3 ms·
Anyone in the world with an internet connection can view, interact with, and download the British Museum’s 3D scan of the Rosetta Stone, for example. The public
by mmooss 2y ago
Anyone in the world with an internet connection can view, interact with, and download the British Museum’s 3D scan of the Rosetta Stone, for example. The public can freely access hundreds of scans of classical sculpture from the National Gallery of Denmark, and visitors to the Smithsonian’s website can view, navigate, and freely download thousands of high-quality scans of artifacts ranging from dinosaur fossils to the Apollo 11 space capsule.
Has anyone used these in games? They would be great easter eggs and they have artistry and design that is far beyond almost anything DIY.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoPotentially cooler than The Teapot, though there are also other considerations I guess...
- diggan 2y ago> Has anyone used these in games? No doubt someone has put some of them into games. However, most likely not in it's original shape/form, as the scans usually produce highly inefficiently (but high resolution, great for renders) meshes. The meshes from scans tend to be a mess, and when inserting a 3D model for games, you care a lot about how optimized the meshes are, and that the mesh has a low polygon count as otherwise you'll tank the performance quickly. So since a developer couldn't just copy-paste the model into the game (requires a prepass to fix issues/optimize before import), it'll take valuable time from other things for just this easter egg. Again, no doubt someone has done this at one point or another, but that's probably why it isn't as common as someone could think. As an example, take a look at the wireframe of the Rosetta Stone (https://i.imgur.com/rtpiwjZ.png https://i.imgur.com/rtpiwjZ.png | https://github.com/BritishMuseumDH/rosettaStone/blob/master/models/stone.stl https://github.com/BritishMuseumDH/rosettaStone/blob/master/...) and you'll see what I mean. For a high quality rock-like object, you'd probably aim for 2000-5000 triangles, while the Rosetta Stone scan seems to have 480,000 triangles straight from the scanning software. Sadly, it's simply too much detail to be able to import straight up. Luckily, Nanite ("Virtualized Geometry") and similar implementations starts to give us tools so we can stop caring about things like this and let the game engine optimize stuff on the fly.
- permo-w 2y agoso it wouldn't be easy because these scans are highly detailed and so would require too many polygons to be loaded at once would this remain true for modern higher end graphics cards?
- diggan 2y ago> but you have to compress the scan A bit simplified but yeah. In the industry I think it's commonly referred to as "cleaning up the topology" or "simplifying the topology" where "topology" is the structure of the mesh essentially. You'd put the scan/model through something like this: https://sketchfab.com/blogs/community/retopologise-3d-scans-low-poly-game-assets/ https://sketchfab.com/blogs/community/retopologise-3d-scans-... > is this true with top spec machines too? Games frequently feature 100s (sometimes 1000s) of models at the same time, so the optimization of each model is important. Take a look at the launch of Cities Skylines 2 for an example of a game that launched without properly optimized 3D models, the performance was absolutely abysmal because the human/resident models were way more detailed than justified for a city simulation game.
- AlunAlun 2y agoFor rendering an individual piece, maybe not; but as part of much larger scene with many objects, animation, and rendering effects, it would place an unnecessary burden on the GPU. It would be much easier to simply have a 3D artist create the object anew from scratch, in a format and resolution that best fits the game.
- tomooot 2y agoEven modern high end graphics cards use abstractions of the base data to create vast amounts of the final output's fine detail. For example tessellation and other techniques used for complex geometry like compound curves, which allow millions or billions of polygons can be visually simulated without needing to be present as polygon data, increasing opportunity for processing parallelization, while reducing load on communication busses and VRAM. As an example, you could probably represent something like the grip of this FLIR camera in a couple hundred polygons and surface/curve definitions to help the rendering engine tesselate correctly. On the other hand, this overall scan is 357000 vertexes. Sure you can simplify it and bake a bunch of the texture into a normal map, but that then requires manually reworking the texture map and various other postprocessing steps to avoid creating a glitchy mess. https://i.imgur.com/aAwoiXU.png https://i.imgur.com/aAwoiXU.png
- Tarq0n 2y agoPath of Exile has some fountains and sculptures in it that are based on publicaly available scans iirc. Edit: best source I can find on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPy74M9FNpY&t=690s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPy74M9FNpY&t=690s and here's one from the Louvre: https://www.reddit.com/r/pathofexile/comments/8b6f54/nice_detail_in_oriath_four_captives_louvre_museum/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pathofexile/comments/8b6f54/nice_de...
- mmooss 2y agoThe Louvre sculture is the sort of thing I mean. Wow.
- doctorpangloss 2y agoThe kind of person who’s good at making games and is excited about ancient artifacts makes their own 3D assets that make the most sense for their game.
- mmooss 2y ago> excited about ancient artifacts It depends what you mean: If you mean, they like the idea of 'ancient' and 'artifacts', they may make up their own. If they like the actual history, then the whole point of the ancient artificats in the museums is that they are actual things from actual ancient civilizations - making something up would defeat the purpose. Also, as I said, almost certainly they lack the artistry to match what's in the museum, simply because what's in the museum is often the pinnacle of human creativity over millenia.
- h1fra 2y agoRosetta Stone is an item in Animal Crossing, it's very similar to the original I wonder if they used the model as starting point. https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/Informative_statue?file=NH-Statue_Informative_Genuine.jpg https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/Informative_statue?fi...
- m463 2y agoThis makes me think about old racing games. (Maybe it was Gran Turismo?) I remember the racing games had likenesses of some major manufacturer cars, but I believe the license terms said that the cars could not look bad. So not show crash damage, modification, etc.. Basically, the license terms protected the brand. Now what if you put some country's national/cultural artifacts in a game... then let them get weapon or explosive damage? Something to think about.
- creativenolo 2y agoThe British museums license at least is creative commons non-commercial which would likely prevent them being used as something insignificant like easter egg as a license would need to be acquired.