4 ms·
Let's not be calling these people "militias" as that word gives them a tiny veneer of legitimacy. These are armed thugs at worst and mentally ill army cosplayer
by ryandrake 2y ago
Let's not be calling these people "militias" as that word gives them a tiny veneer of legitimacy. These are armed thugs at worst and mentally ill army cosplayers at best.
Something tells me that if this were in the city instead of the countryside, and the people threatening violence were not white, they'd just be called "gangs" like usual.
- diggan 2y agoWhat is the difference between militia/gangs/armed thugs/military? As far as I know, militias tend to be ex-military/military-affiliated people acting outside of the official arms of the government or even the law, gangs are just organized armed thugs, and the military is the armed thugs that are officially designated as being the armed thugs protecting the country. Who cares what they're called? Feels much more important to focus on their actions and motivations, which seems to be against helping their own people.
- ryandrake 2y agoWell, the difference between the actual military and all these other groups is that the military is organized under the Constitution (specifically Article I, Section 8), whereas the other groups are not. There really doesn't seem to be any meaningful difference between a militia and a gang. They're exactly the same: organized for some (usually unlawful) purpose, armed, dangerous, some form of leadership, pursuing their goals through violence or threats of violence. Very little difference between the Oath Keepers and the Crips.
- josefritzishere 2y agoI dont think this samantic argument is adding anything to the convo.
- unsnap_biceps 2y ago> which seems to be against helping their own people. The twist is they honestly believe they are helping their own people. They are convinced FEMA is a private police force working for Biden and FEMA's aid is rounding up republicans to put into camps and by signing up for FEMA aid, you are signing over your house and personal property. And with social media fanning the flames, it's a very tense environment and can get bloody quite fast if two wrong groups run into each other at the worst possible time :(
- krapp 2y agoMilitias are legal and existentially necessary for a free state per the Second Amendment, whereas gangs and armed thugs are not. Semantics? In terms of the way these groups are seen by the public, covered by the media and treated by the government, yes. If they're white and Republican, they're probably a militia. Otherwise they're terrorists, thugs and gangsters. If they're black, toss in "Marxists" as well.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoThat depends. What are they doing? Are they stealing, looting, or racketeering? -> gang Are they trying to protect property from these activities, or guard people as they engage in recovery activities? -> militia Labels aside, the whole story is nonsense: > The North Carolina National Guard told CBS News in a statement on Monday that it had "no reports of our soldiers or airmen encountering any armed militia, any threats and any type of combatants. We are continuing to serve all those counties in need of our assistance." > ... > "The initial report stated there was a truck load of militia that was involved," the sheriff's office said. "However, after further investigation, it was determined Parsons acted alone and there were no truck loads of militia going to Lake Lure." So not a gang and not a militia... One guy. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fema-crews-relocate-reported-threats-armed-militia-hurricane-helene-relief/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fema-crews-relocate-reported-th...
- kcplate 2y agoNC is an open carry state and firearms are not uncommon to be seen on a normal day. In the western side of the state, you should pretty assume that every resident is armed, because it’s just the way of the area. In a disaster torn area in that part of the state you should pretty much assume that everyone is well armed, but well armed doesn’t necessary mean that they have nefarious intentions, it might just mean they are letting people with nefarious intentions know it’s probably a good idea to behave. Who knows what the real story actually is—I don’t trust the WaPo to provide proper context here. DC culture and opinion is not Western North Carolina culture and opinion. They are writing for a wholly different audience.