4 ms·
"Anybody that thinks Android hasn't brought anything new to the table hasn't really used an Android phone." Not sure who said that anywhere in the discussion,
by Uchikoma 14y ago
"Anybody that thinks Android hasn't brought anything new to the table hasn't really used an Android phone."
Not sure who said that anywhere in the discussion, or in the linked article, or anywhere else.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man
- kleiba 14y agoNot sure that your "Straw man" link is appropriate - the very first comment in this thread starts with: Copying Apple is not really 'innovation' This implies (to me anyway) the notion that Android does not innovate (aka bringing something new to the table) but merely copies Apple. (I assume that Android is meant here because the original article discusses the mobile sector.)
- Uchikoma 14y ago"Copying Apple is not really 'innovation'" Let's break this down: a.) Well is it? Is copying Apple 'innovation'? I'd say no b.) Did it say that Android is only copying Apple without adding something else? I'd say no c.) Do you say that Android does in no way copy Apple? I assume the answer to c.) is also no, so how is this not a straw man argument?
- kleiba 14y agoBecause as I said, I differ in point "b" - I would say it's a "yes".
- tallanvor 14y agoEh? cageface is supporting nodata's position. A straw man argument is used to attack a position.
- Uchikoma 14y agoSupporting arguments can't be straw man arguments? Where did you read that?