10 ms·
The major problem I see with QR Codes is that they tend to be 'naked'. They're an opaque blob of stuff and it's not clear what I'm going to get for scanning one
by jgrahamc 14y ago
The major problem I see with QR Codes is that they tend to be 'naked'. They're an opaque blob of stuff and it's not clear what I'm going to get for scanning one. They seriously need to be accompanied by some sort of text and it would be ideal if there were some standard for how that text was presented so I can quickly figure out if it's worth scanning.
This is especially true of QR Codes because the use of them in public is asking people and not machines to interact with them. Contrast with barcodes and MICR codes which were primarily there to be read by machine but both are human readable (almost all barcodes have their number equivalent below them).
- corin_ 14y agobut both are human readable (almost all barcodes have their number equivalent below them) I think it's worth keeping in mind that this sort of "human readable" is very different to what you suggest (and I agree with) QR codes need. One is "here's a backup for if the code doesn't work" and one is "here's prose about what this QR code takes you to".
- evilduck 14y agoQR codes don't even have to take you anywhere. The code can contain email addresses, phone numbers, phone numbers + SMS message text, calendar information, plain text, vCard data, etc. QRs containing URLs are the most common in my experience, but you'd probably need a HTML5 badge system* to convey what the QR code contained if you didn't want to spell it out right next to the code. * http://clubajax.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/HTML5Icons1.png http://clubajax.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/HTML5Icons1.p...
- shill 14y agoGood idea, but UPC codes contain only 12 digits which can be nested neatly under the machine readable portion. It requires significantly more print area to represent a human readable QR code body. Maybe standard icons and a domain name (or phone number) could help identify the protocol and contents? The article also mentions that QR code readers are not widely installed. I think this will become less of an issue in "the future" when we will use our smart phones to interface with everything--refrigerators, drip irrigation systems, door locks, automobiles, etc. When that happens, consumers will demand phones with OEM scanning software and a dedicated scanning button.
- flogic 14y agoI think the primary problem with QR codes is the whole dance you have to do to read them. I have to notice the QR code. Pull out my phone. Wake it up. Load the QR app. Point it at the QR code. Really you want to have QR codes automatically read by looking at then and stored in some sort of buffer until you give a crap or they expire.
- vilhelm_s 14y agoThis seems like a nice use for augmented reality. Once we are all wearing Google Glass clones, they could automatically superimpose the decoded QR data next to the code.