3 ms·
There Are No Efficient Markets in Politics
- PaulHoule 2y agoI’d solidly blame the current deadlock on Bill Clinton. in the book The Political Economy of Dictatorship Wintrobe considers the example of a tinpot dictator who has stolen all the resources of his country and would mostly like to spend them on himself but has to spend some of it on buying people off and some of it on repression, what is the optimal mix? An elected politician faces a similar situation. Once elected they’d like to be able to “do what the hell they want” but are constrained by all the promises that they made to people. It is in their best interest to (1) not make any more promises than they have to and (2) have an excuse for breaking promises. If you wanted to win an election by 70% or something you’d need to make some big promises that people would have to believe in. If you want a chance of winning it close to 50% you can put together a coalition which might win based on a “cheap” set of promises. (The “culture war” is the ultimate example of cheap in the sense that statements of identity don’t require spending real money) The Democrats in particular traded a broad-based coalition (support the 99%) for a coalition that can sometimes break 50% that doesn’t promise a lot… except to campaign donors. Now they wonder why they can’t do better than 50%…
- ggm 2y agoBlaming it on one president ignores the tripartite nature of government because the WH is in a dance with house and senate as well as the DNC. Clinton led at best. At worst made choices from a small field of plays, each with consequences for a side of the triangle.