Ranking makes sense if you have objective measures. In this industry there are staggeringly few, especially for large internal teams working on parts of a whole. Everyone has agendas and imperfect knowledge, everyone has bias and self-serving judgments.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI personally feel that anything where the words "and the judges' scores are ..." get uttered shouldn't be an Olympic sport.