6 ms·
40+ voice searches thrown at Google on Jelly Bean
- vibrunazo 14y agoI was impressed that most of these searches already work on regular google search (just tried them). I had no idea the knowledge graph could do those already. This is not only a great demo of android voice search. It's a great demo of google search.
- vibragiel 14y agoHowever, at least some searches from the video seem a bit cherrypicked. "How much is Angelina Jolie worth?" is throwing an answer: https://www.google.com/search?q=how+much+is+angelina+jolie+worth%3F https://www.google.com/search?q=how+much+is+angelina+jolie+w... But "How much is Brad Pitt worth?" isn't: https://www.google.com/search?q=how%20much%20is%20brad%20pitt%20worth https://www.google.com/search?q=how%20much%20is%20brad%20pit...? "Fish species in Lake Tahoe": https://www.google.com/search?q=fish%20species%20in%20lake%20tahoe https://www.google.com/search?q=fish%20species%20in%20lake%2... But "fish species in mississippi river": https://www.google.com/search?q=fish%20species%20in%20mississippi%20river https://www.google.com/search?q=fish%20species%20in%20missis... Edit: changed ".es" by ".com" in all the links.
- abrahamsen 14y agoI had to change ".es" to ".com" in all those links to get anything.
- vibragiel 14y agoOops, weird. Changed them.
- switch007 14y agoI assume that's over wifi? I'd like to see its performance over 3G.
- mise 14y agoOn a related note, does the voice get intrepreted on the device, or on Google servers?
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoAs of JB, it can do both. Though I believe the offline mode is only used as a backup if the network's acting up.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoI wonder whether the offline performance is comparable? If it was then surely you'd do all the voice parsing locally so I'm guessing that it's not. Unless anyone can think of another reason you'd push it through the servers?
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoTwo factors: - online should have more training data and can be improved much more easily. Don't see that advantage going away. - power efficiency and/or speed. Sending 5s of audio across the net can be less strain on the device (esp. older ones) versus parsing the audio locally.
- Inversechi 14y agoFrom what I've read It's all done on the device. "One of the biggest issues with Siri is that it requires access to Apple’s servers in order to work. In Jelly Bean, however, Google will provide full offline voice dictation to users. Granted, that’s not a full Siri competitor, but the fact that the search company has been able to take it offline in a mobile setting is very important." http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Mobile-and-Wireless/Android-41-Jelly-Bean-10-New-Features-That-Make-It-the-Best-Version-Yet-140400/ http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Mobile-and-Wireless/Android-41-Jell...
- apendleton 14y agoPure speculation, here, but some of the transcription looked like it relied on pretty heavy statistical inference stuff (like knowing that "Worcester" comes before "Mass" but "Wooster" comes before "College," even though they're both pronounced the same). I would be really surprised if the client-side recognition was that smart, so I'd guess that they do it server-side if they can.
- bmj1 14y agoLooks good - 1 hiccup: the calculations aren't rounded correctly. (time: 4.10) Rounded to 2 decimal places: 11.65600 is 11.66 not 11.65 80.4672 is 80.47 not 80.46 Sorry to be pedantic...
- jarin 14y agoWhat's up with it showing directions to Moscone Center and then when he closes it there is something about Wooster College? I don't wanna call fake, but that's definitely strange… Then later on he asks a question about Wooster College Edit: Also, he says "Where is that museum with Egyptian stuff in San Jose?" and after he closes it, it shows "where is the tallest building in the world"
- itp 14y agoFrom the link text on the post: Disclaimer: the only edits I made were to cut time between each of my queries, as well as re-order some of the demos from the original order I recorded them in, so they would fit into categories. None of the queries themselves have been edited or cut down, and the sequences are intact. The processing time happened exactly as you see. This demo is made on the early build of Android 4.1 (JRN84D, takju build for Galaxy Nexus I/O edition), on a wifi connection. Consider this beta. So what you're seeing are places where the queries were reordered.
- jarin 14y agoAh, I did not notice the cuts.
- Swifty 14y agoif you read the page he says he cut the video down a bit, and also recorded some of the clips to fit them in to categories and not the order he record them. That could explain why some of the results have other things shown when he closes them.
- fabiandesimone 14y ago212 is also the area code for Caracas, Venezuela ;)
- itp 14y agoIt'll be interesting to see if the response changes based on localization (once this is available in more languages than US English, of course). Having the response to that query change if the locale is es_VE would be pretty slick! Thinking about this, do systems like Android typically offer localization that specific?
- raldi 14y agoIndeed; do questions about the Cardinals give different answers during football season? And if it's the time of year that people are playing both baseball and football, does it distinguish by whether you live in St. Louis or Arizona? Edit: or Vatican City?
- bsimpson 14y agoGoogle Now is awesome, but it's way worse at calling my friends than Voice Search was. It's like it doesn't index my address book. The other day, I told my phone "Call Nico Thornley." Instead, it searched for "call me-so-lonely." Not the first time Google Now has completely botched a friend search either.
- lukeschlather 14y agoVoice search seemed to quit indexing contacts with the 2.1 upgrade. Which is too bad, since putting addresses in my contacts made it remarkably efficient for driving to a friend's house on a lark.
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoThis is what pisses me off. We clearly have the capability for really obvious stuff like this to just work ("navigate to wendy's house"), yet it still often doesn't.
- pilif 14y ago(disclaimer: this is based on demonstrations I have seen - I don't have access to JB and thus I can only speak of Siri): In many of these demonstrations I noticed one thing that was bugging me: Even though the voice recognition in Android seems really cool (I don't have JB yet), it doesn't give definite audible confirmation of the command in many cases and sometimes it even requires user interaction with the screen. Now personally, I already believe that speech input is kind of a gimmick in itself (try using english voice recognition with my address book filled with german names...), I believe that to even have a chance to move from gimmick to useful feature, it must work without user interaction on the screen. "Play <whatever band name>" followed by "beep" and the a button to press on the screen doesn't help me. A useful response to "play <insert band name here>" is "playing <insert band name here>" followed by actually playing it. Or "call <some name>" - if you just get back "calling" or even just a beep - how would you know whether the recognition was successful or not and the correct name has been recognized? Some commands on Android seem to be doing fine (the weather example), but others fail in one way (the play example seems to require user interaction on the screen) or another (the "turn on wifi" command doesn't produce any audible confirmation or error message - just the same beep sound as if it worked). Siri, while it might not have as good a recognition as the Android solution, is much better in that regards: It always confirms your command. As such Siri seems moderately more useful as an additional input method whereas Android, by forcing you to look at the screen when inputting a voice command, reduces this to a gimmick and nothing else.
- srj 14y agoIt appears that for queries that don't have direct "answer" type response and will perform an action it displays a progress bar with the query it understood. Presumably this is so that you can cancel the action if voice recognition was wrong. It doesn't require any input though - I just tested it. Once the progress bar reaches the end (it seems to take ~7 seconds) it will complete the action.
- pilif 14y agoThat means that in case it mis-understood you that you have to wait ~7 seconds before you notice that it was wrong. If it immediately confirmed like Siri, you would know right then and could re-issue the command.
- gurkendoktor 14y agoI think these are great times to be a gadget consumer. Apple made the Siri interface 'mainstream', and Google is great at throwing brainpower at their own version of the interface. (I hope I'm not mistaken that Apple integrated the 'vertical list' interface first.) The fact that JB's dictation works offline whereas Siri needs a connection is the icing on the cake. Same for the race to having better maps or the better browser.
- greggman 14y agoWhat's the "vertical list" interface? Android had lists of results on voice search for while. Is this what you mean? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0L_IhqGcRM8#t=8m36s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0L_IhqGcRM8#t=8m36s Here's the navigate by voice from nearly 4 years ago http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLXZ5BHeDFg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLXZ5BHeDFg Here's the original voice actions video by Google from 2 years ago http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGbYVvU0Z5 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGbYVvU0Z5 Siri was introed 1 year ago? I agree though, it's a great time to be a gadget consumer. I love Siri's conversational style. It actually doesn't seem too far off before I can actually start having a conversation with a computer though something like Siri which is both awesome and terrifying at the same time.
- gurkendoktor 14y agoI meant that the interaction with Siri looks basically like a chatlog (conversational). Here's what I misunderstood - I thought Jelly Bean was the same, but he would always just tap away the last item in the video so we don't see it. Maybe there is no scrollable backlog in Jelly Bean.
- mrich 14y agoWell done, unfortunately all devices using this will be sued out of the market by Apple.
- zmanian 14y agoAnyone have a hypothesis on how Google's offline line voice recognition works? it definitely seems like they have moved more voice recognition work onto the client even in the online mode. My understanding of Google's approach to voice recognition was that it was big data dependent. This would make it hard to move to client devices....
- Zenst 14y agoWhen I see 40+ voice search's by various accents, including Socttish - THEN I will be amazed.
- sxp 14y agoThere is also this test of 1600 queries: http://gizmodo.com/5922332/google-search-beats-the-crap-out-of-siri-in-1600-question-test http://gizmodo.com/5922332/google-search-beats-the-crap-out-... Final results is 86% to 68% for Google.
- shawndumas 14y agowhat happens with jellybean when you make an appointment for a time slot and you already have one at that time slot?