4 ms·
> The free market has the assumption of perfect information. No. Where do you get that misinformation? Yes, it's relatively easy to construct a model where p
by eru 2y ago
> The free market has the assumption of perfect information.
No. Where do you get that misinformation?
Yes, it's relatively easy to construct a model where perfect information and a bunch of other assumption lead to markets being great. But that merely shows that these conditions are sufficient. Not that they are necessary.
To make an analogy:
We can analyse spherical, friction-less cows in a vacuum and conclude that as long as they move less than about 10km/s the won't escape into space. If we then observe that real cows aren't spherical nor frictionless, we can't automatically assume that they'll escape into space at a lower velocity.
> This breaks the assumption, making government intervention useful.
Non sequitur? Reminds me of the famous syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician's_syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician's_syllogism
Something has to be done. This is something. Thus it has to be done?
- ben_w 2y ago> No. Where do you get that misinformation? > Yes, it's relatively easy to construct a model where perfect information and a bunch of other assumption lead to markets being great. But that merely shows that these conditions are sufficient. Not that they are necessary. "Markets are efficient if and only if P = NP": https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284 https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284 To quote: """ I prove that if markets are weak-form efficient, meaning current prices fully reflect all information available in past prices, then P = NP, meaning every computational problem whose solution can be verified in polynomial time can also be solved in polynomial time. I also prove the converse by showing how we can “program” the market to solve NP-complete problems. Since P probably does not equal NP, markets are probably not efficient. """ > Non sequitur? Reminds me of the famous syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician's_syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician's_syllogism I think I see what you mean, as I didn't give sufficient justification. In this case, government control makes this sector function as a planned economy. The normal flaw in a planned economy is that it cannot respond quickly to changing consumer demand, and I do not dispute this. In the case of medical issues, consumer demand is a lot more predictable by the government than by the general public, as the demand 20 years from now is mostly directly influenced by other government interventions in the meantime (governments have a better awareness than random 18 year olds choosing their university degree of the plausibility of a smoking ban or a sugar tax, they can change pollution rules to ban leaded fuel, etc.), and the exceptions are things like "novel global pandemic" or "we're at war now" where the government has to directly intervene in other ways anyway.
- eru 2y agoThanks for the considered response. > "Markets are efficient if and only if P = NP": https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284 https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284 That's a very cute result, but requires a very specific definition of 'efficient market'. There's actually a range of 'efficient market' definitions, each with their own 'efficient market hypothesis'. One of the weaker forms that I like is: 'don't expect to make any money trading stocks as an amateur on news that the full time professionals (and their computers) in the hedge funds and at Goldman have already seen.' (This one is mostly useful for internet discussions with people who believe in reading price charts etc.) The paper basically shows that if you want to be really careful in your definition of '(weakly) efficient market', you need to take computational complexity into account. It says more about definitions, than about the economy. In any case, if you like that kind of thing, you should check out https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=735 https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=735 too. --- > In this case, government control makes this sector function as a planned economy. The normal flaw in a planned economy is that it cannot respond quickly to changing consumer demand, and I do not dispute this. There's lots more wrong with (most) planned economies. Eg the demand for toilet paper is---covid aside---famously easy to predict. Yet, the Soviet Union was also infamous for their toilet paper shortages. > In the case of medical issues, consumer demand is a lot more predictable by the government than by the general public, as the demand 20 years from now is mostly directly influenced by other government interventions in the meantime [...] The government officials in power today are most likely not the government officials in power over the next 20 years. In most cases, it's not even the same party that's in power. Current government officials don't necessarily have any special insight into long term government actions.