6 ms·
“I see Microsoft as technology’s answer to Sears,” said Kurt Massey, a former senior marketing manager. “In the 40s, 50s, and 60s, Sears had it nailed. It was t
by mgkimsal 14y ago
“I see Microsoft as technology’s answer to Sears,” said Kurt Massey, a former senior marketing manager. “In the 40s, 50s, and 60s, Sears had it nailed. It was top-notch, but now it’s just a barren wasteland. And that’s Microsoft. The company just isn’t cool anymore.”
Probably the best line from the article.
The point about stack ranking - good observation. I've heard about it for years from MS people as well as mini-MS and such. It struck me as problematic even back then. In one way it's "just another internal policy", but it's pretty obvious it's going to create internal competition, which is the last thing a company needs.
I remember around 2000 or so - when the DOJ trial was going on - the stuff coming out of MS was "we're the underdog - we see everyone as competition or potential competition" (paraphrasing, obviously). I don't know where that mindset went, but the last decade, they've not really acted like it.
Gosh, I'm not saying this well. They have acted like it, but haven't chosen their battles well, perhaps. Trying to compete in dozens and dozens of competitive landscapes at the same time has led to little focus. Yes, "Office and Windows" are cash cows, but the respect (and fear) for MS is largely gone - they've squandered their image playing "me too" catchup in too many fields, and they've got a long way to go to be the leader in any field that they once were.
At least one tech generation, probably more, never experienced MS as the big leader to be feared - back in the mid 90's, any conceptual startup had to consider "what if MS gets in to this market?". You had to be able to answer that question. I doubt that's a question anyone has asked themselves in at least 10 years, if not more. Replace MS with "Google" or "Apple" and that would instantly make sense to today's crop of startups. But if you said MS, no one would even take you seriously.
- vessenes 14y agoI think the DOJ results had a big impact on that aggressive competitive spirit -- Microsoft sort of seemed to go into a quieter sort of ecosystem mode, where they used combined marketing launches and strategy to achieve the lock-in they had been just out and out dumping on consumers with technology. I would say the brio left after the DOJ trial, but it may be back with Surface. If Surface sells, I would expect a new CEO and an invigorated Microsoft.
- wcdolphin 14y agoWell, given how the DOJ treated MS, it is pretty clear that there was very little it could do in terms of integrating experiences without getting sued. Bundle a browser in your OS, get sued. Bundle a media player in your OS? Get sued. But Microsoft is in the middle of a huge culture shift, and it is doing things that are new, bold and targeted, unlike any company in the industry. Google is shooting blanks in every direction, hoping something won't just be a flash in the pan. Apple is cold and consistent, but given their record and how they treat developers, I would be surprised if they don't overplay their hand again. Amazon, on the other hand, is pretty awesome. Besides being a horrible company to work for, from all reports I have heard, they execute hard, fast and generally pretty well.
- chris_wot 14y agoTightly coupling products does not necessarily lead to greater innovation.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoBut it did lead to better user experience. Imagine buying an iPhone which was unable to play music and videos or surf the web, and if you tried to do those things it would tell you to go and download an app for it. The average user doesn't want to have to download some program to listen to an MP3. They want it to "just work". And that's what Microsoft did.
- chris_wot 14y agoI don't call 2 years between IE5 and IE6, then 5 years between IE6 and IE7 and then 3 years between IE7 and IE8 a "better user experience". Tell me again how tightly coupling the apps made things better?
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoFor the average user, an included, well-integrated browser makes surfing the web easier. Even if it's a PITA for web developers like me that they are using an outdated browser.
- Apocryphon 14y agoTrying to compete in dozens and dozens of competitive landscapes at the same time has led to little focus. Isn't this what happened to Sony in the '90s?