3 ms·
Yes there's no air resistance, but also most of the fragments aren't going your way. If you have a 25 m^2 cross section in the direction of the explosion, at t
by ben_w 2y ago
Yes there's no air resistance, but also most of the fragments aren't going your way.
If you have a 25 m^2 cross section in the direction of the explosion, at that distance you have a roughly 1 in 246 billion chance of any given bit of debris hitting you.
- throw4950sh06 2y agoWhat is the chance of getting hit by further broken pieces of that satellite and other satellites? When calculating risk, you have to take into account how many are there and what is the chance that any will be hit. Then you have to calculate what's the chance this will happen again, etc - and only then you can calculate the risk to your own satellite. It's true that the chance of getting hit by one broken satellite is small. But that assumes there are exactly 2 things on the orbit.
- ethbr1 2y agoAka Kessler syndrome [0] or neutron flux / cross-section (and associated equations, if you want to model it that way) [1]. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_flux https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_flux
- throw4950sh06 2y agoThat's if the risk comes out at 100%, but there's some space below that.
- anjel 2y agoIt might not place neighbors at appreciable risk but wouldn't debris still prevent replacing the failed satellite with another one at the same precious original address?
- ethbr1 2y agoWouldn't debris at the same address (after some time) therefore have zero relative motion?
- user32489318 2y agoNo, because the debris = tiny pieces of aluminum, will be pushed around by solar radiation. Also, there’re tiny meteorites, and other pieces of debris colliding with it, which adds energy to the system, if you like. TLEs are not maintained for small debris, so you can’t really predict conclusively. But my hunch is that eventually, the orbit will become a bit more parabolic, precession of which could put it into a trajectory of a S/C and cause a collision.
- verzali 2y agoThings in geo orbit aren't perfectly stable, since the Earth's gravitational field is not perfectly uniform. Without active station keeping things tend to gather at two particular longitudes over the equator. So eventually that debris will probably end up at those points.
- randmeerkat 2y ago> If you have a 25 m^2 cross section in the direction of the explosion, at that distance you have a roughly 1 in 246 billion chance of any given bit of debris hitting you. Source?
- a1369209993 2y ago$ units You have: 25m2 / 2tau(700km)^2 You want: /billion * 0.0040600751 / 246.30086
- randmeerkat 2y ago[flagged]
- ben_w 2y agoThe 'units' command line tool has been part of Unix since Bell Labs, and GNU Units came along in 1997. Personally I used basic high school geometry knowledge of "what's the area of a sphere", and you could also have just asked WolframAlpha, which also predates LLMs.
- randmeerkat 2y agoYet a formula that actually calculates the probability of impact is nowhere to be found in your response. You don’t consider mass, density, velocity, orbits, or anything else for that matter.
- ben_w 2y agoThe formula is an excercise for the reader, even if my audience was a 14 year old learning about this for the first time. As is figuring out why "mass" and "density" are unimportant. Might be a valuable lesson in "reading the question carefully" for them, though, as the scenario was: "That’s pretty close when your neighbor just exploded", which is why orbital mechanics can be disregarded in this instance.