7 ms·
I don't understand the ruling. Sure, my tweet is public, but why does that mean that the government can demand my email address and other identifying user infor
by eridius 14y ago
I don't understand the ruling. Sure, my tweet is public, but why does that mean that the government can demand my email address and other identifying user information?
I'm also confused as to what's even being demanded. If the tweets are public, doesn't the Manhattan DA already have them? And if they know who this person is (since they said his name, Malcom Harris), what identifying user information do they actually need?
- themgt 14y agoYeah, it sounds like an absolutely ridiculous ruling. The judge compares a tweet to shouting something out a window. Which is a perfectly good analogy. But then in his analogy, since you shouted it out the window of the Twitter Bar, now months later that establishment is required to turn over all its CCTV recordings and information on you to the DA
- latch 14y agoHow is this "absolutely ridiculous"? The government is investigating someone they suspect committed a crime and issued a subpoena to get more information. It's how the system is supposed to work.
- _delirium 14y agoAs the judge noted, there are different standards for the subpoena depending on whether there is a "reasonable expectation of privacy" in the information being subpoenaed, because the Stored Communications Act of 1986 adds certain extra requirements on when an ISP may release materials that fall under the latter category. What was in dispute here wasn't that some information was subpoenaed following proper procedure, but that the judge held that the "proper procedure" in this case was the procedure for public information in which there isn't a "reasonable expectation of privacy", while Twitter was arguing that the subpoena was requiring them to disclose things that were not in fact public information.
- latch 14y agoSure, but the idea that tweets have an expectation of privacy, reasonable or not, is absurd. From a PR point of view, Twitter did the right thing. They executed their right to challenge the subpoena. Now they have to begrudgingly hand over the data. It makes it look like they'll fight for their users, even though there's clearly nothing they can do.
- kd0amg 14y agoSure, but the idea that tweets have an expectation of privacy, reasonable or not, is absurd. What about the rest of the information associated with a Twitter account?
- latch 14y agoThe top comment, by Tangaroa, points to 18 USC 2703 which covers this. A company can be compelled to give that information. You really find it odd that the government can force company X to turn over your ip address, name, email and other such information? The concern over growing fascism comes from warrantless government behavior. This, on the other hand, seems completely within the realm of government acting properly.
- kd0amg 14y agoYou really find it odd that the government can force company X to turn over your ip address, name, email and other such information? People keep on pointing out to you that the judge applied a standard meant for public information to a request for non-public information.
- eli 14y agoI expect my Direct Messages in Twitter to be private -- don't you?
- _delirium 14y agoIt looks like the judge did agree on that part, that Twitter DMs are a separate category of message more like email.
- trotsky 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subpoena https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subpoena
- alttab 14y agoI agree. The tweets are public. Who cares. The email address is not public. This sets a dangerous precedent that if you post on the Internet you are giving up your anominity.