4 ms·
How Excessive Red Meat Consumption Increases Colorectal Cancer Risk
- bell-cot 2y agoSummary: In the lab, using selected "standard lines" of cancer cells, it looked fairly plausible that iron encourages the growth of colorectal cancer cells. Eating "excessive" red meat seems very likely cause high iron concentrations in your lower intestines. Beyond that - YMMV.
- cynicalpeace 2y agoSo it's a junk headline? Also, telomerase activation is heavily correlated with longevity and less risk of disease.
- riku_iki 2y agoPer dietaryguidelines.gov cereal contains 8 times more iron per calory than beef: https://www.dietaryguidelines.gov/resources/2020-2025-dietary-guidelines-online-materials/food-sources-select-nutrients/food-sources-iron https://www.dietaryguidelines.gov/resources/2020-2025-dietar...
- cynicalpeace 2y agoSo the answer is yes, lol
- Bluescreenbuddy 2y agoIs this why millennials and early genx are seeing higher rates
- photonthug 2y ago> Beyond that - YMMV. Looking at Inuit and Mongolian populations for stuff like this would likely be a good approach to actually learn stuff. Almost a strictly meat diet, but without all the confounding variables of sedentary office workers, industrial chemicals, and highly processed foods with tons of sugar.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stackghost 2y agoThere's more to it than diet. Genetics also plays a large role. I'd be leery of generalizing dietary advice across ethnicities.
- inglor_cz 2y ago... and microbiota, too. Colorectal cancer is located at the end of a very densely "populated" tube. In all likelihood, Inuit microbiota is very far from Western one, at least as long as they don't adapt Western diet.
- jollyllama 2y agoI wonder if tea, coffee, wine, phytate containing foods (beans, nuts) and calcium rich foods (dairy, etc) would counter the risk by blocking iron absorption.
- fyt2024 2y agoJust getting celiac disease would counter iron intake :-)
- tcdent 2y agoThe correlation with Iron makes me wonder if the polymerization of cooking oils is related. https://www.lodgecastiron.com/cleaning-and-care/cast-iron/science-cast-iron-seasoning https://www.lodgecastiron.com/cleaning-and-care/cast-iron/sc...
- Findecanor 2y agoI have heard of there having been earlier studies that have linked iron intake with colon cancer growth, and I have personal reason to believe them. I have Lynch syndrome: a hereditary cell mutation which increases risk of colon cancer. Patients like me get a colonoscopy every eighteen months or so only to remove polyps. For a decade I had not had a single polyp to remove. Then in 2022, I got another cancer which gave me blood deficiency (low hemoglobin levels), and just to keep myself alive I took strong iron supplements for months. It did of course also stress my immune system. I got colon cancer in record time, which surprised also my doctors. It grew from no visible polyp (my last colonoscopy) to two inches in nine months, and in-between that I had an X-ray that also showed nothing (but which can't detect tumors small enough).
- smm11 2y agoEverything in excess might be a problem. I guess the Standard American Diet is better, right?
- henning 2y agoOK. How much red meat do you need to eat to have the excessive high iron levels likely to trigger the behavior under consideration in the study? How much higher is the risk? Also, spinach has iron. So excessive spinach consumption at levels that most people couldn't tolerate could also increase colorectal cancer risk? Or no?
- ygouzerh 2y agoThat's a good question, spinach have the same type of iron than in red meat, iron-(Fe3+), so it seems that it could a culprit as well. It looks like however the absorption of iron in red meat is quite high (15%-35%) compared to spinach (2-5%), so maybe not enough to really be a risk factor.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stackghost 2y agoVegans, especially vegan women of menstruating age, are well known to be almost universally iron-deficient, because our bodies absorb iron from meats much more readily than other (such as vegan) sources. Interestingly, Vitamin C increases the rate at which you can get iron from greens such as spinach. So maybe a glass or orange juice and a bowl of salad a day keeps the doctor away.
- david-gpu 2y agoIf you want vitamin C without the sugar load of drinking orange juice, you may be interested to learn that bell peppers have a much higher content of vitamin C than oranges, either per gram or per calorie. Edit: Let me offer some USDA data points for those who are curious, but not curious enough to bother Googling for themselves. Red Bell Peppers: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/170108/nutrients https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/170108/n... Green Bell Peppers: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/2258588/nutrients https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/2258588/... Oranges: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/746771/nutrients https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/746771/n...
- m0llusk 2y agoIron supplements are often used, so it would be interesting to know if they also might be significant risk factors.
- adrian_b 2y agoThe iron supplements normally contain only reduced Fe(II) ions, because only those are soluble in water and easily absorbable in the intestine. This study identifies only the oxidized Fe(III) ions as causing cancer. The oxidized Fe(III) ions can have any effect in the intestine only when they are bound to organic molecules, like in blood or in red muscles. Otherwise, the oxidized Fe(III) ions form insoluble precipitates, which either pass through the intestine without any interaction, or they are reduced to soluble Fe(II), which is not harmful, but an essential nutrient. Nevertheless, an excessively high intake of iron supplements can have various harmful effects, like any other excessive food intake.
- fyt2024 2y agoI remember a paper long time ago that claimed that one reason why women have higher life spans than men is lower iron content in their blood due to menstruation.
- homarano 2y agoWomen have a consistently lower mortality rate than men at all ages 20-80 with no notable change around menopause. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Mortality-rate-for-men-and-women-1996-99-by-age-per-10-000-log-scale_fig1_233296283 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Mortality-rate-for-men-a...
- DiscourseFan 2y agoMen tend to be in higher risk situations more often than women.
- Beijinger 2y ago[flagged]
- averageRoyalty 2y agoPlease refrain from personal attacks.
- QuercusMax 2y agoHere's an interesting article that talks about sexual differences in life span, which seems to be correlated with the size of the sex chromosome: https://www.science.org/content/article/secret-long-life-matching-sex-chromosomes https://www.science.org/content/article/secret-long-life-mat... Basically, for whatever reason, a larger sex chromosome (X is much bigger than Y) confers a better chance of survival.
- tuatoru 2y agoI thought it was because females have two copies of the X, so defects in a region of one copy can be compensated for by the other. RAID-1 ftw.
- samatman 2y agoHeadline stripped of bullshit: "Fe(3+) reactivates telomerase of in vitro colorectal cancer cells".
- naming_the_user 2y agoIt pays to be careful with studies like this because even if the statement given is proven to be true, that does not logically imply that it is optimal to reduce red meat consumption. As a thought experiment (I'm completely making up these claims, but they do at least seem plausible), imagine a world in which regular coffee consumption resulted in some small increase in cancer risk, but then also regular coffee consumption was correlated with say, academic success, success at work, had some appetite suppressing effects, etc. If the latter outweighs the former then the cancer risk is probably worth it even just longevity wise. Like how we know that going out in the sun increases cancer risk but also is just, well, good for us, to a degree. But of course the media will just run with a headline, which is why it sometimes feels as if the science is constantly "changing".
- aziaziazi 2y agoAverage hn reader needs more sun exposure than he does because the vitD boost will probably worth the cancer risk. With red meat the known benefits peaks (way) lower than average consumption. I’m not an expert but that looks to be shown more than the opposite. On a personal anecdote my doctor tells last week optimum is at 1meal/2weeks. He’s maybe not aware of breaking discoveries but this looks to be in range with what’s discussed here and there. I like critical thinking nevertheless and it would be interesting to learn more.
- naming_the_user 2y agoRight. The question remains though about what we mean by "known benefits". I chose caffeine as an example because I think that it's completely nontrivial to calculate. The physical pathways of things like "well this makes that molecule do this and have some x% chance to mutate and so on and so you get cancer", or the statistical output of "well people in the coffee cohort have % higher rates of this cancer" are much easier to accurately study than things like "if you drink coffee you are 3% more likely to get into law school and therefore become significantly wealthier and probably live a longer/healthier life and we can measure that impact precisely". It's also not at all obvious that lifespan above all else is the thing to maximise. e.g. maybe red meat reduces lifespan but makes your 20s-60s more fun because you're likely to be more muscular or whatever. My personal feeling is that aside from really really bad things like smoking, heavy alcohol use, heroin etc the error bars are too large to make decisions purely on long-term health impact alone.
- throw_pm23 2y agoIs it the meat or the sodium nitrite used to cure it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_nitrite#Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_nitrite#Cancer
- adrian_b 2y agoThe research paper identifies as the cause of cancer the oxidized Fe(III) ions, which are bound to the hemoglobin from blood or to the myoglobin from red muscles. Those are the proteins with iron that give to blood the ability to transport oxygen and to red muscles the ability to store oxygen. Similar iron proteins, e.g. the so-called cytochromes, exist in all the cells of all aerobic living beings, but only in amounts many times lower than in the blood and red muscles of vertebrates. Most of the other iron ions that can be found in water, in food or in iron supplements are reduced Fe(II) ions, which are not involved in this cancer-causing process.
- otabdeveloper4 2y agoWe've reached a point where we're starting to literally die out as a species due to obesity and diabetes, and you're complaining about "possibly increased colorectal cancer risk"? Really?