4 ms·
You know your value system sucks when the question "does it matter where you go to college?" is automatically assumed to be about salary.
by keiferski 14y ago
You know your value system sucks when the question "does it matter where you go to college?" is automatically assumed to be about salary.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoWhat metrics would you use to determine quality of education? (I assume, like me, this is what you were hoping this article would be about.)
- keiferski 14y agoHmm, well off the top of my head: - Affordability. Not necessarily low prices, but reasonable prices. - Quality of education, in terms of teaching skill, breadth of courses offered, and the like - Strength of student community (clubs, etc.) - Location of the school (rural schools bore me) - Background of students (I like schools with students from the world over) - Location of students post graduation. I dislike schools where most of the graduates never leave the area.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoThat wasn't quite what I was meaning! :-) What I was really meaning is, what metrics would you use to determine the quality of teaching not necessarily just the overall quality of experience?
- keiferski 14y agoHmm that's a tougher question. The big thing in my mind is having a sincere interest in the subject and the charismatic ability to get students interested in it. Most professors don't really give a shit whether their students like the subject. Also, the willingness to go beyond bureacratic systems in the name of intellectual interest. In other words, talking about X because your students are fascinated by it, not sticking to the curriculum 100% of the time and talking about Y. Sorry for bad sentence form, on my phone.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoPerhaps I should further qualify the question, and this is how I possibly should have phrased it in the beginning: how do you determine quality of teaching before enrolling?
- keiferski 14y agoWell I suppose you could ask the people already there and see what they have to say. Along with visiting and the usual stuff. Otherwise, what can you do?
- kintamanimatt 14y agoI think it's an interesting question in many respects. Those that are there already might not have the necessary experience and knowledge to correctly determine the quality of education being offered. I assume education's like headphones: if you've never had headphones before it's hard to know whether the ones you have suck, unless you've had the opportunity to experience many others kinds.
- jerf 14y agoYou sound like you either have one, or have transcended the need for one. Try not doing either of those things. I too used to sing along in happy harmony with the "it doesn't really matter, follow your bliss". Now I'm 33 and my high school circles are filled with people who have wrecked their financial lives on the shoals of that advice. Now I know I was singing with the sirens. It was already screwed up 15 years ago, as my high school circles can attest to. It's more screwed up now, but now people are seeing how messed up it is. Money matters, especially when accruing lots of debt. It isn't the only thing that matters, but it most assuredly matters. Don't keep singing with the sirens.
- keiferski 14y agoMaximizing income and minimizing debt are not the same thing.
- jerf 14y agoHa! People should be so lucky as to be worried about "maximizing income". We're in an era in which people need to be careful just to balance their income with their college debt. Stop moralizing and think. Millions of people are hurting out there. It's time to put away the gibberish about how it's somehow uncouth to think about money as you think about college. We now know that line of thought is profoundly damaging. If you don't agree... how much more evidence would you need?
- keiferski 14y agoYou're missing my point. Making a decision to go to X school because it will make you more money is fundamentally a different decision than going to Y school because it's cheaper. You may have to get the higher debt to get the higher paying job, but going to the lower debt school is probably good enough to make a decent income.
- keiferski 14y agoUmm? If you go to the cheaper school, you won't be crushed by debt, even though you may make less money in your lifetime. This is what the article was about... I really don't understand what you're arguing for here, Jerf. The article posed a question: is going to the better school worth the debt? You seem to be saying yes, you should focus on the monetary aspects, while simultaneously decrying student debt. What are you arguing?
- crazygringo 14y agoProblem is, what else can you measure numerically? If you can come up with a single, simple-to-calculate, unambiguous, measurement of happiness or fulfillment we could use instead... please share it with us! At least salary gives a basic idea of how much your skills are worth to other people in the free market, which is better than nothing, though it may not be very correlated with how happy that makes you...
- zethraeus 14y agoIt's a pretty useful abstraction. Would you rather measure dopamine levels? (Because there are some good hacks for that one too). Seriously though, given that an increased earning potential is the big rational reason to go to college, how else should it be measured? If you're criticizing the current paradigm for valuing college, or even for valuing life, those are significantly bigger societal issues than a one liner does justice.
- keiferski 14y agoIncreased earning potential is not the big rational reason to go to college. Our society seems to function that way presently, but some people actually do enjoy learning.