2 ms·
How is it not about whether you can "resell a book you bought abroad"? Afaict, the rightsholders here aren't arguing that there is a dollar threshold or level o
by _delirium 14y ago
How is it not about whether you can "resell a book you bought abroad"? Afaict, the rightsholders here aren't arguing that there is a dollar threshold or level of commercial organization he exceeded that turned it into parallel importation, or that it's the importation that's illegal. Rather, they argue that any sale of their book in a jurisdiction where they didn't authorize its sale is illegal. So, even someone who moved would need the copyright holder's authorization to sell their personal book collection, if it included any books that had not already been authorized for sale in the United States.
The European approach, despite being more restrictive in a way, makes more logical sense to me, since it separates legality of importation from legality of sale. Thus customs can hassle you if you're importing a bunch of stuff in violation of the state's trade policies, but if you've legally imported a book (e.g. as a personal effect), you can resell it.
- tptacek 14y agoFirst, I think we agree about what's happening and how things should shake out. Secondly, I knew I wasn't going to navigate the semantic waters of "reselling" vs. "importation" and had hoped that describing a 1.2MM/yr business of importing textbooks would illustrate the distinction. The trouble, as I see it, is that a lower court found recourse to halt a parallel import practice in the contours of the First Sale doctrine, rather than simply applying straightforward import law. Since that lower court's interpretation of First Sale has far-reaching and (probably) unwanted consequences, it's hitting SCOTUS. The trouble I have with the Techdirt piece, I mean besides the fact that it explains none of these complexities, is that it once again paints a genuinely interesting legal dispute as yet another effort by "MAFIAA" (or whatever we're calling it these days) to sieze the pillowcases of the American consumer on the auspices of having copyrighted the color blue. That's not at all what's happening here. Fair warning: I did a lot of reading on this, but the armature of my understanding of this case comes from two other HN commenters who batted this back and forth a few weeks ago.
- ericingram 14y agoThe detail you add here is interesting, but not substantial to the point Techdirt is making. Regardless of how much money this guy made by parallel importing, no one should have the ability to control the sale or distribution of physical property rightfully owned by someone else. He did not steal the property before re-selling it (did he?) -- so your point adds no critical dimension to the problem at hand. Unless of course you believe that some times some people should be able to control others' physical property, you know, for the good of us all, of course.