5 ms·
I don't really see how there can be any question that chaos, poverty, moving every year, constantly changing schools, multiple and changing "parent" figures, ad
by SoftTalker 2y ago
I don't really see how there can be any question that chaos, poverty, moving every year, constantly changing schools, multiple and changing "parent" figures, adults making poor choices over and over, no examples of deliberate planning and saving for the future, screws up kids.
They learn that life is completely unpredictable, that opportunities for reward should be taken immediately because they will not be there later, they never learn to spend extended time on learning anything or saving money for the future because they have never seen anyone in their life do those things.
A few manage to figure it out anyway, but most are doomed to repeat all of that as parents with their own kids. It's sad.
- taeric 2y agoI mean, maybe? They experience that life is completely unpredictable, sure. They learn whatever they are taught along with it. Consider, life was far more unpredictable just a few hundred years ago. Literally stubbing your toe in the forest could go septic and then you were dead. Violently so. Bad harvests could happen with no forewarning at all.
- airstrike 2y agoThe fact that stubbing your toe meant death in the past doesn't mean that facing massive adversity doesn't have real negative long term impact on one's mental well being. You're equating psychological harm and learned patterns of behavior that are unresourceful with physical accidents, without explaining why we should see them as comparable. Even if they were comparable, who's to say Neanderthal younglings with badly stubbed toes didn't also have skewed reward processing as adults?
- taeric 2y agoExample of stubbing toe was about how unpredictable life was. Getting a wound to go septic was basically random for a long long time. Most of the time, stubbing your toe was about the same as it is today. Annoying and nothing more. Have it go septic, though, and it likely looked like someone had been cursed to death. And note that this goes for more than just literally stubbing your toe. Snag on a bush? Bitten by animal. It would have seemed far far more random. My post is specifically in response to the one above me. It is framed with modern events and pushing that they are obviously going to seem unpredictable to people. My assertion is that they can be seen that way, sure; but don't think this is somehow a modern thing. To your point, I would expect that reward processing is influenced by these events, sure. I would also expect any indoctrination that was happening at the same time to stick. My current bias is to expect indoctrination to stick more effectively than raw experiences. And yes, this is somewhat cheating because the indoctrination is almost certainly done to compliment experiences.
- lazyasciiart 2y agoArbitrary danger in nature is where religion came from.
- taeric 2y agoThis largely runs to my point. It wasn't the arbitrary danger that led to religion. It was people teaching that the danger was from a directed source that did. Put differently, without priests, would there be religion?
- em-bee 2y agoIt was people teaching that the danger was from a directed source that did i'd rather think it was the demand for an explanation for those events. and just like any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic, so is any unexplainable event indistinguishable from an act of god.
- taeric 2y agoFor this to work, though, you would have seen a convergence of all humanity onto the same explanations? While I think you can almost make the case that there are some commonalities between origin stories, I think you would be stretching credibility a fair bit there. This also hits a pretty tough point with regards to other animals. Do they have religions?
- em-bee 2y agoFor this to work, though, you would have seen a convergence of all humanity onto the same explanations given the dominance of monotheistic religions this is actually happening. there is no need for origin stories to have commonalities because the convergence can also happen through replacement. if every group comes up with their own explanation for the different experiences they have, their stories are naturally going to differ, and that is what we see in history. but also, commonalities are there. pretty much all stories have some kind of creator of the universe and many refer to someone who will come and bring salvation.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoHumans are antifragile. They survive disease, famine, loss, death of kin, all sorts of horrible abuse and still manage to build a great life afterwards. Look at all of the people who survived German concentration camps and still were able to live lives worth living after the fact. Not everybody, but it's clearly possible.
- crazygringo 2y ago> Humans are antifragile. This is not true at all. Some survive, but many die from the things you've described. Of those that survive, many fail completely to build a great life afterwards. They succumb to alcoholism, other addictions, and many die later from suicide. Talk to any therapist and you'll find out that human fragility is the rule rather than the exception. After traumatic events, even those that "still manage to build a great life", as viewed from the outside, are often suffering greatly on the inside. Some of them manage to heal themselves with therapy and loving supportive relationships, but a great many don't. Which is why cycles of trauma unfortunately get passed on.
- winwang 2y agoCan anecdotally confirm as a data point myself along with some people I know. Certainly, I can be viewed as stereotypically successful by my buddies. Certainly, because the mask we wear should be strong and never come off. But in my nights alone, or even in my therapy sessions, who could possibly see that 'me'? I have come to realize, though, that most people who didn't suffer much, refuse (implicitly, not explicitly) to empathize with those who have -- perhaps even I may be included in this group which 'refuse implicitly' at time. It's not that big of a deal, though. (Generalized) Empathy is a difficult skill to train.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- crowcroft 2y agoThis is extreme survivorship bias. The way you say 'look at all the people' implies that a lot of people survived and had good lives, but this needs to be weighed against the number of people total that entered concentration camps to know if this is actually a meaningful number of people to validate your assertion or not. My guess is that someone who went into a concentration camp were much less likely to live a life worth living than people who did not simply because a large number of them lived a life of torture and then death.
- naming_the_user 2y agoIt's as simple and as difficult as you want it to be really. The main thing is that people have to learn that, paraphrased for brevity, life in the "ends" requires a different set of skills to life in the more civilised parts of society. You have to relearn how to function. Some don't.
- LouisSayers 2y ago> They learn that life is completely unpredictable As someone with pretty much the upbringing you described, I don't think this was the takeaway. For me personally, I learnt adaptability, how to adjust to new situations and people quickly. I saw what my parents did and said "I don't want to be like that". The downside is, it's hard to answer "where are you from?", or to know where home is, and it's especially frustrating as an adult to see your parents continue to make bad decisions, to continue to be broke etc. I know everyone is different, but anecdotally my sister and brother also seem to be doing relatively well.
- em-bee 2y agoi also had a lot of that (except for the bad decisions and lack of planning) and i also became adaptable. what i didn't learn was attachment. and it took me decades of my adult life to understand that, realize how it affects me, where it came from, and i still don't know what to do about it. my brother on the other hand suffered from depression. despite being very similar in age and thus similar experience the outcome was very different.
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoDid you have a counter-example in the nearer family?
- romeros 2y agoFacing adversity when one is young is important. Elon Musk faced it a lot and so did Arnold Schwarzenegger. Both of them credit it for building resilience in them. But again it will back fire if there is too much adversity / trauma. In fact in one of the interviews Elon talks about implementing structured adversity.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoElon Musk is no posterchild for someone who has experienced adversity nor is he an example of good parenting.
- create-username 2y agoYeah. No advice and ignorance is better than certain advice
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoI'm amazed that people still fall for the PR stories from Elom.