3 ms·
I seriously doubt he was an idiot. But his thinking was constrained by what was known at the time and what was commonly thought to be true. Our modern thinking
by WalterBright 2y ago
I seriously doubt he was an idiot. But his thinking was constrained by what was known at the time and what was commonly thought to be true.
Our modern thinking is also constrained by similar misjudgments, we just like to think we're smarter than that. 500 years hence, people will laugh at our idiocy.
- cryptonector 2y agoKnowledgeable Europeans knew that the Earth was round and they knew its size to within a few percent. Columbus thought that the Earth was much smaller though, and in that belief "he was an idiot". It's quite possible that he was trying to make an impossible voyage seem possible, but then again, he didn't take enough provisions, and it was almost a total loss.
- jjk166 2y agoThis is not accurate. Everyone knew the Earth was round and had a good knowledge of the Earth's circumference, as this can be determined with geometry and some basic measurements. What was not well known at the time was the size of Asia, and specifically the distance from Asia's eastern coastline to Japan's easternmost islands, due to the lack of surveying data. Columbus grossly overestimated the size of Asia such that Japan would be approximately where North America actually is.
- samastur 2y agoI don't think it will take 500 years.
- Affric 2y agoOther people brought the receipts. He fully just wishfully thought the earth was smaller. He continued to refused he hadn’t landed in the indies for the rest of his life. Idiot was a strong word. But not as brief.
- SapporoChris 2y agoActually, "On the other hand, in a document in the Book of Privileges (1502), Columbus refers to the New World as the Indias Occidentales ('West Indies'), which he says "were unknown to all the world".[284]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Columbus#Legacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Columbus#Legacy So, it seems at some points he made claims he had a route to the orient and later he referred to it as 'West Indies'. Perhaps he knew the truth all along but had reasons to mislead.
- cryptonector 2y agoHe might have felt the need to understate the journey in order to get it funded at all.
- lazide 2y agoEh, it would be like insisting the moon was made of cheese and in low earth orbit - and somehow getting someone to sponsor your (literal moonshot) - and then somehow reaching it in it’s real place, finding out it was made of gold instead, and then bringing a ton back. Which single-handedly started a space race which led to colonizing the moon (and, uh, mostly exterminating the indigenous population which was totally different than the folks who were supposed to be there in the first place). Oh, except it was also a completely different moon that we somehow weren’t aware was there. Nothing he was proposing should have worked, and yet somehow not only did it, but it made everyone (who funded it) fabulously rich beyond their wildest imaginings. Idiot savant?
- WalterBright 2y agoMany otherwise intelligent people hold on to an idiotic idea, especially when it's to their advantage to hold on to it. In fact, probably all of us do this.
- lazide 2y agoNotably, he would have died out there if it hadn’t, somehow, worked out. Truth really is stranger than fiction.
- Affric 2y agoYes! I started typing up a moon comparison and half way through gave up because it just sounded so insane. Thanks for this.