3 ms·
> You can't outpace investment demand - especially not in the phase when housing is used as collateral to borrow in order to invest in more housing. Huh? What
by eru 2y ago
> You can't outpace investment demand - especially not in the phase when housing is used as collateral to borrow in order to invest in more housing.
Huh? What kind of weird statement is this?
It seems there's a lot of confusion. I think it mostly stems from owner-occupiers.
For our analysis, let's separate them into two: some people own houses and rent them out, and everyone (but the homeless) rent houses. It's just that sometimes people rent from themselves.
What matters for discussions about affordability of housing is how much of your income you have to spend each month on housing every month. Let's call that 'housing services'. That is pretty much a function of available supply every month vs demand every month. Who owns them doesn't make a difference.
If an investor buys a house, but rents it out, that's fine. Neither supply of housing services nor demand for housing services has changed. If an investor buys a house, but doesn't rent it out (eg because it's intentionally empty, or because the investor lives there herself), then she counts as a consumer of that unit for that month. That's an indirect change in supply and demand for housing services, but doesn't directly have anything to do with the investor as a owner.
Now to come to your scenario:
If investors use houses as collateral to invest in more housing, that's great! Ideally that will drive up the prices of housing as a capital god.
The more expensive houses are as a capital good, the more it makes sense for developers to jump through all the hoops and build more houses to sell them into the market. That means more houses available for renting out, which drives down rents.
(In the wake of the Great Recession, we had and have the opposite problem: tightening of credit dropped house prices, thus house construction was choked off, and thus rents rose. The ratio of rents to house prices went up, and rents also went up in absolute terms.)