4 ms·
> Obligatory 'sex differences are innate and have nothing to do with socialisation' study Did you read that one? It's a meta commentary rather than a study and
by defrost 2y ago
> Obligatory 'sex differences are innate and have nothing to do with socialisation' study
Did you read that one? It's a meta commentary rather than a study and it strongly notes that:
Therefore, one key difference between males and females in these studies is that males actually show a toy preference while females do not!
A number of other studies of children's toy play and toy preference have reported similar pattern of toy choice with girls playing about equally with all types of toys and males showing a strong bias for male toys
Which would imply that females can do just as well with computers as boys (and as females did before PC home computers were pushed as 'boys toys' in the 80s) save for that charming boorish boyish behaviour of pushing girls out of the boys fort with catcalls, drink spiking and rape.
And that womnen have a broader range of interests in both toys and work.
Unsuprisingly that lessens the initial appeal (lower female student numbers) and lowers the pass through rate (fewer graduates going on into industry).
- avazhi 2y ago"Previous studies have reported differences between males and females in toy choice; that is, girls generally favor toys such as soft dolls, whereas boys generally favor construction and transportation toys (e.g., Connor and Serbin, 1977; Liss, 1981; Pasterski et al., 2005; Roopnarine, 1986)." The dolls vs construction toys preference holds for both human children and monkeys (the latter of which obviously have no socialising reason to prefer one over the other for reasons of sex). The implication is that girls are innately more caring and social, while boys are more adventurous, independent, and prone to risk taking. These differences are pretty obvious to most people, and to - for example - the insurance industry, which charges a much higher premium for a 16 year old boy's car insurance than for a 16 year old girl's car insurance. By your logic, sex differences in motor vehicle accidents among teenagers must be explicable by reason of something other than sex, which would make you a very rich person if you could prove it.
- defrost 2y agoSelective quoting, ignoring other studies, commentary about toy presentation and the actual big picture comment: Therefore, one key difference between males and females in these studies is that males actually show a toy preference while females do not! But sure, you read the bit that backs your bias. > By your logic, Not my logic, I didn't author the study that you linked. > sex differences in motor vehicle accidents among teenagers must be explicable by reason of something other than sex, That doesn't follow from the quote. Sex differences in motor vehicle accidents among teenagers skew heavily male along with other not fully thought through risk taking look at me behaviours.
- avazhi 2y ago"Sex differences in motor vehicle accidents among teenagers skew heavily male along with other not fully thought through risk taking look at me behaviours." I'm glad you agree with me that certain male behaviours and thought processes are unique to males, implying there are cognitive and behavioural differences between males and females which exist as a function of sex. "Therefore, one key difference between males and females in these studies is that males actually show a toy preference while females do not!" This is further evidence - which you've adduced multiple times now - that innate differences between males and females exist (in this case, we have a difference in the existence of toy preferences as a function solely of sex). Now that we agree about this, you can see why one might reasonably conclude that boys, as a function of being boys, prefer certain activities and topics over others (and, mutatis mutandis, girls). I have nothing further to add.
- defrost 2y ago> boys, as a function of being boys, prefer certain activities and topics over others. As per the aticle this includes leering, drink spiking, date rape, etc. And, fails to address why women avoid male heavy domains despite no evidence that should they dive in they'd be any worse than boys. > I have nothing further to add. You've studiously avoided the innate bad behaviour aspects over several comments now.
- avazhi 2y agoMy apologies. I'm more than happy to admit that men exhibit 'innate bad behaviour' more often than women do. The fact that they do so is a function of them being men, and men and women are very different, as we've seen. I suppose you think that by admitting this, I must then admit that women are scared off by such 'innate bad behaviour' and so don't go into STEM fields. But once again the evidence is that the sex differences are significant from at least the time infants begin playing with toys and that they are not functions of human culture or learned social behaviour. Or are you suggesting that 1 year old infants are capable of making sex-based inferences? Maybe that monkey infants have divined the intricacies of human gender norms? Those differences in behaviours based on sex are conserved across a range of primate species, as we've seen. If the cognitive and behavioural differences arise before girls (or infant female monkeys) have ever been exposed to those big bad mean boys and their bad behaviours, then naturally you can't blame women being underrepresented in STEM fields on the boys, and you'll have to look for other (antecedent) causes. As we've seen, those cognitive and behavioural differences DO arise far earlier than you can explain based on some learned response to male behaviour. The differences can only be explained by the genetic distinctions between the two sexes. I wasn't 'studiously' avoiding anything, it's just that bad male behaviours are completely irrelevant.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoNot that I agree with the parent comment, in particular i disagree that innate differences overshadow socialization in their effect upon gender proportions in stem, but I do want to point out that there isn’t a contradiction here. If males, in effect, have less options they find appealing, then we’d expect a higher likelihood of males selecting stem subjects and thus a gender imbalance.
- defrost 2y agoNot as extreme as has been seen. Taking first year (actual) Engineering as an example, in the early 1980s in my state, at the university I attended, many males applied, only those with sufficient test scores were accepted subject to places available (300 intake). 299 males Vs 1 female. In pure math, chem, physics, law, medicine, the gender breaks were approx 35-55% female (somewhat higher than 50:50 female intakes in medicine|law) but Engineering was (at that time) avoided by women in the application process. There are things males gravitate to, there are things that women choose to avoid, and there's a selection committee that chooses from applications. Engineering was a sausage fest .. and not a pleasent faculty to be a female student in.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoOh absolutely, 299 to 1 sounds like an absolute joke and clearly is social. I just mean that once we have done the important work to eradicate social barriers keeping women out of engineering, we may still find a disparity. I’m not sure of the exact numbers, but I at least hope things have improved since the 80s.