5 ms·
Nearly every stupid thing I've seen the government do recently has been caused by Theresa May. I don't know much about law but the UK sending a citizen to be tr
by k-mcgrady 14y ago
Nearly every stupid thing I've seen the government do recently has been caused by Theresa May. I don't know much about law but the UK sending a citizen to be tried in the US for something that is not illegal under UK law is disgraceful.
Every time I see a news story that involves this woman I get frustrated.
- ajuc 14y agoIs she elected? Write her an email with your opinion. Since ACTA affair I've started to write emails to politicians every time I don't like sth, telling them why I don't like it, and that I'll persuade my friends not to vote them because of the things they did that I don't like. I don't know if it works, but I feel much better after sending such email :) I even got a few responses (mostly stupid, but still).
- JonnieCache 14y ago>I don't know if it works, but I feel much better after sending such email Congratulations, you now understand democracy.
- nicholassmith 14y agoIs she elected? Yes. Was she elected for that role? No, she was picked out for it. And despite people saying "this is stupid" she's got a track record for taking a standpoint and refusing to move even when it's one that causes people to actually get motivated in saying "We think this is wrong".
- toyg 14y agoTo be fair, sometimes it does look like a government can't win: stand your ground and you'll be abused for being insensitive, change your mind and you'll be crucified for flip-flopping/being indecisive and out of touch (see also: pasty tax, fuel duty etc). This doesn't mean they aren't a bunch of nasty Tories (they are) or that they are right on this issue (they are not); it's just that criticizing a politician for his day-to-day behaviour rather than his/her political stance is just a way of buying in the politics-as-sport worldview pushed by media interests.
- nicholassmith 14y agoWell the issue with this more than pastygate or the fuel duty is it's not good for British citizens as a whole. It sets a worrying precedent of them kowtowing to U.S media interests when they've already said "We don't think it's worth the time in prosecuting internally". Sure, this is a larger scale thing but it indicates that British citizens are now not only subject to laws of their own country, but also of America if they so choose. Granted they've probably bowed to the extradition demand because America has a 'special relationship' for us in terms of economy and the like, but it reinforces the belief that we're essentially puppets for America.
- arethuza 14y ago"is not illegal under UK law" I believe what he is accused of is illegal under UK law - but that the Crown Prosection Service appears to have no interest in prosecuting him. Why we would extradite someone for a crime which nobody can be bothered prosecuting him for here seems a complete mystery to me. If he did commit a crime then then get him in a UK court to defend himself: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/jun/24/richard-odwyer-legal-questions-answers http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/jun/24/richard-odwyer-lega...
- ubernostrum 14y agoThere are several levels of traps here. One is a form of magical thinking -- the idea that "on the internet" should grant some sort of mystical immunity from jurisdiction. There's a fairly large body of pretty well-settled laws and treaties for deciding whether a country has jurisdiction for potentially-criminal actions that cross national borders, and for deciding whether to extradite to that country. That's exactly what's applying here. Another is wishful thinking: wanting a system that extradites for things HN thinks should be crimes, but doesn't extradite for things that HN thinks shouldn't be crimes. The plain and simple fact is that it doesn't work that way; we can wish that the laws regarding, say, copyright were other than they are, but wishing won't make it so. Only actual changes to the laws will make it so, and extradition treaties are not the laws that would need changing. Finally, there's the trap of assuming that this sort of thing -- a vengeful, powerful figure abusing the most convenient jurisdiction to punish someone -- is somehow new, or is unique to the US. Libel tourism is a relevant example here, since the UK is often a very friendly venue for those who seek legal revenge on critics/dissenters. It also ties in quite nicely with the second point above, because it has resulted in other countries actually changing their legal systems to bar enforcement of UK libel judgements.
- arethuza 14y agoSlight nitpick - you mean English & Welsh libel judgements. Scots law is pretty different in this area (no idea about NI).
- 14y ago
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoI just hope we don't have double standards and start extraditing people to Saudi Arabia for adultery - even if they committed the "crime" in the UK. While we are on the subject shouldn't the UK attempt to extradite US "hate" organisations like the KKK who run a web-site clearly in violation of the UK's Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006. Seriously, why shouldn't we? It is exactly the same thing, they said something online which is illegal to say in the UK - therefore we should extradite them and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoBecause we signed a treaty with the US that lets them do it to us, but does not let us do it to them. When the US signs a treaty that lets us extradite KKK members we can start your policy. I suspect Mexico will have invaded California before then.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThat isn't completely true: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition_Act_2003#Controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition_Act_2003#Controvers...
- rmc 14y ago• Adultery isn't a crime in the UK. • Signatories to the European Convention of Human Rights cannot extradite people to countries where they might face the death penalty. So no extradition to SA if they could be executed. • Extradition requires "double criminality", i.e. that the act is a crime in both countries. US Constitutional law means that hate groups are not breaking the law in the US and hence the US would not extradite them.