3 ms·
I think a relevant gap you may be underestimating is "if you finish your solder job and it just doesn't work, what now"? Just getting some melted metal onto a
by esrauch 2y ago
I think a relevant gap you may be underestimating is "if you finish your solder job and it just doesn't work, what now"?
Just getting some melted metal onto a thing is really ~none of the skill cap that makes it "scary", when it inevitably doesn't work, the skill involved in debugging it, fixing the issue (desoldering), identifying if you fried other small cheap components that may need to be replaced, that's really the part that makes soldering a scary skill.
FWIW I think this is an example of a broader class of "being a beginner is much harder than knowledgeable people think"; if you're skilled then you also actually don't make nearly as many basic mistakes to begin including the connection being bad, accidentally shorting, wrong polarity, wrong sized component, and you'll recognize something might be problematic right when it happens. That means you don't even need to do noideadog debugging when a beginner must.
You can probably imagine doing "carefully solder and just fail the project if it still doesn't work at the end" being a strategy that would have a pretty good success rate, when it would actually have a dismal project success rate for an actual beginner.
- bigfishrunning 2y agoAll of those knowledgeable people were beginners once, made those mistakes, and came out the other side as knowledgeable people. You'll never do anything if you don't start somewhere. This is a fairly simple electronics project, with relatively easy soldering.
- 0xEF 2y agoI am not sure what gap you mean, since troubleshooting is part of the learning process. If someone expects to always get it right the first time, they are a bad student. Problem solving is relevant to all learning.
- esrauch 2y agoWhat I meant is that the comment said that you can learn soldering in a weekend and described only the physical aspect of getting solder onto some components. I spent a number of weekends trying to get any intuition over basic circuitry components and how you might debug things and got basically nowhere. I can put some hot metal on stuff but it's not useful if you can't debug and the knowledge needed to debug isn't remotely obtainable in a weekend.