4 ms·
It's weird that wikipedia took down the page for all users, rather than only for Indian users. AFAIK most tech companies only comply with "political" takedown r
by gruez 2y ago
It's weird that wikipedia took down the page for all users, rather than only for Indian users. AFAIK most tech companies only comply with "political" takedown requests (I'm using this broadly to include anything between blasphemy/lese majeste laws and defamation/right to be forgotten laws, as opposed to something like DMCA requests) in the country where the takedown was issued, leaving it up for other countries. Does the wikimedia foundation not have the infrastructure to do geo-targeted takedowns? Or was this the intended outcome?
- aspenmayer 2y agoFrom what I've gathered, the worldwide takedown was court-ordered. https://archive.is/dNTEl https://archive.is/dNTEl
- lopis 2y agoBut how can a court have worldwide jurisdiction? I suppose it was technically harder to handle this request just for Indian users, since it was an unprecedented request.
- aspenmayer 2y agoI don't believe it does, but the courts threatened to block Wikipedia or find WMF and likely any assets and/or staff in India in contempt if they did not comply, likely including fines.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThis is similar to what Australia is doing to X, requesting content be taken down worldwide, which X is fighting.
- aspenmayer 2y agoI think that as of June this year, that saga has ended in favor of X: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/06/win-free-speech-australia-drops-global-takedown-order-case https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/06/win-free-speech-austra... https://archive.is/rgNKq https://archive.is/rgNKq
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 93po 2y agoMany US laws apply to US companies regardless of where they're operating. A US company can't do something that's illegal in the US like bribery just because the employee doing it is based out of their (whatever country) headquarters.
- adastra22 2y agoThis isn’t a political takedown request.
- aspenmayer 2y agoIt seems like an explicitly political takedown request to me, based on what I have read and what others who study such things also say. Can you find some sources that share your view, or can you elaborate why you think that this is not a case of censorship and extraterritorial overreach by the Indian court?
- adastra22 2y agoTFA backs me up as a source: > The takedown follows an order by the Delhi High Court, where Chief Justice Manmohan and Justice Tushar Rao Gedela ruled that the Wikipedia page describing criticism of the lawsuit “amounts to interference in Court proceedings,” and that this violated the “subjudice principle”. In case you're not familiar with the subjudice principle: > This legal concept essentially means that cases being considered in a current trial should not be prejudiced by public discussion. It aims to avoid biasing or influencing the judicial process while the matter remains undetermined by a judge or jury. https://www.vintti.com/blog/sub-judice-legal-concept-explained#:~:text=This%20legal%20concept%20essentially%20means,by%20a%20judge%20or%20jury https://www.vintti.com/blog/sub-judice-legal-concept-explain.... Basically the article in question is about a current court case in which Wikimedia is the defendant. The court has ruled that neither party should be making public statements about the case until a judgement is made. This is very standard practice and happens in all jurisdictions. The article on Wikipedia, hosted by the Wikimedia foundation itself, would be such a statement. Wikimedia is not being asked to censor an article for political purposes. It is asked merely to refrain from making statements about an ongoing court case in which Wikipedia itself is a defendant, in standard accordance with the subjudice principle.
- aspenmayer 2y agoWMF isn't making statements; WMF is being forced to censor free speech of independent Wikipedia editors on behalf of a court that doesn't even have jurisdiction over editors outside India, to my reading.