4 ms·
Just to play devil's advocate here, if the offences were conducted in the US (US hosted servers, paid for in dollars and earning e.g. advertising revenue from U
by simonh 14y ago
Just to play devil's advocate here, if the offences were conducted in the US (US hosted servers, paid for in dollars and earning e.g. advertising revenue from US customers serving ads to US users) then maybe he has a case to answer for in the US. I don't know, I made those things up because I'm not familiar with the case. If anyone here knows more please do tell.
If that is the case, then it's just a question of whether he should be tried in the US or the UK. However if you set yourself up to do business in the US and break the law there by e.g. violating the copyrights of US companies, surely doing so while sitting in another country should be no defence?
As I say, I don't know enough about this case to be able to say but the basic principles of responsibility in play here seem sound to me. If you earn US dollars in the US and break US laws, you should be prepared to defend yourself in a US court. No?
- brackin 14y agoThey weren't US Hosted Servers fyi. Richard confirmed this before. The only reason the US is claiming is that it was a .net and the dns goes through Verisign.
- simonh 14y agoIf that's the case, and that's the whole of their justification, then it seems a pretty flimsy pretext. I'm not trying to be obtuse, but in almost all the cases like this I've seen in the media, there just hasn't been anywhere near enough information about the case to come to an informed opinion.
- arethuza 14y agoNot if you are in France, Germany, Austria, Russia, China or Japan - who apparently never extradite their nationals. Rather their laws give jurisdiction over laws committed by their nationals while abroad. Given this kind of nonsense, I can see that they might have a point.