5 ms·
Novell did something similar. They used to fire IIRC the 'bottom' 10% every year. This HBS article talks about the system: http://hbr.org/2001/05/leading-throu
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Novell did something similar. They used to fire IIRC the 'bottom' 10% every year. This HBS article talks about the system: http://hbr.org/2001/05/leading-through-rough-times-an-interview-with-novells-eric-schmidt/ar/1 http://hbr.org/2001/05/leading-through-rough-times-an-interv... Interestingly, Eric Schmidt seems to have modified it a bit and seen that it wasn't working well.
"Incidentally, not all systemic changes work. I’ve also learned that certain management techniques can actually make things worse when applied to a distressed culture. For example, I had always worked in companies with yearly and quarterly employee ranking systems, in which people were divided into three groups: overperforming, performing, and underperforming. So not long after I came here, we started a ranking program that graded on a curve: 45% into the overperforming group, 50% into the performing group, and 5% into the underperforming group. I didn’t know—and certainly didn’t intend it this way—that if you got the lowest grade, it was presumed that you were about to be fired. We started getting hate mail from people who argued that there was no way to rank people who worked as a team. The ranking system exacerbated the culture of fear and proved to be such a huge retention and motivation issue that we were forced to stop it after a year. In its place, we introduced a modified ranking program that better reflected overall employee performance."
- thaumasiotes 14y agoIt seems like one factor in that scheme that would imply you're going to fire "underperformer"s is that 95% of people can't be classified that way. The names are symmetric; why not something more like 20% - 60% - 20%? The other factor would be that there's an idea (which I can't speak to personally) that the only purpose of performance evaluations is to protect the company in case a fired employee sues to reinstate their job, which would mean that an "underperforming" grade was a necessary prereq to firing.
- silverbax88 14y agoThe overall flaw in this system is that it assumes that there are always people worth firing. But some companies - and let's think of smaller start ups as an example - try to hire really well, and there are some shops that are loaded with talented people. Stacking them and firing the 'worst' performers because of a metric is basically just cutting talent. My take is that if a company thinks they have 10% of people on staff worth firing every year, fix the hiring process - that's the problem.
- rcthompson 14y agoFiring the bottom 10% company-wide is quite different from firing the bottom 10% from each department, regardless of the performance of that department relative to others, which is closer to what the article describes for Microsoft. As the original article noted, being in a 10-person "unit" meant that 1 out of those ten was guaranteed a bad review, even if that unit as a whole somehow generated 50% of Microsoft's profits for the quarter.
- Elepsis 14y agoThe article is completely wrong on this point. In 99% of cases, people are stacked in a sufficiently large group that everyone on your immediate team could hypothetically get a great review.
- Umofomia 14y agoWhile that's true, it is also reliant on the fact that the manager of your immediate team be able to effectively argue for your team members during the stack-ranking meeting. If you happen to have a manager that ends up being too reticent, many of the underperforming scores could end up being disproportionately assigned to your team.
- Elepsis 14y agoYou're definitely right on that. However, if your manager isn't willing or able to effectively argue for your team members, it doesn't matter what the review system is: you'll still get screwed.
- krishnakv 14y agoRead the article closely it says "Every current and former Microsoft employee I interviewed—every one—cited stack ranking as the most destructive process inside of Microsoft, something that drove out untold numbers of employees". Are you saying the employees were lying or that the interviewee misheard? Its not possible to argue against this point. Also, what you say about a sufficiently large group never happens. What actually happens is each lower level manager is forced to rank his or her team members along the curve so as to make the process "fair". And inevitably, this gives rise to a large host of harmful behaviors - slacking off on work by people who have low self esteem as they will get ranked low "anyways", grandstanding, people trying to take credit for others work, infighting, corporate politics, people waking up and starting to work hard closer to the appraisal cycle to capitalize on the "recency effect", dysfunctional teams that deliver only because of heroic efforts from a couple of the team members. Any system can be gamed this one has got gamed out long ago, my experience - I have seen it do nothing but harm in every single case.
- iterationx 14y agoThat was an idea they (probably) stole from Jack Welsh. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve