3 ms·
Microsoft CEO Nadella asked for pay reduction after security slip
- JacobThreeThree 2y agoIf he expects cybersecurity to be a factor for determining the compensation of other Microsoft employees, at least he's leading by example, even if it's not a really meaningful amount for him one way or another.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bko 2y agoThat's all well and good, but I think the reduction should be put in the proper context. From the article: > Nadella received $79.1 million for the fiscal year that ended June 30, up from $48.5 million in the prior year, according to a proxy filing Thursday. Most of his pay is in the form of stock. The board’s compensation committee said Nadella asked that the cash incentive portion reflect the security issues... It was originally supposed to be $10.66 million, but the full board approved a $5.2 million cash incentive instead. I personally do believe effective executives are often easily worth their salaries. Not moral worth of course but pure economics. For instance, consider when Nike hired CEO John Donahoe, their stock jumped 10% which was around $16bn. Now either Nike shareholders are stupid (maybe), or the strategic move to appoint Donahoe was worth billions even above his salary of ~$30 million.
- dataflow 2y ago> I personally do believe effective executives are often easily worth their salaries. Did you literally mean "salaries" here, or total compensation?
- bko 2y agoTotal compensation. To me how its split up is irrelevant although the board often prefers stock to have their incentives more in line with long term stock performance.
- dataflow 2y agoYeah I figured the same, just wanted to make sure because the stocks are a massive portion of the total compensation, so it's a more controversial stance to take!
- diggan 2y agoUnfortunately, the HN title misses (probably because of the char limit) the fact that his total compensation still went up: > Microsoft CEO Nadella asked for pay reduction after security slip, but total comp still rose 63% > Nadella received $79.1 million for the fiscal year that ended June 30, up from $48.5 million in the prior year, according to a proxy filing Thursday. Most of his pay is in the form of stock. The board’s compensation committee said Nadella asked that the cash incentive portion reflect the security issues. The ongoing sentiment remains true: There are no real punishments for security failures
- choppaface 2y agoAlso missing that he oversaw layoffs of 2550 https://www.eurogamer.net/microsoft-ceos-pay-rises-63-to-73m-despite-devastating-year-for-layoffs https://www.eurogamer.net/microsoft-ceos-pay-rises-63-to-73m...
- BadHumans 2y agoThis is a performance. His total compensation still rose 60% because like most CEOs, his real money comes from stock. You have CEOs taking 1 dollar salaries because the real money is in stock. > In June, Microsoft said it would consider employees’ cybersecurity efforts when determining their compensation. The reason for the performance, a way of saying "look I'm accountable too!" except not at all.
- chaos_emergent 2y agoGood on him, he’s getting ahead of bad PR before it can catch up to him and his company. That sounds like great leadership.
- jjmarr 2y agoFor reference, he cut his total comp for 2024 from $84.6 million to $79.1 million. That's 6.5% of his TC he gave up, and it wasn't a discretionary bonus. I wouldn't call this a symbolic gesture. Everyone here would feel a 6.5% cut to their TC. I don't believe anyone would ask their boss to cut their already vested RSUs because of a mistake. Especially when those RSUs went up 50% in value. Yes, there is no real punishment for CEOs anymore. That's why great leaders punish themselves. He beat his KPIs, looked at corporate output, and still rated himself as needs improvement. I respect anyone that does that.
- diggan 2y ago> That's why great leaders punish themselves Is it still a punishment if you still end up with a higher compensation compared to previous year?
- jjmarr 2y agoIf you got "needs improvement" on your performance review and missed your target bonus, but the company's stock went up 30% meaning your total compensation still increased, what would you expect? Would you consider that to be a fair punishment? The standard Nadella is setting is that cash bonuses needs to be determined by cybersecurity impact, and that expectation needs to be in every part of the company. So he cut his (non-discretionary) cash bonus by 50%. He could've cut his stock package as well, but you're not going to work at a company where meteoric increases in the stock price can be clawed back if your performance was bad. People would freak out and ask if their stock would be cut if a cybersecurity incident occurred.
- glimshe 2y agoA "needs improvement" is a kiss of death for a normal tech worker. For him, it makes him look humble and deserving of the tens of millions he'll get anyway. Gosh, he might even brag about it.
- wenc 2y agoYes, why would it not be? It’s still skin in the game. If we think it’s a symbolic gesture, which it may well be, it is still a gesture that most CEOs would not have made. Unlike most here, I don’t think with this he’s saying please punish me for wrongdoing, but more I take responsibility for this failure (which could have happened many levels below him) and will take the loss personally. Sounds like HN folks would love for Nadella to completely reduce his salary compared to last year. I don’t know that I agree. I’d say, let’s see you do it.
- SilverBirch 2y agoThis is a weird one. Does the $5m theoretical pay cut (a $30m real terms pay bump actually) reflect his personal commitment to security? Or does it reflect his massive massive personal wealth that means he can shrug off a $5m dent in his compensation? Or that taking the security problems seriously amounts to a dent in his pay so small that it still went up by $30m? Just strange. Good for the PR though - getting Microsoft in every newspaper next to the words "security slip" is great for the brand.
- diggernet 2y agoWhy did he need to punish himself? Isn't that the board's job?