5 ms·
Facebook simply doesn't have an ethical central core. They've shown over and over that when user privacy or security conflict with facebook's goals, they'll cho
by SwellJoe 14y ago
Facebook simply doesn't have an ethical central core. They've shown over and over that when user privacy or security conflict with facebook's goals, they'll choose facebook over the user. It's always relatively subtle; they strive to only do what they can get away with...but it's always pushing the line, and is never based on trying to do what's right, merely avoiding backlash. Facebook, the company, is kind of a sociopath.
I wish it weren't this way. I have several friends within facebook whom I like and respect, and they produce a lot of great technology. But, I fear facebook having more power than they already have. It can only end badly for the user.
Facebook really needs a "don't be evil" moment, but I suspect it's too late, and I suspect that Zuckerberg simply doesn't think that way.
- carsongross 14y agoThe "don't be evil" moment will be when people really start pulling the plug en masse. I mean the advertisers.
- SwellJoe 14y agoI don't advertise my company with facebook, for this very reason. I'm sure there are other people out there who feel this way. I spend about $1500 a month with Google, because they're trying not to be evil (even if they fail at the attempt sometimes). Not big money, by any means, but if a few thousand companies are opting to not advertise with facebook because they're kinda evil, it could start to be real money.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThat's not a don't be evil moment, that's continuing to act in a self interested way, just circumstances changing what is in your best interest.
- orijing 14y agoCan you elaborate on why you think in this specific case user privacy or security conflict with Facebook's goals?
- SwellJoe 14y agoIt seems obvious, to me, but I guess I'll spell it out: Facebook wants access to your email so badly that they're willing to steal it. This is, in my opinion, among the worst things they've ever done for user privacy (and security, but mostly privacy in this case), in a long list of subtle, and not-so-subtle tactics. It also has very real security consequences. The automatic contact list updates for potentially millions of users means that sensitive information is likely flowing into facebook servers as we speak, without users knowing it. Passwords, medical information, company secrets, who knows what else? Someone who trusts facebook enough to use it for social interactions might not trust them enough to know about their medical conditions, proprietary company data, passwords for other sites, etc. Facebook took away that privilege for many people with this change. All that said, here's what's important: This does nothing good for users, and a few bad things. The fact that facebook made this change, knowing that the vast majority of users were not interested in using facebook email thus far, tells us that facebook thinks first of facebook. Even if there were no privacy or security concerns, what the user wants wasn't even in the equation, when facebook did the math on this.
- tedunangst 14y agopasswords for other sites Wait, seriously? People are using websites where the password reset emails are being sent from somebody's Droid phone? I think you've gotten a little carried away.
- thezilch 14y agoEver seen sites with the ability to connect via Facebook? It often grants said site(s) with the user's Facebook primary-email. Now all personal emails, including password recoveries, are going through Facebook for said site(s).
- tedunangst 14y agoI'm having a hard time imagining a scenario where a site would send some information via email but that same information would not be available to anyone logging in via the web interface. But whatever.
- Splines 14y ago> I have several friends within facebook whom I like and respect, and they produce a lot of great technology. I find this idea interesting. Can an entity like a corporation have a life beyond that which is given to it by its employees? Like the ship of theseus, can you replace all employees and still have a business that "feels" the same?
- AceJohnny2 14y agoWhy not? http://www.scribd.com/doc/73492989/Stephenson-1966-Cultural-Acquisition-of-a-Specific-Learned-Response-Among-Rhesus-Monkeys http://www.scribd.com/doc/73492989/Stephenson-1966-Cultural-...
- Heinleinian 14y agoOf course. Work with any government bureaucracy and you'll notice it pretty quickly. Entire divisions can be filled with good, bright, well-meaning people, yet that division can still churn out crap work product. How is that? An organization's culture and the way incentives are aligned can quickly override any pockets of talented individuals.
- Splines 14y agoSo the obvious question is: How does one change this from the inside? Does the plan of attack differ if you were a line worker versus a VP?
- polynomial 14y agoTherein lies the difference between a company and a quality company.
- alttab 14y agoSounds like they just tried to steal a huge network of e-mail addresses and run it through their infrastructure. To me, this is essentially theft.
- BadLogInMyAss 14y agoWhy do you think they have this bullshit policy: http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/forcing-people-to-use-e-mail-address-as.html http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/forcing-people-to-use...