4 ms·
I'm imagining a "secure slate" you can carry between the computers, a tiny tablet with a camera, e-ink display, and replaceable batteries. It does nothing but s
by Terr_ 2y ago
I'm imagining a "secure slate" you can carry between the computers, a tiny tablet with a camera, e-ink display, and replaceable batteries. It does nothing but snap a picture of a QR code and then (if error checking is OK) reproduces it on its own durable display. Add a write-protection switch that doubles as a cover on the camera-lens, and have it auto-blank when not in use.
So you'd snapshot its QR code, hand-carry the slate to air-gapped Computer B, press a button to wake it up, brandish the "copied" QR code in front of B's camera, etc. Maybe even take one and (with careful labeling) put it into a safe, depending on how long you plan to store it.
You could do something similar with a camera and thermal-paper printer, but then the physical artifact needs to be reliably destroyed by manual effort, as opposed to auto-erasure.
- itishappy 2y agoIt'd only take about 1000 QR codes to install vim!
- Terr_ 2y agoExcept low-bandwidth here is a feature, not a bug. ... Plus one more QR code to quit vi(m) when it's accidentally launched.
- therein 2y agoNot a small number even for BBQr. https://github.com/coinkite/BBQr https://github.com/coinkite/BBQr
- vlovich123 2y agoYour air gapped machine would be generating the QR codes not ingesting them.
- zmgsabst 2y agoThere’s scanners at 100+ pages per minute and you can fit a (half) dozen maxed out QRs per page. I’m okay with it taking a minute or two to install software on a high security system, eg, the root cryptography for our military radios. …maybe I should get into the business of “paper drives”.
- pontifier 2y agoFor longer term storage use an analog camera to take pictures of the QR codes, then develop the film and store them in an airtight climate controlled vault. Bonus points if the film is designed to be very stable after developing. Maybe platinum prints with lots of error correction.
- thinkmassive 2y agoHere’s some similar devices that already exist: https://seedsigner.com/ https://seedsigner.com/ https://foundation.xyz/passport/ https://foundation.xyz/passport/ https://store.blockstream.com/products/blockstream-jade-hardware-wallet-1 https://store.blockstream.com/products/blockstream-jade-hard...
- rblatz 2y agoWhy not just use a Polaroid camera?
- Terr_ 2y agoWell, the context is a facility where security must be so tight that you're air-gapping computers in the first place, so a lot of the same reasons nobody would be permitted to bring their personal film-camera into the place either: You don't want to make it easy for people to take pictures of arbitrary things (faces, documents, whiteboards) and you don't want to always be searching everyone's underwear for instant-photos or film-canisters. In contrast, a worker can sign-out a hardened device, and when they return it on the way out you can be reasonably sure they couldn't have easily made copies. Plus the scanner won't capture arbitrary pictures in the first place, and it can be set to auto-wipe after X minutes of inactivity. If you give people 10 unexposed sheets and require them to return a total of 10 used/unused on the way out, that's susceptible to them smuggling in an unexposed sheet, and you're back to underwear searches again.
- miki123211 2y agoWith appropriate encryption between the two machines, the slate could even be a simple smartphone. It doesn't matter whether the smartphone is internet-connected or not, as the slate's contents wouldn't be of any use without hacking one of the machines, and if you could do that, you wouldn't need to hack the slate in the first place.