3 ms·
> That 0 knowledge tracker is interesting, Most actual trackers are zero knowledge. A tracker (bit of central software that handles 100+ thousand connections/
by defrost 2y ago
> That 0 knowledge tracker is interesting,
Most actual trackers are zero knowledge.
A tracker (bit of central software that handles 100+ thousand connections/second) is not a "torrent site" such as TPB, EZTV, etc.
A tracker handshakes torrent clients and introduces peers to each other, it has no idea nor needs an idea that "SomeName 1080p DSPN" maps to D23F5C5AAE3D5C361476108C97557F200327718A
All it needs is to store IP addresses that are interested in that hash and to pass handfuls of interested IP addresses to other interested parties (and some other bookkeeping).
From an actual tracker PoV the content is irrelevant and there's no means of telling one thing from another other than size - it's how trackers have operated for 20+ years now.
Here are some actual tracker addresses and ports
udp://tracker.opentrackr.org:1337/announce
udp://p4p.arenabg.com:1337/announce
udp://tracker.torrent.eu.org:451/announce
udp://tracker.dler.org:6969/announce
udp://open.stealth.si:80/announce
udp://ipv4.tracker.harry.lu:80/announce
https://opentracker.i2p.rocks:443/announce
Here's the bittorrent protocol: http://bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0052.html http://bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0052.html
Trackers can hand out .torrent files if asked (bencoded dictionaries that describe filenames, sizes, checksums, directory structures of a torrents contents) but they don't have to; mostly they hand out peer lists of other clients .. peers can also answer requests for .torrent files.
A .torrent file isn't enough to determine illegal content.
Pornography can be contained in files labelled "BeautifulSunset.mkv" and Rick Astley parody videos can frequently be found in files labelled "DirtyFilthyRepubicanFootTappingNudeAfrica.avi"
Given that it's not clear how trackers could effectively filter by content that never actually traverses their servers.
- TZubiri 2y agoOh ok, it seems to be a misconception of mine then. Mathematically a tracker would offer a function that given a hash, it returns you a list of peers with that file. While a "torrent site" like TPB or SH, would offer a search mechanism, whereby they would host an index, content hashes and english descriptors, along with a search engine. A user would then need to first use the "torrent site" to enter their search terms, and find the hash, then they would need to give the hash to a tracker, which would return the list of peers? Is that right? In any case, each party in the transaction shares liability. If we were analyzing a drug case or a people trafficking case, each distributor, wholesaler or retailer would bear liability and face criminal charges. A legal defense of the type "I just connected buyers with sellers I never exchanged the drug" would not have much chance of succeding, although it is a common method to obstruct justice by complicating evidence gathering. (One member collects the money, the other gives the drugs.)
- defrost 2y ago> A user would then need to first use the "torrent site" to enter their search terms, and find the hash, then they would need to give the hash to a tracker, which would return the list of peers? > Is that right? More or less. > In any case, each party in the transaction shares liability. That's exactly right Bob. Just as a telephone exchange shares liability for connecting drug sellers to drug buyers when given a phone number. Clearly the telephone exchange should know by the number that the parties intend to discuss sharing child pornography rather than public access to free to air documentaries. How do you propose that a telephone exchange vet phone numbers to ensure drugs are not discussed? Bear in mind that in the case of a tracker the 'call' is NOT routed through the exchange. With a proper telephone exchange the call data (voices) pass through the exchange equipment, with a tracker no actual file content passes through the trackers hardware. The tracker, given a number, tells interested parties about each other .. they then talk directly to each other; be it about The Sky at Night -s2024e07- 2024-10-07 Question Time or about Debbie Does Donkeys. Also keep in mind that trackers juggle a vast volume of connections of which a very small amount would be (say) child abuse related.
- TZubiri 2y agoInteresting. That's a good point. I'll restate the principle of good usage to bad usage ratio, telephone providers are a well established service with millions of legitimate users and uses. Furthermore they are a recognized service in law, they are regulated, and they can comply with law enforcement. They are closer to the ISP, which according to my theory has some liability as well. It's just a matter of the liability being small and the service to society being useful and necessary. To take a spin to a similar but newer tech, consider crypto. My position is that its legality and liability for illegal usage of users (considering that of exchanges and online wallets, since the network is often not a legal entity) will depend on the ratio of legitimate to ilegitimate use that will be given to it. There's definitely a second system effect, were undesirables go to the second system, so it might be a semantical difference unrelated to the technical protocols. Maybe if one system came first, or if by chance it were the most popular, the tables would be turned. But I feel more strongly that there's design features that make law compliance, traceability and accountability difficult. In the case of trackers perhaps the microservice/object is a simple key-value store, but it is semantically associated with other protocols which have 'noxious' features described above AND are semantically associates with illegal material.
- GoblinSlayer 2y agoAre you sure open.stealth.si is a zero knowledge tracker? Some trackers reject unregistered torrents.
- defrost 2y agoThe list I gave was of some public trackers, I made no claim that they were zero knowledge trackers, I simply made a statement that trackers needn't be aware of .torrent file manifests in order to share peer lists. I also indicated above that having knowledge of .torrent manifests is problematic as that doesn't provide real actual knowledge of file contents just knowledge of file names ... LatestActionMovie.mkv might be a rootkit virus and HappyBunnyRabbits.avi might be the worst most exploitative underage pornography you can think of. Some trackers are also private and require membership keys to access. I was skating a lot as TZubiri seems unaware of many of the actual details and legitimate use cases, existing law, etc.