3 ms·
Besides the hyperbole of the title, this article is flawed in that products sold within the US must comply with US law. If a copyright holder hasn't given permi
by briandear 14y ago
Besides the hyperbole of the title, this article is flawed in that products sold within the US must comply with US law. If a copyright holder hasn't given permission for usage of their copyright in a specific country or territory, than products bearing that copyright can't be sold within that country. Otherwise, copyright would offer no protection since I would simply have to set up a factory in Mexico and I could infringe all I wanted and then sell those products in the US with impunity.
These are the same laws that prevent counterfeiting. If I own a copyright or a trademark for something I created, then how is it fair to me that my work be stolen? For example, if I record a great song and spend thousands of dollars in the studio, how is it fair that others can profit from that work without me getting compensated?
Don't misunderstand, I'm not talking about fair use, I am talking about people receiving money (i.e. commercial gain) by stealing the labors of others. That's straight up theft.
- _delirium 14y agoWhat IP holders are arguing here is considerably stronger: that I need their permission to sell a product in a country even if it is a legitimate, non-ripoff product that I myself own. This is not about unlicensed, counterfeit products, as in your Mexico hypothetical, but about licensed products that were produced with authorization of the rightsholder and then legally purchased. The question is if, once that purchase has taken place, the new owner needs to go back and get permission a second time from the rightsholder if they want to do something with their property. IP holders are arguing that if I buy a Nike shoe in Japan, and then want to sell it on eBay in the United States, I need Nike's permission, because they never licensed me to distribute their trademarked shoe in the USA. But I own the shoe! And it's a genuine Nike shoe, not a ripoff! They licensed its production, then authorized its sale to me, and at this point the shoe should be my property, and they should not be in the picture anymore. This is essentially in non-book form what the first-sale doctrine put an end to in books: the rightsholder trying to control resale of the goods for their entire lifetime, past the initial sale. Which of course makes a mockery of the idea of "property". If I can't sell my shoes without getting permission of the shoemaker, I "own" my shoes in a sense considerably weaker than the traditional definition of property.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- antiterra 14y ago> This is essentially in non-book form what the first-sale doctrine put an end to in books: The case SCOTUS will rule on, Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley actually is "in book form." Also, be careful to not mix up trademark and copyright. Omega v. Costco occured because "the watches included a small copyrighted design on the back surface."[1] The cases were not based around an argument that involved trademark at all, only copyright. [1] http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2010/12/supreme-court-does-not-decide-costco-v-omega-intl-exhaustion-case.html http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2010/12/supreme-court-does-n...
- antiterra 14y agoI believe you have misunderstood the issue at hand. There is no straight up theft in going to the UK, buying a book published under contract with the author in the airport store, reading it on the plane back the US and selling it on Amazon. That is the sort of case that we're talking about here, works whose creation do not violate the laws of the US but which are not produced under US jurisdiction.