3 ms·
What I don’t understand about quantum mechanics is the reason nature had to make things so damn complicated. What was the fundamental problem that led to the so
by elorant 14y ago
What I don’t understand about quantum mechanics is the reason nature had to make things so damn complicated. What was the fundamental problem that led to the solution of quantum entanglement, or the duality of the wave-particle situation.
- robertfw 14y agoMy gut tells me that the underlying reasons are elegantly simple; it is our imperfect understanding - and a long chain of knock on effects - that leads to complication
- aidenn0 14y agoArguably having separate waves and particles would be more complex, since there would be more entities.
- elorant 14y agoYes but why you need to have a wave function in the first place? Why can't we just have particles with a single state?
- eevilspock 14y agoWhat do you mean "reason nature had to make things so damn complicated"? Nature has reasons? And even if it did, why does this "reason" have to be simple? Does it even have be something humanly comprehensible or even observable? Could an ant ever comprehend or even "see" a microwave oven? Nature is what it is. We may only ever get glimpses. And a bias toward simplicity may be more a function of human limitation than some fundamental truth.
- elorant 14y agoOf course nature has reasons. Natural selection is the prime example. The reasoning doesn't have to be simple but there must be a pretty good explanation of why it is so complicated. Lets not forget that even Einstein thought that something must be wrong with quantum physics because it doesn't make sense. Nature is what it is but that doesn't mean that we can't question what's happening and seek answers to every single aspect of life. That's the basis of science.
- tikhonj 14y agoThere's no guarantee that nature is complicated--it's just that current models of nature are complicated. But any sort of model that you can begin to understand without tons of math has to be at least somewhat intuitive. So what you're asking isn't so much "Why is nature complicated?" as "Why is nature not intuitive?". And the answer to that is simple: nature is not intuitive because intuition is a very pragmatic tool evolved to deal with the macroscopic world you inhabit; it would not make sense for it to be optimized for understanding particle physics! Also, our understanding is simply not complete; it might turn out that there is some relatively simple underlying system and we are merely describing part of the second or third-order effects so cannot see this underlying pattern.
- ramses 14y agoBesides the other good replies to your comment, I should remind you not to confuse the model with what it describes. We can describe electrons as a wave and as a particle, but in reality they are neither.